The most important poll of the WEEK

Jenball717 · March 2014

Yup, I went there.
When it comes to ice cream, I am very specific. Not just any old pint will do. And, I am brand loyal. Is this common and if so, what brand?

bionicb · March 2014

Ben and Jerrys, then Tillamook, then Umpqua. Yum yum.

SuperSecretStatus · March 2014

Blue Bell makes the best ice cream.

Jenball717 · March 2014

SuperSecretStatus said:

Blue Bell makes the best ice cream.

Oops, that's what I meant instead of blue bunny. Too many ice cream brands! And I forgot the Edy's next to Dreyers. Oh well, I poll fail again.

bkeane619 · March 2014

Haagen Dazs gelato

beesquar3d · March 2014

Tillamook

Welshgirl12 · March 2014

I eat ice cream, any ice cream, all the ice cream, but not chocolate.

CousinVicki · March 2014

well breyers mint chocolate chip is the best. haagan daz makes good stuff too, obv. ben and jerrys froyo works when i want 'less calories' lol but, this amish place near me has the best homemade ice cream i have ever had in my entire life. ever.

as for retail type places, they just opened a Pinkberry near me and it's THE BEST!

kimbo1216 · March 2014

Blue Bell ftw. I feel sorry for those states that don't have it. :P

SuperSecretStatus · March 2014

@kimbo1216‌ I almost lost it when we first got here to NC and some lady in Walmart told me they didn't have Blue Bell. Fortunately the commissary had some, and the walmarts now sell it too.

Flutterby00 · March 2014

Blue bell Nom Nom nom. I voted blue bunny because I figured that's what you meant!

trackgirlparis · March 2014

Welshgirl12 said:

I eat ice cream, any ice cream, all the ice cream, but not chocolate.

All of this!

tashad18 · March 2014

For my basic vanilla and chocolate usually any brand will do.

However, we are big Blue Bell fans around here. One of my friend's husband's is high up in the Blue Bell company here, and we get free vouchers all the time. Plus he is always bringing ice cream cups to the kid's parties and play dates. It is awesome!

sarahcatie · March 2014

Stewarts, hands down!

StefMurph · March 2014

Blue Bell only! DH tried to buy the big tub o' yuck from Schwanns while I was pregnant and it got thrown in the trash.

acethebase · March 2014

Friendly's FTW!

jennlin · March 2014

I have no soul.

I don't hate it, it's just not something I really care about it. I'll eat it if it's presented..don't ever crave it. Any brand will do, though- you can call me an ice cream slut.

taylormarie923 · March 2014

Blue bell all day, son. Their new chocolate lovers is to die for.

ajjf1026 · March 2014

I love all ice cream, I'm slightly obsessed. Store brand, name brand, Dairy Queen, Coldstone, it doesn't matter. I love it all!!

jnsmith85 · March 2014

Yeah how was Blue Bell not on the list??? BEST ice cream eva.

mancila60 · March 2014

Blue Bell! We refuse to buy anything else and will always be brand loyal. It's getting really expensive but it's totally worth it.

carawasa · March 2014

acethebase said:
Friendly's FTW!

all of this. I love Newport creamy as well.

CatieG · March 2014

I put Breyer's/Dreyer's but it actually has to be Dreyer's Slow Churned. Breyer's is too watery for my taste!

HOWEVER, since we currently live in Europe again, I will gladly forgo my Fudge Tracks (among other flavors) and eat all the homemade Italian gelato I can stomach!

pandaglitter · March 2014

Tillamook's grandma's cake batter is the best ice cream ever in the world end of story.

hartsl01 · March 2014

I put as, not because you forgot but because I like several of those choices. Blue Bell is delish. We have a regional brand called Edy's that is amaze balls, plus my cousin works there so we get it cheap! And if nothing is on sale the meijer store brand is pretty good. Plus who doesn't love Cold Stone, cake batter with brownies and caramel... Mmm. I might have to make dh go get me some!

RedZee · March 2014

I voted 'store brand' because I'm more swayed by flavour than brand. BUT Trader Joe's ice cream is freaking A-MA-ZING. Maybe I should have voted SS.

norbert5 · March 2014

There is a local gelato place called Devine that so amazing I walked two miles in a hundred degree plus weather while 7 months pregnant to have some.

When I can't go there it is Ben and Jerry's chubby hubby. But tillamook's marionberry pie is a close 2nd.

elllaf · March 2014

Friendly's

But since that doesn't exist in Montana...
I voted B&J because it's my favorite to eat right out of the carton. Phish food ftw.
But I buy Breyers for when I make cobbler, fruit crisp etc.

jnsmith85 · March 2014

baconface said:
Wow, I've never heard of Blue Bell, but I will have to look for it.

@crunchymama11‌ Phish Food is my fave B&J flavor!

Where do you live? I could be wrong but I think Blue Bell is only sold in southern states for the most part? I know it's not sold in the New England area. (sucks for y'all!!)

Ursidae · March 2014

I have to throw Carvel into the mix..... Their cake batter ice cream is amazing.

& I love dip n dots

MangoMama82 · March 2014

@sarahcatie‌ have you been to Mt. Tom's Ice Cream? It's my weakness. I go there a little too often. It was the last thing I ate before I went into labor

carawasa · March 2014

jnsmith85 said:

baconface said:
Wow, I've never heard of Blue Bell, but I will have to look for it.

@crunchymama11‌ Phish Food is my fave B&J flavor!
Where do you live? I could be wrong but I think Blue Bell is only sold in southern states for the most part? I know it's not sold in the New England area. (sucks for y'all!!)

I have had blue bell a few times but in ri I'm pretty sure it's like 7$ For a gallon. I had one that was a 3 different types of coffee ice cream and then I died of the deliciousness.

Never mind it was blue bunny..

sfshorter · March 2014

Blue Bell = best store ice cream ever. I hate going to the shops and spending 15 bucks or more for three of us when I could get three gallons for that, but we love Marble Slab Double Dark Choc.

pmarie33 · March 2014

I don't see Baskin Robbins anywhere. Their chocolate peanut butter is so good. And of course Oreo.

tmccord21 · March 2014

Ben and Jerry's if I'm someplace that doesn't have fancy ice cream. But I prefer the good shit. Phin and Phebes (cinnamon), Steve's(strawberry ricotta), Van Leeuwen (earl grey).

MissLauraPants · March 2014

Bluebell

sarahcatie · March 2014

MangoMama82 said:

@sarahcatie‌ have you been to Mt. Tom's Ice Cream? It's my weakness. I go there a little too often. It was the last thing I ate before I went into labor

I have not! I'll have to try it next time I venture down to the valley!

Want a personalized experience?

The most important poll of the WEEK

The most important poll of the WEEK 157 votes

Re: The most important poll of the WEEK

Choose Another Board

Search Boards