January 2014 Moms

S/O suing medical professionals

A good friend of mine and I are FB chatting, and she just sent me a link to this article from her home town.


An Ohio woman is suing her gynecologist for allegedly spraying a chemical used in drain cleaner into her private parts.

The woman, who is only being identified as "Laura," said she visited her gynecologist,Dr. John Black, in his Akron, Ohio, office for a routine gynecological exam called a colposcopy.

At one point, she said Dr. Black squirted some liquid from a spray bottle marked "vinegar" onto her sex organs and into her vaginal canal.

She immediately felt horrible pain and burning down there.

"It was like an open cut with rubbing alcohol being poured into it," she said, according to UPI.com.

Laura said Black noticed her reaction and placed a tiny amount of the solution he used on her into a cup.

Medical records say Black "tasted it on the tip of his tongue which immediately started to burn."

Then he allegedly told his suffering patient, "I'm breaking all the rules"and proceeded to irrigate the burned area with three bottles of saline solution. He also applied a cream inside her to numb the pain -- without wearing gloves, according to Laura's husband, Paul.

"He puts an ungloved dirty finger inside her and rubs a numbing cream inside her. It's disgusting," Paul told WKYC-TV.

Tests on Laura determined that the chemical that her doctor thought was vinegar was actually potassium hydroxide, a chemical found in drain cleaner, that can decompose human flesh.

A few hours after seeing Laura, Black called her and suggested she go to to Akron General Hospital’s emergency room. There, doctors discovered a plastic bottle cap inside her cervix, RawStory.com reported.

In addition, they discovered the pH level of the liquid sprayed inside Laura’s body was not the harmless 7.5 level that Black claimed, but was 12 or higher, a level damaging to the human body.

Laura and Paul have filed a malpractice suit against Black and his employer, Paragon Health Associates. The company denies all their allegations, but said that Black sprayed what he thought was a vinegar liquid into her vagina, USA Today reported.

Laura said she experiences ongoing, irregular bleeding as a result of Black's actions and is no longer able to have sex with her husband. She also said she hoped to have more children, but now believes she will need a hysterectomy, the Daily Mail reported.


Thoughts? My first reaction was that I really don't think it was the Dr's fault (I highly doubt he'd be the one refilling bottles), and the practice should be investigating possible disgruntled employees. Also, at that point I don't think I'd care too much about his ungloved hand, I'd just want the pain to stop. But the bottle cap in her cervix?

I just had a colposcopy a few weeks ago. Cannot imagine.

Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

imageimage


Re: S/O suing medical professionals

  • Ummm... someone needs to be held responsible.  In the end, it is the physician's license and therefore his responsibility.

    That is very disturbing.
  • Loading the player...
  • What a nightmare!!
    :-O
  • Um...I have so many questions after reading this. Like you, my first thought was that he is highly unlikely to be the one filling bottles, so I don't fault him personally there. I'm curious why he wasn't wearing gloves to begin with if he was spraying anything inside someone's vag, unless he had taken them off before she started complaining. The "breaking the rules" comment is weird, and I'm curious what the rest of the convo was. Also very confused by the bottle cap...where they heck did it come from?

    What a weird story.
    -----------------------------------------------------------------

    mutt_zps2fb5f039-1_zps7220f27c
    BFP 11.8.12 * EDD 7.17.13 * MC 12.20.12
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
     photo bump_zpsf1e8435c.jpgRIP Post Count
     
  • WHAT?  That is so scary!  Sounds like there needs to be an investigation regarding how that ended up in a vinegar bottle.  I'm not the litigious type but based on just what the article tells us I think I would want to hold the person responsible accountable (I don't think we know enough to say who that really was as I'm sure there is more to the story).  That's awful though!!
    _____________________________________________________________
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    imageimage 
  • That is absolutely horrible. Somebody does need to be held accountable.
  • megngregkmegngregk member
    edited November 2013
    My skeptical side wonders if they aren't just seeing dollar signs, but then my sensitive side says "I can't imagine how bad that must have hurt or the damage it would have caused". I know nothing about this chemical, so I don't know how bad it really was. I also assume if it was that strong that the Dr would have smelled it and not had to taste it. So many holes in the story. I'm sure he took the gloves off for the numbing cream because they were contaminated with the fluid, which is what I would have done in the midst of the chaos.

    The bottle cap really gets me, though. However, it was also hours later that she went to the ER (if it hurt that bad, wouldn't you have gone immediately?). Not saying, but just saying, she could have put it up there.

