ameda vs. hygeia?

EMoose6550 · June 2013

My apologies if this was already posted earlier, but I'm looking for opinions about the Ameda Purely Yours Ultra and the Hygeia EnJoye. I've ready good and bad things about both (mainly about Hygeia's spotty customer service). I had a Medela PISA for DS1, but am looking for a closed system pump for DS2. Thanks in advance!

LJUTCMommy · June 2013

I'm FTM so although I don't have experience with it, out of the options through my insurance, I ordered the Hygeia Enjoye.

It had better reviews on Amazon and just seemed like a stronger pump overall.

orangecurls · June 2013

My lactation consultant recommends ameda or medela.

amief · June 2013

Another FTM here so I don't speak from experience but I got quite a few recommendations for the Hygeia and I"m going with that. The lactation consultant at the place I ordered it also said its one of her favorites (for what its worth).

Unknown · June 2013

Ameda is recommended by most hospitals, lactation consultants, and Baby Bargains as well.

EMoose6550 · June 2013

Thanks for the insight, ladies!

Cubskers · June 2013

I've for a 5 month old and LOVE my hygeia. I was hesitant when that was the pump my insurance covered, but I've had nothing but positive experiences with their customer service.

I also have a PISA and use my Hygeia 100 of the time.

Angela814 · June 2013

I bought my Ameda over 7 years ago, and it still works great today.

Jolililas · June 2013

I have the Ameda Purely Yours Ultra and I HATE it! Don't get me wrong- it gets the job done, but it is cumbersome, loud, and bulky. If I had the choice I would go with the Hygeia.

Want a personalized experience?

ameda vs. hygeia?

Re: ameda vs. hygeia?

Choose Another Board

Search Boards