I hope you don't mind me popping over here. My local board is dead so I'm hoping you all may help me.
Ds is almost 18 months. For the past month we've had incident reports because another kid keeps scratching his face. The other kid is closer to 2. It's becoming more frequent and seems like she's seeking him out. Last night I picked him up and he had a bandage in his cheek because she walked over to him, grabbed his cheek and left a 1/2" scratch down his face. It was deep and bleeding. I'm livid but held it together and asked for a conference. I was already told that they are having a counselor meet with her and her parents. I do feel like the teachers are upset that it's happening but it keeps happening.
One of my friends said "it's a developmental thing and part of growing up" but I feel like he's being targeted by this kid and I don't want him being all scarred up because of her! He's a little boy and will have his share of bumps and bruises but this seems like too much.
Am I over reacting? What would you do?
Our little hippo was as impatient as mom!
Hoping for a full 40 weeks!!
Re: Updated (post meeting) Daycare "bullying" wwyd?
I would do as you are doing, and make sure that they are filling out incident reports. Is your son the only one she is scratching? If so, they need to keep them apart or put this kid in a "time out" etc when he does.
As far as bullying.. I am going to address it by the law for my state anyway... bullying as it is being motivated by a perceived characteristic....Race, color, religion etc.
Because they are kids, I would agree with your friend that this is developmental. Perhaps also call the mother? I would feel the same as you!
First, this is a developmental thing, and it's NOT bullying. I just need to get that out there.
Second, there are things your daycare should be doing to prevent this from happening. The little girl needs to be shadowed, so they can figure out the situations that trigger the scratching. And then prevent those situations, or redirect/intervene as necessary. They need to talk to her about appropriate behavior, and model it for her "we're gentle with our friends, or we keep our hands to ourselves". Her parents should be reinforcing this message at home - every day, we walk to our daughter about being gentle and keeping hands to ourselves.
And most importantly, we cut and file our daughters nails every other day. Lots of kids will hit when they're frustrated, but some kids have fingernails that grow like weeds!
As soon as he switched classrooms, he was happy again. As a parent my priority is that my own kid is safe and happy while I am at work.
My nearly-3 year old has "told me" who bit him - once it was a child WHO IS NO LONGER AT THE CENTER.... so, yeah....take everything your toddler says as FACT. Totally good start.
And I think you are out of your mind if you think two sets of parents-of-2-year-olds can come together and hash out a solution to one child biting another in a situation that neither set of parents has seen and that neither set will be present to monitor in the future.
Really, what do you think can come of this? "Oh, I am so so sorry! We will go home and have a solid, rational conversation about keeping our teeth to ourselves with Betsy, right away. If it doesn't work, we'll punish her at home as well." Last time I checked 2-year-olds don't understand "rational conversations" or punishments meted out hours after incidents.
I'm not sure if this center is doing all they can, but I'd be very concerned about any daycare that didn't respect confidentiality. Kids get scratched, they get bit... Centers are equipped (or should be) to handle it. Sounds like @PhillyGal34 is doing right by listening and asking questions ... here's hoping they do a better job of shadowing.
Let me give it to you from the perspective of a person who has worked with large numbers of children for a long time. First, it's not bullying. Kids aren't able to do that until much later. It is possible that two children that age simply don't like each other... I've seen plenty of that, after all these are people we're talking about, not robots. People are able to dislike other people at all ages.
That doesn't seem to be the case here since the scratcher runs to greet your child.
I would try to take this in stride. This happens ALL THE TIME, it's just that this time it's happening to you. It's nothing personal about you or your child. This little girl is just trying to get along in the world. Also, I fail to see how this is a red flag regarding the center. DCPs don't want your child to be hurt any more than you do, but since children are humans there is only so much that can be done. Yes, they can shadow the offender... but I've spent days shadowing children who still managed to hurt other kids while I'm standing right there. Once a kid I was practically on top of bit an other kid on the face while I was standing right next to him. I turned my head to see what was happening elsewhere in the room and in that second he bit her on the face. Now in this situation the kid was three and was very aggressive due to deplorable parenting and likely some other issues and he was eventually termed... but even in normal situations, kids are fast... my point is that we can't prevent everything.
I'm always slightly entertained by the attitude that I perceive about daycare providers on this board, and in my life in general... I could be wrong, but it seems like many parents like to think we're unintelligent, or lazy, or that bad things happen only because we're being neglectful or otherwise "bad" at our jobs. Providing care to children is a HARD job. We're doing the best we can, but we can't prevent everything. It's simply not possible. That being said, I know it's not fun to watch your child get hurt and I hope they can find a solution for you.
I have no idea what I'd have done had I been in that situation when my son was being constantly bitten... What should that family's "approach" be?
2010: Infertility
October 2015: missed miscarriage #2 at 11 weeks (trisomy 22)
I also think (not being snarky, really) that your daughter sounds really advanced compared to some of the 2 yo that I know.
And that you're lucky you had another set of parents who were on the same page as you. In my experience that is not always the case.
BTW, I don't disagree that at this age it's easy to find out who the biter is, but I still think confidentiality is really important.
I have no plans to approach the other mom. I'm sure she's upset and embarrassed. She's not a bad person.
