I've used the Jergens one for years. I am very fair normally, so I like that it doesn't make me really dark and looks pretty natural. I got a spray tan once that was pretty dark and looked really unnatural on me.
I've only had self tanning fails. Although the Jergens one has been ok because it's more subtle. I got a professional spray tan and it was AWESOME. I couldn't stop checking myself out!
Re: NBR: Self Tanners...