Hello STMs (or more!)
My son is 20 months and I am due for our second son in 3 months. My first birth was not induced, but I had an epidural and a vaginal birth. I am looking for some stories about your first birth as compared to your second, whether it was med-free or not. Just wondering about how fast labor went the second time as compared to the first and any differences or similarities between the two. I am going for a natural birth this time, and I am curious about your 1st vs 2nd time experiences...
Hope this question hasn't been recently asked. Thanks!
My TTC History:
2009: missed miscarriage #1 at 9 weeks (trisomy 16)
2010: Infertility
2011: Diagnosis and treatment (low sperm count, anastrozole for DH, clomid for me + IUI)
2012: Baby #1
2014: Baby #2
October 2015: missed miscarriage #2 at 11 weeks (trisomy 22)
March 2016 BFP#5, due November 2016.
My Charts since 2009
Re: Tell me about your 1st birth vs 2nd birth
I had my 2nd when my first was 30 mo old. We hired a different doula. I told her about my first birth and she mentioned that vomiting can indicate transition. I went into labor at 42 weeks after having my membranes swept by my midwife. She wanted me to come in for an induction the next morning. I stayed at home as long as I could handle it on my own. We got to the hospital at 7PM but didn't get looked at until 8 because all the beds were full. When I was checked I was at 8cm already. I got into the tub and labored there until I needed to get out. The midwife was with me the whole time. The baby was born at 10:20PM. I had a small tear but the midwife didn't feel it needed stitches.
Night & day differences between my first & second. Third & fourth were also natural hospital births. #3 I had to go in early because I was GBS+. Got there at 3:30AM and baby born 11AM. The OB delivered as the midwife wasn't on call that day. Small tear that he did stitch up. #4 my water broke at home with meconium in it. Got to the hospital about 5:30AM. My labor did stall a bit and the midwife had them give me pitocin. Totally different than the first as it was a much lower dose. Baby born at 6PM. No stitches and I don't recall her mentioning any tear.
I'm hoping that #5 goes like #2.
My first was hospital birth with an epidural, augmented with Pitocin. Labor started with bloody show & very mild contractions at 35.5 weeks. I went to the hospital (one known to not be NB friendly) right away. Was 3 cm dilated and 50% effaced. Being a scared FTM, who'd been told too many horror stories by friends and family, I ordered my epi at the first contraction that wasn't "mild". That was about 2 hours into labor at 5 cm dilated. Labor basically stalled. I'm not sure if it was the epi, my stress level from having to be hooked to BP cuff & monitors, or maybe just having to be in bed. Either way, I made almost no progress over the next 16 hours. They started Pitocin at 7am (would have started it earlier, but they wanted to wait till my Dr. was in normal office hours). Contractions picked up a lot almost immediately, and I was fully dilated within 3 hours. They called the Dr., set everything up, and got me started pushing. I pushed for about an hour. I couldn't feel anything, so they had to tell me when to push and for how long. Baby was born healthy with no issues breathing or anything else after 23 hours of labor. I had an episiotomy that I think was the equivalent of a 3rd degree tear. Recovery wasn't awful, but it definitely wasn't fun. It probably took me a good 10 days before I felt anywhere near normal. Baby was very sleepy for the first few days after birth. Never did BF well, but I blame that more on him being born early than on the epi.
2nd birth - I was physically in better shape. I gained the same amount of weight, but it was all in my belly, where as with my 1st pregnancy I didn't exercise much and the weight gain was everywhere! I felt my first "contraction" - it was really a burning sensation in my back - at 11PM. By midnight it was a constant pain in my back. Called my mom to watch DS1. Called the Dr. By 12:45 when my mom arrived, I was lying on the floor not sure if I would make it without pain meds. We got to the hospital a little after 1. My back hurt so bad I refused to ride in the wheelchair to L&D. The nurse said last time she seen that the woman was 8cm & delivered w/in an hour. She was right, I was an 8! Contractions were actually better/easier at this point because they were coming and going like you'd expect instead of constant. Got the hep-lock put in, and labored on my hands an knees on the bed. DH applied counter-pressure and talked me through them. At 2:15 my water broke, and almost immediately I felt DS2 turn from face up to face down & drop into the birth canal. I felt a lot of pressure & asked for the Dr. to check me. I was completely dilated & effaced. They let me push when I felt ready. Baby was out in three pushes (2 contractions) after less than 4 hours of labor. I tore just a little bit (1st degree). They laid baby on my chest to clean him up and do AGPAR. I BF'ed right away. Baby is still a great nurser. Recovery was super easy. I was up and walking within maybe 4 hours after birth. The stitches pain was mild & easy to control with ibuprophen. I felt back to "normal" by 3 days PP. I really think both excercising during pregnancy and having a natural birth contributed to how easy labor and recovery were for me.