    Edited "no" to "know".
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

    imageimage


  • Potassium hydroxide is often on the counter of every gyn room, it's what they use to evaluate yeast on microscope slides. So I can imagine how the mix up could happen.... I had no idea it could burn like that. Either way, this doctor seems super skeezy.
    _________________________________________________________________


    My cat can read EKGs, can your human do that?
    ♥BFP#1 12-23-12, M/C 12-31-12 at 5w4d♥
    ♥BFP#2 05-09-13, EDD 01-15-14. C/S 12-23-13 at 36w5d for complete previa. Healthy baby boy♥
    _________________________________________________________________

  • Am I the only one wondering why he would be spraying her with vinegar in the first place?

    Baby Lexi: BFP: May 12, 2013 (Mother's Day), EDD: January 21, 2014
  • I understand the vinegar mix up, he's still responsible for that. But wtf to the bottle cap? 
    photo 750f3c1a-2ade-403a-a0f5-dc1db83a8c08_zps3b41b396.jpgphoto 823a6982-64ae-4aeb-8830-c03461e6d517_zps5e065d1f.jpgphoto 53bf98f1-e49e-4c67-acd7-61db3c981d79_zps7cd2176b.jpg
  • If my vagina was burning like that, I honestly wouldn't care about his ungloved hands trying to fix the problem.

    I don't know anything about the chemical. But my feeling from the article is that they are being more dramatic than the situation turned out to be. 'He put his bare hand in there, it was disgusting!' I don't generally consider bare hands disgusting and I would probably be preoccupied by my spouse freaking the eff out.

    The bottle cap however, wtf?

    @blue_elle. I'm guessing he had gloves on and considered them 'contaminated' when he realized which chemical he used. Took them off and didn't take the time to put on new ones before rinsing and applying numbing cream.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • BMReid said:
    @happydoc - it's something about making abnormal cells visible. I've had a colposcopy and my dr had a bottle of vinegar, too.
    This. Also, @BMReid, I really can't imagine shoving something into myself either. But I did question it...
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

    imageimage


  • Oh. My. Gosh. That makes my whole undercarriage pucker! How awful :( poor girl. Unfortunately, in the end the Dr is absolutely responsible for that incident, regardless who refilled the containers.
    CafeMom Tickers
  • ashleywiz said:
    Oh. My. Gosh. That makes my whole undercarriage pucker! How awful :( poor girl. Unfortunately, in the end the Dr is absolutely responsible for that incident, regardless who refilled the containers.
    Very true, and I agree 100%. I think I get so itchy about people being sue-happy, and I hate to think of somebody's life and career being over because of a mistake. But, if the implications were as bad as her having a hysterectomy/not having children/not being able to be intimate with her husband, then that's just the price Dr will have to pay.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

    imageimage


  • I'm not a sue happy person. If I have a bad experience I usually just don't go back. The article does raise the same questions to ne that were addressed in the pps. I feel bad for the doctor since I think it was an honest mistake.
     ***********************************************************************************************
      blogbutton badge!!!
    Lilypie Premature Baby tickers
  • megngregk said:
    Very true, and I agree 100%. I think I get so itchy about people being sue-happy, and I hate to think of somebody's life and career being over because of a mistake. But, if the implications were as bad as her having a hysterectomy/not having children/not being able to be intimate with her husband, then that's just the price Dr will have to pay.

    Oh I absolutely hate how quick people are to suing these days. It makes me sick. However, in this case, if it lead to something super serious like that- I don't blame her at all. That IS malpractice. Just sad no matter which way you look at it.
    CafeMom Tickers
  • The dr sounds gross. Yes I blame him. His dirty finger is totally uncalled for and unprofessional.

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker imageBaby Birthday Ticker Ticker

  • HappyDoc said:
    Am I the only one wondering why he would be spraying her with vinegar in the first place?
    It's used very commonly to look at the cervix, especially during coloposcopy. We do literally spray it in with a spray bottle, it dehydrates the cells a little bit and makes it easier to identify weird spots on the cervix that may need biopsied.
    _________________________________________________________________


    My cat can read EKGs, can your human do that?
    ♥BFP#1 12-23-12, M/C 12-31-12 at 5w4d♥
    ♥BFP#2 05-09-13, EDD 01-15-14. C/S 12-23-13 at 36w5d for complete previa. Healthy baby boy♥
    _________________________________________________________________

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"