Special Needs

Private vs Early Intervention

Does anyone feel strongly about private therapy versus the therapy your child gets through early intervention? I'm specifically talking about 0 to 3. If you have opinions can you specify what type of therapy: PT, ST, or OT?

How frequently is your child getting therapy? My guy is very delayed. He still has not rolled back to belly, got on all fours, spoken anything like "ma"... we are only doing one hour each week of PT, ST, and OT. So three hours total. Should I be doing more? He is 15 months.


BabyFruit Ticker
Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

Re: Private vs Early Intervention

  • I think it depends on the quality of care you feel you're receiving. I've had a positive experience with ei and have gotten a lot out of the program. 
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Loading the player...
  • heedy07heedy07 member

    In our state (and I think in most states), the early intervention program is very full. This being said, there is only so much time they can devote to each child in the program, and I think they tend to target those children who are higher risk of not receiving necessary therapies (lower income, no insurance, poor living situations, etc). They have told us numerous times that it is such a nice break to come to our home compared to the majority of cases they see, because we are actively seeking out answers for our son and trying to get him the help he needs.

    So, for us, EI comes once a month to check on him and see where he is. He has a teacher, PT, and vision teacher.  His real therapy, though, comes from the 2x/week private therapy we take him to. When he was evaluated at 18 months, his expressive and receptive speech/language was at a 3-6 month old level. He has been receiving SLT since and is doing amazing! His EI team is so happy that we decided to take him, because in Iowa, they wouldn't be able to start him with a SLP until he was 2 1/2. He is also going to start some private PT, too, in order to help with his balance. If it is within your means, I *highly recommend* adding private therapies to his routine. You don't have to stop EI services, rather add to them. Hope this helps and good luck!

     ETA: I just want to stress the fact that I know that it is not within some people's budgets/insurance plans to be able to take their children to private therapies. I don't want to offend anyone in my post. We are blessed to both work for large companies that offer good benefits, so our son's annual out of pocket maximum for medical care and therapies is affordable.

    K, born 05/06/10 B, born with a few surprises 07/20/11  

    image
  • finsupfinsup member

    Although we had a good experience with EI, and he made good progress, looking back I think it would have been better for us financially if we had looked into private therapies.

    EI fees in our state were an income bases sliding scale.  Where we happened to land on the scale made the amount of money we paid for 1 hour a week of speech was ridiculous - but it didn't even occur to me at the time to check into private options. If I had I probably could have saved us a bundle.

  • This content has been removed.
  • We are doing both - EI comes monthly and DD goes to private PT weekly, her appointments are an hour each time.  They both focus on different things and leave me and DH with things that we need to continue working on with DD.  My DD has a physical disability so PT works her on using her wheelchair, helping her up/down from chairs and figuring out how to be mobile.  It's very targeted therapy focused specifically on mobility.  Because of her dx, there is a chance she could also have cognitive delays, which she doesn't today. EI looks at a more holistic view of her development, including physical development.  They make sure she's on track with her milestones and help us with things we can do in our home. 

    I like having EI come monthly because they can tell me if she is meeting the appropriate milestones.  It's been helpful to get tips and tricks from them, like using different signs and different games to play with her.  But there has been nothing like private PT to get her mobile.  Just a few sessions with her therapist have really done wonders for her.  I like EI.  I love PT!

    Lilypie Second Birthday tickers

  • It depends on the quality of your therapists. I will say that we are in a county that supposedly has great EI, and I found it to be an absolute waste of time compared to the private therapists we worked with. We finally just left EI eventually and went fully private, but our insurance covered most of this so it was feasible financially. Also, you might have better results focusing more on one particular therapy as opposed to an hour on 3 per week. For instance, when we went to private PT (with an excellent therapist) she had us double up and do twice per week. Same when we started speech. We also got nothing at all out of OT. It really depends on many factors, but if you are not seeing progress, it's at least worth an evaluation elsewhere.
    imageLilypie Premature Baby tickers imageLilypie Premature Baby tickers
  • St. Augbride you are fairly close to me. Can I ask where you guys are going for private therapy? You can PM me if you'd prefer. We're looking at private options for DS and struggling to find a good fit. He won't start therapies and preschool with the county until the fall since we are so close to the end of the school year. 
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageYellowLilies:
    Wondering if anyone has run into private insuance denying therapy if a child is eligible for ei?  We ran into this with ds1 but didn't fight it because he was getting so much therapy through ei.

    Nope, I don't think our insurance even questioned it.  We needed to have a letter sent to the insurance from our doctor stating why PT was medically necessary.  No one ever asked if we were eligible or enrolled in EI. 

    Lilypie Second Birthday tickers

  • imageKelleyBean:
    St. Augbride you are fairly close to me. Can I ask where you guys are going for private therapy? You can PM me if you'd prefer. We're looking at private options for DS and struggling to find a good fit. He won't start therapies and preschool with the county until the fall since we are so close to the end of the school year. 

    Sorry, just saw this! Sure, I'd be happy to. I loved our private therapists. For PT, we used Early Intervention Associates in Rockville, and I especially recommend working with Becky Leonard there. She's truly amazing. For speech and OT, we worked with ITS Developmental Services in Kensington--Anne Reynolds for speech and Teri Kozlowski for OT. All top notch in the area and highly recommend them! I feel like we encountered almost every specialist under the sun, so if you need any other recs, I'm happy to offer names. Let me know if you have any questions! 

     

    imageLilypie Premature Baby tickers imageLilypie Premature Baby tickers
  • We do both currently, and will as long as we can get insurance to pay for private. Private therapy does a lot more with her but we like the idea of our school district working with her and knowing us early on in the game.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • My son was evaluated by early intervention (not private) for speech issues at 15 months. The speech therapist has been coming now for 5 months and the progress has been amazing. 

    I haven't read all the comments, so you may have already answered this. What does your pedi say about your son's development?  

    Wyatt 9/6/2011 
    Tessa 7/5/2013
    Baby #3- ????? (ttc soon)


  • My son was finally approved for services after two failed attempts.  We needed Speech and Feeding therapy, but finally opted just for the speech.  He has received therapy for about 7 weeks now twice a week for 45 min, and the improvement is really amazing.  I am very satisfied with EI so far.
    Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"