Oops, I did not mean to be rude. I always ask all of my obnoxious questions here on TB, that I would not ask in real life. :-) I have an IUD and no longer get AF. I POAS from time to time to make sure I am not KU. Just been dreaming, I guess, about what it would be like if I found out I was, in fact pregnant. No harm or offense intended.
I didn't find it rude. I could have opted to not answer if I did.
Same. I didn't think it was too bad. The "too type A to be unplanned" kinda irked me though.
DS was unplanned, though I was taking BCP shipped into a Caribbean island on a container ship so it was likely heat damaged. I should have known it likely wasn't working right.
I can find it rude but still opt to answer. I guess I just found her qualifier obnoxious. She's so Type A that an unplanned pregnancy isn't in her realm? Pfft.
I have several friends that "don't TRY, but don't prevent".... Which is just a different approach for me. I used ovulation kits, charted, etc, so I feel it was "actively trying" as opposed to just "letting it happen". Again, I did not mean to offend.
I have one 'I'm 20 and fucking invincible!!!1!' baby, and one 'eh, we're in this for the long haul and BC is a pain in the ass so fuck it we'll take our chances' baby.
"Man, be creative. Like the stuff you do. Do nice things. Love respectfully. Laugh a fucking lot. Curse when you feel like it. Life is cool." - Jean Grae
Rosie was unplanned, thank you mini pill. I then had a "surprise" pregnancy. We NTNP, but we weren't thinking about having babies. So it came as a surprise when I got a positive 6 months into it. Cade was completely 100% planned.
I do feel like it's a rude question to ask IRL, but I don't think it's that rude on here because people are pretty anonymous and they can choose to not answer.
Any question about family planning, including, "so, are you trying for #2 now," is rude to me IRL because that's really personal. DH and I are trying, but I've had 2 losses, and I don't really feel like sharing that with some random person at work. Or like my SIL who tried for 8 years without ever getting pregnant. That can be heartbreaking, and it's just not the kind of thing you bring up with someone who's not super close.
Both were planned. I have PCOS DS took 2 years and with DD it was taking so long (4yr) the doc said to forget about it because it wasn't gonna happen. When it did happen we were like "no f'ing way!" But in a good way.
I've also had lots of people ask me this, I just don't get why.
I never ask any family planning questions in real life because you never know someone's situation. But I don't see why it's a big deal on a message board. No one is being put on the spot.
The type A thing was a bit weird because type A can't prevent bc failure. My most type A friend had an unplanned baby.
I don't think it's rude to ask on a message board. But when you add the qualifier "I'm type A so I've had all planned pregnancies" then yeah, it gets a little rude.
I get this but I didn't read the OP that way. I read it more like, bc she's type A, she went full-guns on planning it like opks, temps, charting etc. Not that she was saying the type A-ness made her not a candidate for unplanned pg. I don't know if that makes sense.
Mine was planned in a way. We had the discussion of trying the next cycle decided to throw caution to the wind one time and I got pregnant.
We were asked a lot if she was planned by family and friends. It always bothered us, but we figured it was because we weren't married and he used to say he didn't want children.
Dd and this one were planned. But it took a while for both of them. Over the last year I have had so many people, mostly family, ask if we would have more. I started just telling people we dont get pregnant easily. That usually stops the questions.
I think our problem with the question was that it usually followed the automatic assumption that she wasn't planned. It was mostly "so were you surprised?"
My first son wasn't planned but we weren't using protection. I had been told a few years ago that I couldn't get pregnant without assistance. So we were open to a pregnancy but not expecting it to happen.
My current pregnancy was 100% unplanned and prevented, but clearly life has other plans for me.
First time we definitely were planning/trying . Sadly it resulted in a loss.
4 months later we were "not trying, not preventing." I remeber saying to H that we should stop trying for a bit and wait. 2 weeks later BFP. 《and it was wonderful!》
“Some people live more in 20 years than others do in 80. It’s not the time that matters, it’s the person.” — The Doctor, Season 3, Episode 6
Ours was planned and we were lucky enough that the plan worked the first time. I do get why some people think its a rude question though.
We got engaged after 7 months, with a 5 month engagement, and got pregnant 3 months after we were married. Apparently some of my friends and family are awful at math and think it was all 'a mistake'. It's annoying enough that people assume we only got married because we were pregnant by accident and that's not even the case here. I can't imagine how pissed off I'd be about some of the comments I've heard if that were actually the case.