#1 - no contractions or anything until 39w3d when I had 'braxton hicks' every 6-7 minutes. Lasted about ten hours then spread out. Then suddenly my water broke. Very intense contractions from the get go every 2-3 minutes. Went to the hospital a few hours later - 5cm 100% effaced. 10 cm a few hours later. 45 minutes of pushing (he was 8lb 12, OP and with a nuchal hand). Or an episiotomy. Had him within 6 hours of my water breaking.
#2 - preterm labor at 33 weeks. False labor on and off for 3 weeks. Preterm labor again at 36 weeks. Left 3cm 100% effaced when things died down on their own. 37w 3d my water broke. Two hours later I had intense, close contractions. Four hours after that I wanted to push but they said I was only 7 cm. A few minutes later she popped out. The nurse delivered her. She was born within 6 hours of my water breaking.
#3 (current pregnant) - preterm labor at 31w 6d leaving me 1cm 100% effaced. Reverted to closed and long within days. Now at 39w 3d (after 8 weeks of false labor on and off), I'm only 2cm 50% effaced. Who knows what labor will be like this time?!
With baby 2 I woke up in the middle of the night when my water broke. MP had been coming out for weeks. Contractions started half an hour later. They were excrutiating almost immediately and I totally thought I would die. Screamed my head off while my husband set up the birth tub. Got in the tub and immediately started pushing, 45 minutes after my first contraction. I am confident in hindsight that I was pretty much in transition from the first contraction. Pushed for an hour and 15 minutes, successful hbac.
37w6d- water broke and contractions started after a little over an hour. Arrived at birth center at 7 cm but birthed my daughter within 10 minutes. Pushed for just a couple of minutes again and ended up with just a teeny tear. Total time from water breaking of birth was 5 hours (around 3.5 from start of contractions).
Hands down the med-free birth was infinitely better. I felt the post labor high and just all around fantastic even though my first birth was textbook for a medicated birth.
Elizabeth 5yrs old Jane 3yrs old
Breastfeeding Counselor with Breastfeeding USA
Babywearing Guide ** Newborn Carriers
Cloth Diaper Guide
Safe Bed Sharing Info
They were mostly the same. Both were spontaneous labors (1st at 39w3d, second at 40w6d), med-free, low-intervention hospital births. First time began with contractions and ended <8 hours later (15 min pushing). Second time began with water breaking, contractions an hour later, birth 5 hours after that (7 minutes of pushing). The major difference was that the second time, the baby was breech. According to the MW and OB, that slowed my labor significantly. I would agree - I felt incredibly pushy for more than an hour before I was dilated enough to push because her bum was softer than her head would have been. If her head was putting pressure on my cervix, I would have been funny dilated and pushing sooner.
My first was born at 42 weeks 1 day at a free standing birth center after I had about given up on labor ever starting . I went into labor the night before my midwife was going to start with nutrual induction methods . I was in a daze for pretty much the entire things . I labored in the water for about 6 hours of my 10 1/2 hour labor . I pushed for 1 1/2 hours and my daughter was born ( water birth) with her head tilted sideways . I had a horrible PP experience. Within an hour of the birth we realized the placenta detached from the cord so my midwife had to scrape the placenta out ( worst pain ever) then I was transferred to the hospital where I was ignored for four hours while I hemorrhaged . The next day I ended up with a blood transfusion .
My second was born at 41 weeks 3 days after only four hours of labor . It was super quick I made it to the birth center 15 minutes before she was born . The tub wasnt even half full but I still have birth in it lol! This birth was such a healing experience . I had no issues after and was even able to take a shower an hour after her birth.
My third was born at 36 weeks 5 days after 29 hours of labor . 9 active hours and only around 2 hard labor hours . He was born in the water with no issues .
Fourth was born at 40 weeks 3 days after 4 1/2 hours of labor . This time I had to go to the hospital ( no my choice my midwife was busy with another client ) and got their 45 minutes before she was born. I ended up delivering on my hands an knees on the bed because I couldn't get up to get into the tub . No immediate pp issues . A week pp I ended up in the ER with pp hemmoraghing and received a D&C and blood transfusion . I have been tolled not to have anymore children since my uterus seems to not like me .
1st was 11 hours with spontaneous rupture of membranes right before I started pushing. I had no urge to push and took 45 mins. I had some tearing and a pressure sore which hurt a lot to sit following.
2nd birth was 17 hours. My water broke and was in early labor for 15.5 hours very comfortably then 1.5 hours of active labor and transition with strong urge to push and just let my body push baby out in 4 mins. No tears the second time and absolutely no pain peeing after and easily could walk around right after the birth no light headedness.
With my son I was having major contractions for about 3 days before he was born. I thought I would have him the first day, but then my MW gave me some Tylenol PM to help me sleep and then contractions slowed down. I had kind of a day off with spaced out contractions and then a full day of contractions before I finally had DS. He was posterior with a military presentation and acynclitic (sunny side up, chin up instead of tucked and to the side). I also had him practically on my back I'm my bed because of the intense back labor. I consider the real work of my labor to be about 25 hours with 2 1/2 hours of pushing.
