I redirect. If she is hitting DD1 or one of the animals I tell her "gentle" or "nice" and move her from the situation. I don't feel that time outs work until they are over 2 and have verbal understanding.
I do the "mommy says no, we don't .blank" and redirect.
I have tried popping his hand recently for playing in the dog water for the 36785442th time in a day. It didn't phase him at all. So i guess I'm sticking with redirecting.
Redirect, redirect, redirect. I say no, but I try to follow up with a short reason why what she did wasn't good. I try not to say no all.the.time. though. I have never swatted her. They just don't understand that right now. If it is hard for me to keep a straight face, I just quickly redirect and look away.
Redirect and say no. i have to redirect because sometimes i want to laugh when I say "no", and I know that he will just want to do whatever he was doing again
For most things we just redirect. For tantrums we try to ignore her until she calms down. And we do timeouts for hitting/scratching because it was getting really out of control.
We don't really say "No." because she just laughs and does it again and I have tried swatting her hand but she also just laughs so that is why we went to timeouts, it has been pretty effective and now 90% of the time all we have to say is "Do you wanna go in your crib?" and she wont do it again.
Warning
No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
We pick our battles and have a handful of absolute "no-nos". Anything dangerous, being mean to the cats, or throwing food are the most common ones. If he does any of those, I honestly "yell" at him or say "No, that is not OK. You must be gentle to the kitties". The tone of my voice gets to him more than the words do. He doesn't like making me upset, so it stops him in his tracks.
Any lesser attempts, such as asking or politely telling him to stop, don't work at all. Redirecting usually causes a small tantrum when I remove the object or relocate him.
I would honestly be saying no all day long so I have learned to pick my battles.
The biggest thing is the dogs water. He wants to either put the kibbles in the water or his pacis in there and it's disgusting and makes a big mess. I have popped his hands a few times but I usually have to physically remove him. He knows without a doubt he isn't supposed to, but he just doesn't seem phased by anything.
It might not be the best method, but he's recently learned the word bad so I'm trying to give him certain actions and associate it with being bad. When I tell him it's bad, he actually [sometimes] moves on and repeats bad back to me.
We try to redirect and give a firm NO. However, sometimes I give a stern NO and she laughs at me, like when she's pulling on a cord or about to touch the fireplace. I have to hold her hand kind of hard and then move on to something else. It's frustrating but I just keep trying to be consistent.
Re: how do you discipline your LO?....
I swat DS's hand when the purposely drops food on the floor, and he usually laughs and does it again...
my read shelf:
I have tried popping his hand recently for playing in the dog water for the 36785442th time in a day. It didn't phase him at all. So i guess I'm sticking with redirecting.
Baby Boy #2 is on the way!
11.2011 - DS1
02.2013 - loss at 6 wks
06.2014 - DS2
10.2015 - loss at 12 wks
03.2017 - DD
For most things we just redirect. For tantrums we try to ignore her until she calms down. And we do timeouts for hitting/scratching because it was getting really out of control.
We don't really say "No." because she just laughs and does it again and I have tried swatting her hand but she also just laughs so that is why we went to timeouts, it has been pretty effective and now 90% of the time all we have to say is "Do you wanna go in your crib?" and she wont do it again.
We pick our battles and have a handful of absolute "no-nos". Anything dangerous, being mean to the cats, or throwing food are the most common ones. If he does any of those, I honestly "yell" at him or say "No, that is not OK. You must be gentle to the kitties". The tone of my voice gets to him more than the words do. He doesn't like making me upset, so it stops him in his tracks.
Any lesser attempts, such as asking or politely telling him to stop, don't work at all. Redirecting usually causes a small tantrum when I remove the object or relocate him.
MMC 3.30.16
The biggest thing is the dogs water. He wants to either put the kibbles in the water or his pacis in there and it's disgusting and makes a big mess. I have popped his hands a few times but I usually have to physically remove him. He knows without a doubt he isn't supposed to, but he just doesn't seem phased by anything.
It might not be the best method, but he's recently learned the word bad so I'm trying to give him certain actions and associate it with being bad. When I tell him it's bad, he actually [sometimes] moves on and repeats bad back to me.