I am a godmother to my niece and my sister is my LO's godmother. It's not in our tradition to buy gifts for the godparents. The godparents get gifts for the baby but that's the only person that gets a gift.
We bought god parent gifts for fun at our showers. Alex and Ani godmother bracelet and then target actuall had a 'godfather' tshirt. (Had the movie cover and said something along the lines of 'call me the godfather')
We got ours a picture frame with a passage thanking them for being godparents engraved on it. I intend to take a picture with them and give it to them late to put in the frame.
Re: Godparents gifts