Which brand of cookie dough ice cream ...

talkthewholetime · January 2014

...has the most cookie dough?

And don't tell me blue bell, I'm depressed everyday it doesn't exist in nj. My husband worked in Texas for a while last year and it was sooooo tasty.

83edwards · January 2014

I'm a ben and jerry's fan. Also, breyers will do in a pinch!!!

Now I must have some.....DH is going to hate you!!!

TheBeeCharmer · January 2014

I don't know if you have Hudsonville there but it has an amazing dough to ice cream ratio. Also, Ben and Jerry's has big chunks of it.

mirdamae03 · January 2014

Haha glad I read that before I responded! I am a Blue Bell junkie! I can remember many trips as a kid to the factory in Brenham. Ben and Jerry's is usually my go to if no BB.

EmilyGolden1 · January 2014

Ben & Jerry's!!

talkthewholetime · January 2014

I remember seeing one that said something along the lines of "x-treme
Cookie dough" but that was before my current CD kick.

bb factory?! I'd die. They need to figure out how to ship that stuff up here.

eemiers · January 2014

Sorry ill abbreviate BB is the best!

SurprisePartySue · January 2014

OMG! I just read something on fb about cookie dough ice cream and now I want/need it right now!

codik86 · January 2014

Beyers or Ben n Jerry's are good! Edys doesn't hav much either.

talkthewholetime · January 2014

I got Turkey Hill because it was 2/$5 and I've just been kinda excavating haha

lamdmk103 · January 2014

So funny I came across this-I literally had my DH pick some up at the supermarket tonight. Breyers is great!

talkthewholetime · January 2014

Thank you for your condolences.

Mint chip is my real favorite. I don't think I've eaten a different flavor in 15 years. But the cookie dough is so tasty these days... Probably because I won't eat "real" raw cookie dough pregnant. Haha

momo214 · January 2014

I live in Trxas but not a Blue Bell fan. I know, shame me now. Does loving Dr. Pepper make up for it? Either way the mother of all chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream is Dreyers Loaded

booie05 · January 2014

Oh I miss Blue Bell so much! All they have up here is Blue Bunny and it is not even close! I tried their peppermint ice cream over the holidays and didn't even touch Blue Bell's

jackdustin · January 2014

Ben and Jerry's....now I will be buying some after work....

theoryofwhat · January 2014

Ben & Jerry's all the way. Dreyer's packs a lot in there, too.

Now I want ice cream..looks like I'm going to the store in my PJs!

gurleymomma · January 2014

Mayfield is my favorite

Bayberry12 · January 2014

I think Ben and Jerry's is the best, but I'd pretty much take any kind!

frugalwife · January 2014

https://cdn.bluebell.com/country_store/how_to_order.html

You can get your Blue Bell, but it will cost you!

dogsombrero · January 2014

Blue Bunny- super chunky cookie dough or Breyers Mrs. Fields cookie dough blast are the best off the shelf easy to find ones that I've found. GL on your quest!

Fitpreggo · January 2014

I like to go to the frozen yogurt places (menchies, tutti frutti, yogurtology, yogurt land etc) so I can load it up with AS MUCH COOKIE DOUGH as I want!!!! It's usually way to much, but it's just the way I like it.....and I must throw some reese PB cup in there as well

I might as well add that I also like to choose the cake batter flavor of yogurt whenever it's available haha.

ETA: note the profile pic!! that is a big container of cookie dough galore!!! it complements my username so well haha

Themetastic · January 2014

Ben and Jerry's!

Seriously, do those asshats think a pint is really going to last 4 servings?

awknyc · January 2014

Yes! Edy's or for you west coast folks, Dreyers! So delicious, although my favorite is French Silk. I'm not allowed to get it because I have eaten the whole thing in one day before. Not my proudest moment.

dogsombrero · January 2014

I excluded good ole Ben and Jerry's because it is a calorie-bomb so so so delicious though but I can't stop myself so I don't buy it.

ArmyMedic7588 · January 2014

Turkey Hill!!!! I've found it in northern NJ! But it's made from back home in central Pa… YUMMY!!

talkthewholetime · January 2014

ArmyMedic7588 said:

Turkey Hill!!!! I've found it in northern NJ! But it's made from back home in central Pa… YUMMY!!

@armymedic7588 - do you live in NJ?!

cnbean · January 2014

You know you can make cookie dough and just sub out the eggs? I've eaten way more cookie dough in the last few months than I'd care to admit. I think the sub for eggs is 2 Tbls oil + 2 Tbls water per egg. I usually just google it to double check though.

cweiss04 · January 2014

mmmmBen and Jerrys.....but my fav is half baked....its everything I could want and more....brownie, cookie dough, vanilla and chocolate icecream....delish!

ArmyMedic7588 · January 2014

@talkthewholetime

Yup, Bergen county. Found Turkey Hill at ShopRite! In love

momo214 · January 2014

Just saw this post again and I'm stuck at work for almost 3 more hours and I may kill someone for some cookie dough ice cream.

talkthewholetime · January 2014

ArmyMedic7588 said:

@talkthewholetime
Yup, Bergen county. Found Turkey Hill at ShopRite! In love

Stop it! I'm a lifelong Bergen County-ite! Although I went to the dark side in July and moved across the street the Passiac County @armymedic7588

ArmyMedic7588 · January 2014

@talkthewholetime - oh as soon as I can be gone from this place I'm out! I grew up in the country… WAY too many people here! This place drives me insane and I swear I almost have an anxiety attack in traffic practically every day! But yes, finding Turkey Hill ice cream in the store gives me a little smile every time I see it! hehe

Want a personalized experience?

Which brand of cookie dough ice cream ...

Re: Which brand of cookie dough ice cream ...

Choose Another Board

Search Boards