I understand that we as the parents must make this name decision for ourselves,  but I love clicky polls and just curious of others thoughts on these 2 names.    
DH's grandfathers name was Gianni.  My great grandfather was from Italy and his name was Paul.    Not the most Italian name,  but that doesn't matter to me. 
DH does know a couple Pauls that he works with,  and he does not care for them,  so he isn't too keen on the Paul name.  
Matteo is just an Italian name that we both like,  not a family name. 
Our last name is 3 syllables and also ends in a vowel.                   
                Nov. '14 January Siggy : Work Sucks!
 
Me 32-DH 38
Married July 14, 2007  ----- TTC # 1 October 1, 2013
BFP   March 7, 2014  -----  EDD November 17, 2014 ---- Baby boy born November 16, 2014
        Baby Name Poll 121 votes
        
                            
                            
                            
                    They are both poo,  keep trying
                    
                                     
                            
                     
             
             
        
Re: Baby Name Poll
my happy boy
Nov. '14 January Siggy : Work Sucks!
Me 32-DH 38
Married July 14, 2007 ----- TTC # 1 October 1, 2013
BFP March 7, 2014 ----- EDD November 17, 2014 ---- Baby boy born November 16, 2014
I got lucky with first DD bc her middle name worked for both sides (my grandma and his mom).
Good luck! The name game was awful for me this pregnancy too!
N14 Nov. Siggy: CELEBRATION!