For meals at home, or when visiting relatives....
What's your expectation for LO to stay at the table during meals? Especially once he or she has eaten and the meal is basically over? Do you have a time limit that you try to force him or her to "participate" in the meal, or do you let them get down and go as soon as behavior becomes undesirable/distracting for the other people trying to eat?
Re: s/o restaurant behavior
They sit as long as they're eating. Once they're done, they may be excused from the table -- there's no formal request to be dismissed or anything.
Most of our adult dinner conversation is better off without them being forced to stay at the table.
If we are home usually I give her a color book and crayons. Just so we can eat without wondering what she is up to in the other room.
This is my thinking, exactly.
I know that DD has about a 20 minute limit, from the time she is given her food, to the time she is ready to get out of her chair. I think that's pretty darn good for her age. At home, DH and I are generally done anyway, so we all get up and clean up together. If we are visiting family, I have no problem letting her get down to go play, if everyone is still hanging around the table talking. As long as she is within sight.
Twice recently, when she started getting antsy after about 20 minutes, my MIL made a remark to DD along the lines of, "I'm still eating, so you will have to wait to leave the table until I'm done." It was obvious she wasn't going to sit nicely any longer, so I just cleaned her up and let her go play. It just seemed silly to force her stay at the table for no good reason, at the expense of everyone else relaxing and finishing our meals. She was done eating.
Table etiquette is NOT the hill I'm going to die on with a one and a half year old. No way. No how. We always remind our kids to use their manners, and use of them is always positively reinforced, but like I said... table etiquette is not a toddler aged concept, IMHO.
As for a relative's, when she's done we clean her up and let her down. I feel she's too young to make her stay put.
See, I think this makes total sense and is appropriate for your DD1's age. I think my MIL can sometimes get a little ahead of herself in terms of what are age appropriate expectations. I can't really blame her, it's been 30 years since she had toddlers, I'm sure my memory will be hazy 30 years down the road!
IDK why it wont bold. This is why we keep DD at the table while we are eating. She is too little to understand she cannot keep coming up to pester and climb in our laps. For now she gets an activity to stay put, but when she is older, I plan to go with what you do with your dd1.
At home we are usually finished before she is so we wait for her (well I wait for her, SO has a bad habit of leaving the table - it drives me nuts). At a restaurant I bring books or toys for her to try and occupy herself with.
Lately she's on a hunger strike with her meals. She's not interested in anything we give her and thus wants to get down early. I have let her, but then she comes back asking to get in our laps which does not work. Like Dollface said I'd rather keep her in her chair for now until she understands what being excused means. There is so much going on with her right now developmentally that I'm trying to pick my battles.
I'm glad that my husband isn't the only one who gets up and leaves the table when he's done. It's so frustrating! I'm always like, umm, excuse me...we're still eating, and there's all this food to clean up! Taking your plate to the kitchen does not count!