How do you PB&J

5speckledfrogs · September 2014

I just had my first pb&j in I don't know how long and I was wondering how others eat them.

5speckledfrogs · September 2014

I'm #2

huntjul · September 2014

And when done making it, put it in the toaster oven and toast it. It's been >5 years since I've eaten a PB&J, but I still remember how gooey and tasty the toasting makes them.

hlb622 · September 2014

#1 and DH will only eat it if the bread is toasted first.

cassey910 · September 2014

#1!! I love PB&J!!

countingthestars · September 2014

Ss. Not a huge jelly with peanut butter fan. Love a toasted peanut butter sandwich though.

Lee81 · September 2014

breadandbutter07 said:
SS: 2 slices, with peanut butter on both slices and jam (not jelly!) in the middle. My mom would make it this way for my school lunch because the PB on both slices kept the bread from getting soggy. I agree with @huntjul‌ that toasted is amazing.

Number one if eating right away. This if I'm making it ahead of time.

mancila60 · September 2014

SS: no jelly and no jam just peanut butter. 2 pieces of bread with peanut butter on both.

ksimo6 · September 2014

I'm number one... For about five weeks of my pregnancy, all I could keep down was pb&j. I made three a day and kept them in my purse. Classy.

Ajoyd · September 2014

Number one. Toasting the bread first is also an important step.

bkeane619 · September 2014

SS: I will only eat it on toast. Number one option on white bread is my biggest nightmare.

5speckledfrogs · September 2014

I've never had a toasTed pb&j. On my to-do..

megs1409 · September 2014

I do like a PB&J from time to time, but I also LOVE (and want to eat one right now) Peanut Butter & Fluff!!! But I think Fluff may be a New England thing??

jennlin · September 2014

Ss: one slice, pb on half, j or honey on the other, fold before eating.

Jenball717 · September 2014

I like my pbandj with a side of LOLZ.

5speckledfrogs · September 2014

megs1409 said:
I do like a PB&J from time to time, but I also LOVE (and want to eat one right now) Peanut Butter & Fluff!!! But I think Fluff may be a New England thing??

I used to do this! We called it a fluffer nutter

Lee81 · September 2014

5speckledfrogs said:

megs1409 said:
I do like a PB&J from time to time, but I also LOVE (and want to eat one right now) Peanut Butter & Fluff!!! But I think Fluff may be a New England thing??
I used to do this! We called it a fluffer nutter

Oh, yeah fluffernutters were good stuff. I don't know that it's a New England thing. We have fluff in PA.