I don't like to be told to unclench. Family planning questions are personal. It can be perceived as rude when a certain someone asks about it IRL and I'm allowed to be annoyed when someone oversteps a line. Eta I'm talking about people IRL. I'm not annoyed at the OPs question.
It takes a special amount of bitch to induce menstruation in another person. - LovelyRitaMeterMaid
All 3 of mine were planned. I would have loved a surprise 3rd baby back when we were still debating on having a third. I am terrified at the thought of having a surprise 4th, so DH just got a vasectomy.
Unplanned. BC failure. But very much wanted. My biggest fear in life was not being able to have children.
The question doesn't offend me. There are a lot weirder questions asked on TB. If it was someone I didn't know well IRL it would be weird. But most people know he was unplanned because we were only dating four months. When I got pg.
Harry Styles = Life Ruiner
There’s a lightningin your eyes I can't deny Then there’s me inside a sinkingboat running out of time Without you I'll never make it out alive But I know, yes, I know we’ll be alright
I don't think it's a big deal on TB or IRL. I just hate questions about more babies. Now that's rude.
Really depends on how it is worded. I have yet to have someone try to push us when we state we are done with one.
No one has done that yet, but they find passive aggressive ways to ask. So annoying.
Have you ever considered maybe you are the issue, not them? It seems like everyone you know is a jerk and hates you.
We get asked all the time when we are having a second one. When we say we're not we've been told it's selfish of us to not have another one, told that we must be lying. I had a friend look at me and ask how I could never want to have another one as if I was less woman than her.
It's rude because while we.are perfectly fine being 1and done. It's mostly financial reasons we aren't having one and it bothers me when someone calls it selfish I want my kid to eat instead of give her a sibling.
Re: Pregnancies: planned or unplanned?
DD-pleasant surprise
Totally agree.
2 pregnancies, both planned
DS was unplanned, though I was taking BCP shipped into a Caribbean island on a container ship so it was likely heat damaged. I should have known it likely wasn't working right.
This LO was planned.
"Man, be creative. Like the stuff you do. Do nice things. Love respectfully. Laugh a fucking lot. Curse when you feel like it. Life is cool." - Jean Grae
Any question about family planning, including, "so, are you trying for #2 now," is rude to me IRL because that's really personal. DH and I are trying, but I've had 2 losses, and I don't really feel like sharing that with some random person at work. Or like my SIL who tried for 8 years without ever getting pregnant. That can be heartbreaking, and it's just not the kind of thing you bring up with someone who's not super close.
LFAF Summer 2016 Awards:
I think the problem with this question IRL is that it usually comes with a lot of judgement...at least in my experience.
Our Little Raspberry Born 3/27/12
I've also had lots of people ask me this, I just don't get why.
I never ask any family planning questions in real life because you never know someone's situation. But I don't see why it's a big deal on a message board. No one is being put on the spot.
The type A thing was a bit weird because type A can't prevent bc failure. My most type A friend had an unplanned baby.
G: 6.10
L: 11.13
I don't know if that makes sense.
We were asked a lot if she was planned by family and friends. It always bothered us, but we figured it was because we weren't married and he used to say he didn't want children.
Me: "not really"
"Oh she was planned?"
I can't get the ticker to work, but I have two sons:
Baby RJ, born 1/25/2014
Formerly Twilightmv
4 months later we were "not trying, not preventing." I remeber saying to H that we should stop trying for a bit and wait. 2 weeks later BFP. 《and it was wonderful!》
— The Doctor, Season 3, Episode 6
We got engaged after 7 months, with a 5 month engagement, and got pregnant 3 months after we were married. Apparently some of my friends and family are awful at math and think it was all 'a mistake'. It's annoying enough that people assume we only got married because we were pregnant by accident and that's not even the case here. I can't imagine how pissed off I'd be about some of the comments I've heard if that were actually the case.
The question doesn't offend me. There are a lot weirder questions asked on TB. If it was someone I didn't know well IRL it would be weird. But most people know he was unplanned because we were only dating four months. When I got pg.
Harry Styles = Life Ruiner
There’s a lightning in your eyes I can't deny
Then there’s me inside a sinking boat running out of time
Without you I'll never make it out alive
But I know, yes, I know we’ll be alright
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
J. 1.14.13 my reason for breathing
We get asked all the time when we are having a second one. When we say we're not we've been told it's selfish of us to not have another one, told that we must be lying. I had a friend look at me and ask how I could never want to have another one as if I was less woman than her.
It's rude because while we.are perfectly fine being 1and done. It's mostly financial reasons we aren't having one and it bothers me when someone calls it selfish I want my kid to eat instead of give her a sibling.