In your experience, is one better than the other? DS1 (5) still doesn't wake through the night to pee. We send him to the bathroom when we go to bed (anywhere from 10:00-12:00) and he wakes wet through the night most nights. We were using generic WM brand, he was leaking through that so we need something of better quality. I've tried Goodnites and they worked well, the prices on Amazon are higher for Goodnites than Underjams. It's worth the higher price if they work better, but as a SAHM with a family of 5, every penny counts (heck, when doesn't it in this economy).
GSx1 - 05/13/2013 GSx2 for T&B - EDD 6/21/2015 - They're having a GIRL!
I used both in the past. And DS would still wet his clothes and all. So we reverted back to pull-ups and wake him up 2-3 times a night. Its cheaper, but requires us to get up with him. On occasions he has done so himself. GL
The Goodnites work the best for us. Underjams leaked horribly. One thing you may also look into is a diaper doubler. One of my kiddos goes a lot a night and leaked all the time. Once we started using those with the Goodnites, we are down to one leaky night every week or so. MUCH better than nightly, especially now that they are out of their toddler beds.
Re: Goodnites vs. Underjams
We've used both based on which brand was on sale and I haven't noticed any major difference.
I recently got tired of buying them for my 4yo and switched over to a cloth version.
TTC #3: BFP 4/27/12, Ectopic 5/16/12 Expectant Management, 8/15/12 Cleared to TTC
BFP 9/25/12 EDD 6/6/13, Shooting 3-for-3 from the line: It's a Girl
PgAL/PAL Welcome
Charlotte Ella 07.16.10
Emmeline Grace 03.27.13