Working Moms

NWMR - Family and Holidays - A Rant

Since Dh and I moved into our new house earlier this year, we've been very excited about hosting Christmas for both of our families.  My family is local.  His family is coming from 1.5 hours and 5 hours away. 

Last night, he asked what time we'd like to have people come over.  I said maybe around 1, eat dinner early-ish around 4, because I know some folks in my family have to work the next day.  His family will stay over, so we'll get tons of quality time after my family leaves.  They will not come before Christmas day.  We've asked.  They don't want to.

He told me that his family does not want to exchange gifts at the same time as my family.  I said that was fine, we could exchange with them after my family leave.  No, he said, I need to tell my family that they can't come over until after we've exchanged with his family.  OK, so can you family come around noon?  His parents, with the longest ride, are typically on the road by 6am at the latest.  When we go to his brother's for Christmas, we're there before lunch, at their insistence.  Noooooo - that's too early.  So they don't want to come until mid-afternoon, but they want me to tell my family not to come over until even later.

So now I'm pissed.  Why can't the kids all open presents together?  Why do we have to wait?  I don't feel like I should have to tell my family to come late because of this.  If they don't want to exchange gifts while my family is there, I kind of feel like they should wait and do it later.

Am I being a huge b!tch about this?

Re: NWMR - Family and Holidays - A Rant

  • They don't want their own gifts opened in front of your family but are requiring that your family's gifts be opened in front of them? That doesn't make any sense.

    On the one hand, they really don't have any say in when your family arrives or leaves or what they do.

    On the other, this may be a big miscommunication between your DH and his family.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Loading the player...
  • Um, no.  I would flat out say "no".  You're not going to cut time w/ your family short so that they don't have to open their gifts in front of them.  They have 3 choices - do it after your family leaves, come at 12, or just do it w/ your family. 

    I think that's more than fair.  Cutting into your time w/ your family is NOT an option - and really, you need to ride your DH about that one.  He needs to "get it" that this is NOT an option.

    Because - you give in and go along w/ it, then his family will start to expect this in future years.

    Which really brings up another point - perhaps in the future, it may be best to keep the family celebrations separate.  We've now combined both Thanksgiving and CHristmas w/ our families.  At first, it was nice.  But now - as the years pass and there is now weird vibes because of DS, it's no longer the fun, comfortable event it once was.  But it's too late to go back.

    Doing it together ONE year, because it's your new home, can really be a one time event.  And now that you've gotten a clue that his family really doesn't want to be "all one big happy family" about it - it might be best to not make this the norm.

    One question - though.  Do they not want to do this because they don't want ot have to BUY for your family?  Is this where the concern is coming from?  (I mean, if it is, I get it.  Presents can be $$).  BUT that still doesn't give them the right to dictate that your family needs to come late.
  • I think you are being more than accommodating. In the future I would do holidays seperately (in our family we do Christmas Eve with my family and Christmas Day with DH's family).
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic


    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • You are hosting. Just decide what time to serve dinner and what time to open gifts, with some consideration for travel schedules. It's a freaking holiday. YH and ILs need to chill about the schedule.
    DS born 8/8/09 and DD born 6/12/12.
  • i would just tell them everyone is invited for 1:00 pm. If they want to arrive earlier to do gifts alone, they are welcome to arrive at 12:00. And have your H deliver the message.
    Daisypath Happy Birthday tickers
    Daisypath Happy Birthday tickers



  • I can't stay away.

    You're INVITING them to YOUR home, and now they are trying to dictate the schedule to you?  That's honestly so damn rude. 

    And "mid afternoon" doesn't sound like 1 to me.  It sounds like 2 or 3, or even 4.  So - they want your family to come AFTER that and have dinner when, exactly?

    Again - you need to give your DH the riot act on this. 
  • I don't have any additional advice to add as you have already received great input from everyone, just want to say I am solidly on your team with this one.  DH's family is being way too difficult about this.

     

  • THANK YOU!!! Historically, my family has been a collective PITA about holidays, but I just feel like they're being ridiculous.  They're not worried about buying gifts for my family.  They're worried that my family will go over the top with gifts, and my kids will compare what each set of grandparents gave them.  DD1 is 4.  She's going to be in such a tizzy that she won't know who gave what.  She's just going to be thrilled that the whole family is in one place.

    DH threw out there that I had NO IDEA what it was like to have both families for a holiday.  Except that EVERY SINGLE CHRISTMAS, both sides of the family came to my parents house.  I'm sure there were issues, but as kids, we never saw it, and no one compared presents, either.

    The whole thing is ridiculous.  I was really crazy excited for Christmas this year.  I started my shopping in October.  I've been listening to Christmas carols with the kids for 2 weeks now.  This totally took the wind out of my sails. 

    Bah humbug.
  • mae0111 said:


    DH threw out there that I had NO IDEA what it was like to have both families for a holiday.  
    So..... this means that YOUR family has to be the one to come later and spend less time w/ you?  HIS family is the one w/ the issue, HIS family is the one who needs to find a solution that does NOT impede on your family.
  • If they are so concerned about her comparing, which I agree is a ridiculous thing for them to be concernced about because 1) she is 4, but also 2) I am sure you are raising a polite DD who wouldnt do something like that if she were old enough to know, then why not just put all the presents in a pile she she wont know who gave what?

    Im Jewish and dont know better so I am sorry if this isnt in line with tradition, but perhaps it is a way to get around their silly concern. Jeez.

  • Although really, it's not about your daughter noticing who gave more. It's about all the adults noticing. That's where some people get sensitive and feel judged and snickered at. (And sometimes it's even true.)
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Sounds like the adults need to pull up their big kid pants. It's your house, your rules. If they don't like it they don't have to come. Now I know that sounds easier then real life...but still.

    Henry Cavill...You're welcome!

    image

    BFP #3: EDD 1/10/13 **DS born 12/30/12!!!**
    BFP #2: MC 7/2/11 @ 12 weeks
    **Missing our February '12 LoveBug**
    BFP #1: MMC discovered on 12/6/10

    image

    Anniversary



This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"