March 2013 Moms

MIL and name vent

So this is why I didn't want ANYONE to know the names we picked out. We are team green so we picked a boy and girls name (obviously). Anyways, for the boys name we chose a middle name that is DH family name to continue the tradition. In honor of my abuela and my aunt who is also my God mother we chose her name for a girls middle name. The name was supposed to be my name as well but my grandma talked my mom out of it. ANYWAYS, DH told MIL the name and she doesn't like it so of course DH is 'second guessing' the name. WTF.

What are your opinions on Amelia Esperanza (last name is german). She thinks that the name is too spanish and we need to change it um Amelia is german not spanish! Esperanza means Hope in English. I was the one that said Amelia Hope to begin with but DH was the one that doesnt like Hope for a mn and suggested Esperanza but now because of MIL is not sure. I already told my dad and he was so happy. He is from Spain but grew up in Venezuela and when we moved to the USA he only saw his mom once until she passed away. I thought this would be a great way to honor her.

 Sorry...I just needed to vent!

BabyFruit TickerBaby Birthday Ticker TickerAnniversary





Re: MIL and name vent

  • ETA:  Their Names - sorry Mobile site...abuela & her daughter (my aunt/God Mother) have the same name.
    BabyFruit TickerBaby Birthday Ticker TickerAnniversary





  • Loading the player...
  • I think your MIL needs to butt out and DH needs to not second guess. We also pick names to honor family, and I think your choices make sense and sound fine together. I like the Spanish version better than Hope.

    Hang in there... DS1 came home without a name because DH second guessed. And we ultimately went with what we were originally thinking!
    Mommy to Seth (4) and Catherine Anne (13 mo.) Excited to welcome a third child in March of 2013!
  • My sweet little cousin is named Amelia, so I love it!

     Lilypie Second Birthday tickers

    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • Very beautiful name.  It doesn't matter what anyone else thinks as long as you and DH like it.  Everyone else will get used to it and not give it a second thought a couple wks after the baby is born.
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Image and video hosting by TinyPic Why do they have to make it smell so good if you can't eat it?? BabyFruit Ticker
  • I LOVE the name Amelia. I kinda of wish I thought of it!!! And I think both Esperanza and Hope are beautiful. That sucks your DH is going to second guess his choice because of his mom..... it shouldn't be ANY of her business!
    Pregnancy Ticker
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    Photo of the Remarkables mountain range in Queenstown, New Zealand.
  • It is a beautiful name.
    5.18.11 Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker BabyFruit Ticker EDD 3.12.13
  • I love Spain and the culture. I wish I had some Spanish blood in me in order to use a name that is hispanic. You know what? It's a family name and you have a Spanish background so you should ask yoir MIL what she has against it? Won't hurt to be a little snitty if you ask me.
  • I agree with PP and it is a very beautiful name!
    Lilypie Pregnancy tickers


    EDD 10.26.15

    Garrett Samuel 1.30.14
    Vanessa Ruby 2.21.13
    Joseph Michael (born into Heaven) 6.17.10
    Rae Patricia 4.14.07





  • Easy.

    Tell MIL and H you're second guessing the boy's middle name, and that you think it's too "...".

    That'll shut him up. 

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imagevmihelci:
    I LOVE the name Amelia. I kinda of wish I thought of it!!! And I think both Esperanza and Hope are beautiful. That sucks your DH is going to second guess his choice because of his mom..... it shouldn't be ANY of her business!

     

    I completely agree with this! I LOVE Amelia!! And it sounds great with Esperanza! 

    Wedding Countdown Ticker
  • imagejessicadube:

    Easy.

    Tell MIL and H you're second guessing the boy's middle name, and that you think it's too "...".

    That'll shut him up. 

    this! haha. how would he feel if YOU shared the name that was personal to him and his family and were second guessing it based on someone else's reaction? Amelia Esperanza is beautiful! Esperanza is my husband's abuelita's name, too!

  • Love the name, it's great that it has that kind of meaning to you. It's doesn't matter what MIL thinks too bad. My Mom doesn't like the middle name we picked n I told her too bad we love it, she keeps telling me to change it but I tell her no. 

    Like it was said above tell him you are having 2nd thought about the boy name you picked, n if he changes the girl you get to change the boy name too.  

    BabyFruit Ticker Pregnancy Ticker CafeMom Tickers
  • That's a beautiful name! My mom had trouble with our middle name choice.  (For those of you on the moblie site, it's Marguerite.)  She's used to short middle names - ie, Ann, Lynn, Ruth etc.  I swear the first thing she said was, "That won't fit on the baby quilt I'm making."  I know she's also struggling with it cause we chose the name partially for a Catholic saint, and she has trouble with us baptizing  her/raising her Catholic.  (I know this post makes her sound unsupportive, but I swear she's really a wonderful and thoughtful mother.  She jut wears her feelings and thoughts on her sleeve.)  Anyway ... I stood my ground and I think the name is growing on her; either that or she knows I'm stubborn and she's accepting the facts. :)  Good luck!

    image

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    BabyFruit Ticker
  • Thanks everyone. You made me a little feel better. I just hope DH will stop listening to everything his mom says...especially since she put her 2 cents in about my BIL's name choice (they are due in April). BIL & SIL are holding their ground so why can't DH?!
    BabyFruit TickerBaby Birthday Ticker TickerAnniversary





  • This content has been removed.
  • It really doesn't matter what anyone on here says it matter what you and your husband have decided and NO ONE ELSE! I think Amelia Esperanza is a beautiful name!
    Lilypie First Birthday tickers image     Lilypie Second Birthday tickers  imageDaisypath Anniversary tickers  image


This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"