We did cry-it-out with my daughter when she was about 11 months old which worked well for us. Since then she will typically go to bed without a problem, however we've had a few regressions here and there which has usually followed an illness or teething. The regressions were never too bad (maybe 10 minutes of crying) and typically takes us about a week to get her back on track when this happens, with crying getting gradually less as the week progresses. I don't know what happened, but about 2 weeks ago she started crying hysterically again to sleep. My husband and I have been standing strong as we usually do and have not gone into her room while she's crying. This time, however, instead of getting better, it's getting worse. One night she cried for 20 minutes, another a half hour and tonight a whole whopping 45 minutes. She's not sick or teething. She's happy when she wakes up and the whole day, until I put her down to bed. We've had the same consistent nightly routine since she's been about a year (bath, pajamas, book before bed). She seems tired as she's yawning before bed and will often yawn as she's crying. My husband thinks we should try going in the room and comforting her, however I'm scared to do this, as past experience this always seemed to make things worse and prolong the crying even further, which is why we resorted to CIO in the first place. I guess you should know her typical bedtime is 7pm to 7am, with a 1-2 hour nap at 12pm. Anybody else have this happen?


Re: 20 month sleep regression?!
I was going to post something like this today! DS usually goes down really easily after our bedtime routine. He'll talk in his crib for a bit and then fall asleep on his own. Last night he popped right back up after I laid him down and started crying immediately after I left the room. I went back in a couple times - we rocked for a bit, I tried laying next to his crib - but he thought that was really fun so I finally just had to let him cry it out. It is so hard! He only cried for 10 min but it felt like longer.
I think you did the right thing - with our little one, if we keep going in it just prolongs the crying and staying awake. Hopefully, it will get better and back to normal soon!
Baby #2!