DS1 is almost 4 and he seems to go through spurts of several days in a row where he claims to have nightmares. I say "claims" because I'm never really sure that's what's going on. He wakes up and calls for one of us but isn't upset or crying. He wants someone to come sit with him and THEN he says he's "scared." I think most of the time he happened to wake up and then just wants us in there. I'm talking at 2 in the morning when the baby was already up at 1 and 4 or sumshit. DH always goes in the first time and sits with him but then we end up frustrated because he could keep it going for hours and we're torn between tough love (i.e. we've tried to sooth you for a half hour, nut up and go back to sleep lol) and feeling badly if he's genuinely upset. WDPD?
Formerly known as elmoali

Re: How do you guys handle "nightmares?"
We haven't dealt with them personally, but when I worked with kids and parents who dealt with it, I would advise them to speak in low soothing tones to calm the kid down at first.
Once the kid is calm, encourage them to lay back down and try to go back to sleep. Don't talk anymore. Rub their back or hand, sit there with them, but don't engage with them anymore. If they try to get back up or talk, just SShhh them and lay them back down. Once they realize that it's boring and it isn't going to be a fun interactive time, they should go back to sleep.
Maybe a book about how kids deal with nightmares so he can start to soothe himself...
https://www.lilsugar.com/Books-About-Nightmares-Kids-21768399
I'm thinking...I'm thinking...