Two nights ago, I decided to cut the 5:30 bottle, and it's working really well! Like megs suggested, I just shut the doors, had the white noise machines on, and picked a time to go in (6:30). The first night he cried on and off from 5:30 to 6:30 (and was sleeping when I finally went in, though he woke up shortly after); last night, he cried a bit at 4:30(?) and then didn't make a peep until after 6:30. Then, when he did get up and my husband gave him a bottle, he was barely even interested! Somebody wasn't so hungry after all. Thanks to all for your advice and support.
Re: Update on 5:30 feeding (paging megs)
Married: 5/21/05 **~** Emery Aylin 6/30/12
BFP#1-11/5/10- Surgery for ectopic pregnancy 11/15/10 BFP#2-11/1/11 Due 7/8/12 Born 6/30/12
Oops we did it again... BFP 03/23/14 Due 12/6/14 Nora Born 11/23/14