I already clarified that I don't really think it is bullying but I could not think of a better word
I am leaving this to the daycare providers whom I do trust. I am not a professional in this area and they are. I think that both of his teachers are upset about this and they have both reached out to me to let me know that they are not happy with what is going on. I know that they have to work within the confines of the center's rules and guidelines.
And my son was over two months premature therefore even though he's 18 months old he's a little bit smaller than other students his age and this girl is much bigger than he is. So physically she is much stronger and faster then he is.
I just misinterpreted what cecily was saying - I thought she was implying that Centers SHOULD do cross-family conferences in these situations. And frankly, I don't necessarily think they should (and that's just my opinion based on my feeling that confidentiality is important to all sides; note that I, too, have the bitee, not the biter) and I legitimately didn't see how that could help. I'm REALLY glad that she was able to have that kind of conversation and that it worked. I think that is AWESOME.
So... I misinterpreted what she wrote to be more directive than she'd intended and also I didn't get it; now I do.
Kids are kids. Really all you can do is ask the school what they're doing to prevent it, or make sure it doesn't keep happening. Is your child instigating, are they supervising the offender more closely, are they keeping your child and the other child apart, etc.
Don't approach the parent, I'm betting they feel horrible and super embarrassed and it will only make things more awkward for you.
But, yeah, my number one question at the conference would be "What if it doesn't stop? What is the next course of action?.
I agree that 20 times in a month is completely out of line. I would have spoken up earlier. At this point I expect the DC worker to shadow the other child ALL the time. If they can't do that physically because of ratios and numbers it's their responsibility to communicate with the parents and remove the other child from the room if that's what it takes. But I also agree that it's not your place to talk to the other parents, even if you do know who it is. However, I would not leave this in status quo - if I didn't get the resolution which leads to a stop of this behavior then my child would be leaving.
the ratio is 8 kids to 2 teachers.
I did speak up earlier and was told that things were being done. I wanted to give it time to work (I know change does not happen overnight) but when I didn't see any change and saw that she was actually seeking him out to scratch him I got more upset.
She has not scratched him the last two days. Maybe the break for the holiday broke the cycle? wishful thinking.
I believe I said this a few times but I have never and do not plan on ever approaching the other parents. I know the mom (even though again, I'm not supposed to know who the child is, and I am sure she is uncomfortable. I'm not even sure she knows it is my son that she is scratching but I would not want to make things awkward.)
I do know that she is this way at home. her older brothers are treated the same way as my son and are scared of her. I think she's a sweet kid but more than a bit rough. I do not know if the brothers instigate it or anything and cannot speak to what goes on at home of course.
DH and I talked about everything in depth and our questions are going to be
what has been done
what is being done
what will be done
what if none of this works
is there anything we can do? (We have been told time and time again that DS is not instigating anything and that most times he is sitting with other kids or alone and playing and she comes to him)
if we do not get answers that work for us we will be looking for a new daycare. He really loves it there and we like that his godmother is there but if I will not allow this to continue.
We started with voicing our concerns and the reason we asked for the meeting. I indicated that I was frustrated and concerned that nothing was changing. They advised me of the steps they had taken which included a lot of observation by the behavioral counselor and a lot of data collection and what they are doing now. They are implementing a lot more separation for the class in general but specifically with this child and my son. (we also learned that he is not the only child now but of course they were careful to not say a lot but they said they are separating her from the children effected). One of the issues they have in this classroom is that this group of children tends to want to be together at all times. Many classes have some kids that will want to play in one center and others in another. This class will not separate on their own and when they are divided they focus on the other half unless they are all doing the same thing. It is just the dynamics of this group.
So they are keeping them apart when they are in various situations (separate tables, separate buggies for walks, etc) and then keeping them apart by division of the class for other activities.
They mentioned that my son is (in my words for clarity) "100% boy" and wants to play by rolling around and being physically engaged. he is the only boy in the class as I mentioned and some of the girls don't like that. This one does engage in physical play but then reaches a point where she gets tired or done with it and that is when the incidents seem to happen. It also seems to be related to certain toys or items that have been taken away.
One thing that really hit me was how much anxiety this is causing me. How I get so upset before I even pick him up wondering if it happened again. I broke down in tears during the meeting (which is not like me at all) and said that I just want this to all pass. Unfortunately I'm not sure it is going to immediately but I know that it is being taken seriously and that they are on top of it.
My other concern was her nails. They said that they did talk to the parent and that they will continue to follow up with them. Looking back I wish I had asked if they could do a daily nail check and let the mom know when they consider them too long. I may bring it up when I drop him off tomorrow because the teacher that was there at the meeting won't be there when I pick him up.
So all in all nothing major is changing but I know that they are working on this. DH and I will talk more about it tonight when we are alone but he had to leave for a work meeting immediately after the meeting. If things don't change we will have to consider our options but the flip side is what if we go somewhere else and he has to deal with a biter or something. I know this is a developmental thing so I'm not sure we can avoid it even if we try unless we keep him home with a nanny.... which we do not want.
I really appreciate all of your help and suggestions and understanding with this and if you have other suggestions/input I'm open to it. I'm sure I missed things from the meeting which was over an hour long so I'll add as necessary to answer questions but I felt you all deserved an update after all the help you offered!
thanks!
(((Hugs))) and keep us posted.