Here's our girl list! Feel free to offer opinions.

MrsMandaK · February 2012

My other two children are Lily and Charlotte if that helps at all. Big Smile

Eliza
Marin
Victoria
Alice * current favorite, but not totally sold
Eden
Amelia
Violet
Gabrielle
Amaya
Savannah

bubblegummum · February 2012

I really like Alice, Eden, and Violet. I think they would work well with Lily and Charlotte too.

Michellie7 · February 2012

Nice looking list:) I "vote" for Violet... but Alice would fit very nicely with your sibset!

LemonBlush · February 2012

Amelia and Eliza would go great with your daughters names. I also love Maren.

Pearl16 · February 2012

Nice list! I really like Eliza with your other two girls, followed by Alice and Amelia. Marin is a good name, but it's not as feminine as Lily or Charlotte. I also really like Violet, but the fact that your first daughter already has a flower name would make me choose something else. Good luck!

Indynurse12 · February 2012

You have a great list! My first choice would be Eliza followed closely by Alice. Good luck deciding!

strawberrytree · February 2012

Oooh, I like! I think Eliza, Amelia, and Victoria would go best with your other girls, but Alice is my favourite overall from your list. It's so pretty but next to Charlotte and Lily I think it might come across as a bit simple. But hey, simple can be good!

Sunkiss028 · February 2012

I like Savannah and Gabrielle. The other names are not my style. Good luck!

AshleyC0117 · February 2012

My favorite is Violet (duh- see siggy) but I also LOVE Alice.

The only ones I don't really care for are Marin, Gabrielle and Amaya.

westrose · February 2012

My top three out of those names are Amelia, Violet, and Eliza.

I really do not like Eden and Amaya.

mlf625 · February 2012

Alice, 100%. You've got other pretty names on the list, too (Violet is my 2nd fave) but I love Alice.

TheWop · February 2012

Eliza - Ok, I like Elizabeth better
Marin - Ok
Victoria - Like
Alice * current favorite, but not totally sold - OK
Eden - Love!
Amelia - Meh
Violet - Meh
Gabrielle - LOVE!
Amaya - Don't like this, but I like Amara
Savannah- Don't like

Pictures29 · February 2012

Love Alice with those two! Victoria & Violet would be my next 2 choices in order.

alliejo725 · February 2012

All of your names are nice, so I'm going to comment on the ones that I think you should rule out:

Eden and Amaya are just such a different style from your daughters' names. They sound odd next to them. Since you have such a long list, I'd cut them.

Violet, while lovely, is also a flower---like Lily. I think it's sort of silly to use more than one floral name within a family.

Savannah works, but is also the name of a prominent city in the South, like Charlotte. I'd rule it out for the same reason as Violet.

With your daughters' names, out of the names left, I like Marin, Victoria, Alice and Amelia best.

BarefootRI · February 2012

Those are all such great names, you really can't go wrong. Eden is NMS and I'm not crazy about Victoria, but I like all the rest. I would avoid Savannah since you already have a Charlotte and that would technically be two "place names" (even though they are legitimate names).

My favorites are Eliza or Alice. I think either of those sound perfect with Lily and Charlotte. What I really like about Eliza (aside from loving the name) is that all three of your girls' names would end in a different sound.

jenwet · February 2012

westrose:
My top three out of those names are Amelia, Violet, and Eliza.
I really do not like Eden and Amaya.

I agree with this. Also think Maren (spelled this way) is beautiful.

alohamora · February 2012

I like Eliza, Victoria, Alice, Violet, and Gabrielle. I think Victoria, Eliza, and Alice fit into your sibset especially well. Nice names!

KarlsSweetie05 · February 2012

My favorite is Violet (but I'm biased as that is my daughter's name).

Love Violet, Lily, and Charlotte. All names go together and seem like sisters and names of the same era.

Though... some may not like that you have 2 flower names and one non-flower name.

and while I like others on your list (Victoria, Alice, Amelia), I don't think they go as well with your other daughter's names.

and I hate to say this, but I really don't like Alice with Lily and Charlotte. Don't know why as I like Alice in general, but not with your sibset when I say all 3 names out loud.

Really dislike Marin, Eden, Amaya. Seems to be different naming style than sisters.

Eh on Gabrielle and Savannah - doesn't go with other kids' names in my opinion.

Goodysgirl · February 2012

MrsMandaK:

My other two children are Lily and Charlotte if that helps at all.

Eliza
Marin
Victoria
Alice * current favorite, but not totally sold
Eden
Amelia
Violet
Gabrielle
Amaya
Savannah

You have great taste in names I love Alice and Gabrielle. However, I think Alice and Victoria sound best with Lily and Charlotte.

giraffe54 · February 2012

MrsMandaK:
My other two children are Lily and Charlotte if that helps at all.

Eliza - like
Marin - greatly prefer Maren, but it's lovely
Victoria - love, esp. with your sibset
Alice * current favorite, but not totally sold - also love
Eden - I love this name, but I think I'm the exception to the rule. Most hate it. I don't think it works well with your sibset
Amelia - like
Violet - this gets my top vote. I see no issue with two flower names
Gabrielle - like
Amaya - least favourite on the list given your sibset
Savannah - like Eden, I love it, but I may be the only one who feels that way

I don't think you can go wrong with this list, they're all lovely.

magsugar13 · February 2012

Love Gabrielle and amaya

eden is nice

PhilsWife07 · February 2012

I love Alice! It's classic, lovely, and way underused.

Eden is really pretty.

Amelia and Violet are two of my most-detested girls names and for some reason I often see them on lists together. I just don't like them at all.

Gabrielle and Victoria are pretty.

Marin (just makes me think marinade), Amaya (why does this make me think of The Ring every time I hear it?), and Savannah (I can't get behind this name at all. It's just not classy to my ear) are NMS.

AnneEB · February 2012

I like Alice a lot, Violet is pretty as well.

med380 · February 2012

Good names. LOVE Alice - I wanted this for our baby, but DH vetoed it. I also really like Eliza.

kisha16 · February 2012

I love the names Violet and Amelia! I think they work well with your other daughters names since they are all soft and feminine names.

becketts · February 2012

I think Victoria, Alice, or Violet would be very cute with your other names.

PitterPat11 · February 2012

Alice, Eden, Marin and Violet are my fav. I hate Savannah, just one of those names I dislike, nothing wrong with it I just dont like it. Also Eliza is getting popular, pretty but I have been hearing it a lot lately!

hjo2010 · February 2012

I like Alice and I think it goes great with your other two girls' names!

FrecklesInside · February 2012

Best: Eliza, Eden, Gabrielle

Hearing too much, getting boring: Amelia, Violet (I find this too poodle), Alice

Don't like: Marin, Victoria, Amaya, Savannah (not a fan of place names)

I see that Alice does sound nice with Charlotte an Lily but it's still kind of dated and boring to me - yet I hear it a lot on here. I think it's gaining in popularity. My favorites are Eliza, Eden and Gabrielle

I think Eliza is lovey with your Ds' names.