With DD, I had a peaceful water birth. It was about 7 hours (from when I called the MW) and I pushed for about half and hour to an hour, tops. I basically squatted her out in the tub. Much nicer and more relaxing in the water.
First: 37w 6d. Started spontaneously, total 9 hours. My OB broke my water at about 8 cms. 20 minutes of pushing, 2nd degree tear.
Second: 17 months after the first. 39w 4d. Started spontaneously, total 3 hours. Water broke when I started pushing. 2 pushes and she was out, 2nd degree tear.
Third: 14 months after the second. 39w, 2 days. Started spontaneously, total 2 hours 45 minutes. Water broke when I started pushing. Pushed about 10 minutes, second degree tear.
My labors were remarkably similar to each other, except that the first was much longer. All three I woke up in the middle of the night in full blown active labor- never had early labor.
DS#1 (hospital) born around the EDD, water broke just before midnight, Dr ordered pitocin even though I was having contractions. DS born a bit over 12 hours after water broke, 30 min of pushing, tore in 5 places+got cut. Healing over 8 weeks, lots of ice, motrin and pain spray.
DS#2 (home) born around the EDD, started contractions/stomach upset. DS born less that 4 hours after first contraction, water broke after I started pushing, pushed for 10 minutes, 2nd degree tear. Healed very fast, no pain management at all.
Loved the high after DS#2 birth
DS1 - Labored for 18 hours at home before going to hospital, labored 7 more hours at the hospital, pushed for 3 hours, had a baby. Very long but med-free and manageable.
DS2 - Water broke at home and baby was born 4 hours later. Fast and med-free but exponentially more painful.
My Blog




My son was born med free, in the birth center after 6 hours of labor. He was out in 2 pushes! It was awesome, and going med free was relatively easy after the 24 or so hours I labored med free with my DD.
#2 was totally different . I went at 42 weeks 2 days . I labored at home for a few hours before heading to the birth center . We got there 15 minutes before the birth. The tub wasn't even half full when I got in . I pushed twice and my husband caught her . I'm pretty sure she didn't even touch the water . Because of my fear of bruising my tailbone I refused to sit down so I was on my hands a knees . She was born 15 minutes after midnight at 42 weeks 3 days. Pp was better but breastfeeding was excoriating and I couldn't do it .
# 3 I went into labor at 36 weeks 4 days . I woke up with my water leaking then contractions started shortly after . For 20 hours my contractions were only 30 minutes apart and not to painful . I was able to rest and at times sleep. At 5 the next morning the contractions got more painful and went from 30 minutes to 15 minutes apart . At around noon I decided I wanted to leave for the birth center . At around 1 pm things got more intense . My contractions never did become consistent . I was very frustrated since I could never get into a good labor pattern . Despite not having constant contraction I delivered again in the tub at almost three that afternoon . My husband caught our baby yet again. Pp was easy just like my second however breastfeeding again was way to painful so yet again I was unsuccessful .
# 3 I went into labor at 40 weeks 3 days . After being in a good labor pattern for a few hours I decided to call my midwife when my contractions were about 10 minutes apart . When she answered she tolled me she had another client currently at the birth center who had been pushing for awhile . She hopes she would have the baby soon and she would come over however I wasn't going to be able to have my water birth at the birth center like all my other babies . I was quite devastated . Having that thrown at me in the middle of active labor was terrible and made the pain from the contractions horrific . I was tense . About twenty minutes after I had hung up with my midwife my contractions went from 10 minutes apart to 3 minutes apart . I tried calling my
Midwife and she didn't answer so I made the decision to go to the hospital which isn't known for being natural friendly ( or had not been ). When we got there we went to the ER . We must have been a sight . We walked to the check in where the gal called labor and delivery without even calling me back to the ER ( thankfully) . Labor and deliver asked what number of baby this was and we said four. Apparently when you are in labor with your fourth they take you seriously because we were tolled to go straight to labor and delivery . When I got there I was checked and was 8 cm . I labored for maybe 20 minutes before I was checked again and was a nine with a lip . Knowing what I needed to do I just flipped myself on the bed onto my hands a knees where just a few contractions later I was ready to push. I pushed for maybe five minutes and my daughter was born. I didn't get to wait till the cord completely turned white like my other babies and my husband didn't get to catch her but overall it was very nice and they were pretty ok with my wishes . Pp was pretty good for the first week but again breastfeeding was unsuccessful. A week after her birth I ended up back in the ER with pp hemmoraghing due to my uterus being filled with clots . Because of this I had to have a D&C and a blood transfusion . I was also tolled it would be a very very bad idea to have more children ( which is fine because we were done anyway) since I had two bad pp issues. Each of my labors and deliveries have been so different .