Blended Families

Yes I know it is none of my business

I know it is none of my business what ex spends his and his wifes money on....BUT excuse me if it pisses me off a bit when your son asks for help paying his truck insurance and you say no and turn around and buy a Harley one month later, especially after the lies in court about your income that allowed your child support to be cut in half.

Re: Yes I know it is none of my business

  • It's very frustrating, but you're right - it's none of your business. BD told me just last night he will be buying the iPhone 5 (outright, not through an upgrade) yet he has no money for new clothes and shoes for DS that fit, and he is living with his parents. It's all about priorities.
    image
  • Loading the player...
  • Very frustrating, I wouldn't give a crap about the reduction in child support if he would step up and help the kids with other things like insurance or clothes or shoes and I wouldn't care about the reduction if it was not based on big fat lies.  I just keep telling myself karma is a cold B*&^h.

     

  • Oh, man.

    When XH and I were going through the divorce he whined all the time about how he had no money for CS. He had no money to come see DS. He had no money for a carseat. Whine whine cry cry.

    Then I got his financial affidavit and saw where his money was going. $150 bouquets for his girlfriend. $100s on fast food every week. $300 for luggage to go see her. $500 plane tickets. I mean really.

    I called him on it one time. He was outright lying, and I cannot stand someone lying to my face. But after that, I was done with it. It's easier to just not know or not think about it.  

    my read shelf:
    Erin's book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)
  • Maybe I'm the only one, but its my personal opinion that a teenager can drive when they work to pay for their own insurance and gas.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageKaeldrasmommy:
    Maybe I'm the only one, but its my personal opinion that a teenager can drive when they work to pay for their own insurance and gas.

    I am with you there. 

  • On the flip side from the SM point of view...I make a good living and it infurates me that I have to justify what I spend my money on.  If I choose to buy my husband a new Harley, take vacations, buy a new car/house, it's really no one's business as long as CS is paid and needs are being met. 

     

  • Yeah, I don't think car insurance is a parent's responsibility.
    DD(14),SD(13),SS(11),SS(9),DS(3)

  • First, I want to say that I do not know your background or the tenor of your Ex and/or His wife.  Just like you do not know my background with DH, SS and BM.

    But you sound just like our BM when we, yet again, chose not to pay for SS's car insurance. 

    We actually HAVE custody of SS and our financial situation is okay, but not great.  Even if it were great, we are not paying for his car insurance (sure as hell wouldnt pay for a truck). 

    For us, its a two-fold lesson: forcing him to get a damn job and teaching him responsibility and the power of money.  But it does not bother me if the BF just doesnt think it is his responsiblity.  Because cars are not rights, they are priveleges.

    file:///Users/Ilumine/Desktop/Family%20Portrait%20for%20gift.jpg
  • My son and I have a deal that he works during the summer to pay for 6 months of the car insurance and I pay the other six months.  I fill his gas tank twice a month.  He plays several sports and is a senior in high school and had the opportunity to play some sports over the summer for elite athletes so that did not allow him to work as much as he could have otherwise.  There are rules to his vehicle and he helps transport his sibling a lot and keeps his grades up.  That is why he asked his dad for help he was short some of the money.
  • imagedocco11:

    On the flip side from the SM point of view...I make a good living and it infurates me that I have to justify what I spend my money on.  If I choose to buy my husband a new Harley, take vacations, buy a new car/house, it's really no one's business as long as CS is paid and needs are being met. 

     

    I agree but to tell your child that you cannot afford to help with something and then turn around and buy something expensive is to me a lie, had he said something like it was your responsibility and now you have to figure out how to handle it would have been different. The child support is generally a month or two behind also, which considering how some people never see a dime I am thankful.

  • image&babymakes5:
    imagedocco11:

    On the flip side from the SM point of view...I make a good living and it infurates me that I have to justify what I spend my money on.  If I choose to buy my husband a new Harley, take vacations, buy a new car/house, it's really no one's business as long as CS is paid and needs are being met. 


     



    I agree but to tell your child that you cannot afford to help with something and then turn around and buy something expensive is to me a lie, had he said something like it was your responsibility and now you have to figure out how to handle it would have been different. The child support is generally a month or two behind also, which considering how some people never see a dime I am thankful.

    I think the only time its your business is like you said, CS payments aren't being made, needs aren't being met. Otherwise I'd tell you to butt out.
  • Maybe the BD can't afford it, but the SM can?  We are obvisouly not in the same situation as we have never been behind or missed a CS payment.  I can tell you that if my SD or BM came to us, asked MH for car insurance, he says "no, I can't afford it"  (which would be a true statement) but then they throw out "how come you can afford XYZ" I would be hella mad. I shouldn't have to justify that we spend my income on and our priorities as long as SK'd needs (not wants) are being met.  My income and what we do with it should never be questioned.

     

  • can tell you that if my SD or BM came to us, asked MH for car insurance, he says "no, I can't afford it"  (which would be a true statement) but then they throw out "how come you can afford XYZ" I would be hella mad. I shouldn't have to justify that we spend my income on and our priorities as long as SK'd needs (not wants) are being met.

     

     

    My son would never say this to his father.  Second his dad expects him to drive himself and his sister over to his house for visits, don't you think if he wants him to drive 100 miles round trip he should maybe contribute something to the vehicle?

     

  • image&babymakes5:
    My son and I have a deal that he works during the summer to pay for 6 months of the car insurance and I pay the other six months.  I fill his gas tank twice a month.  He plays several sports and is a senior in high school and had the opportunity to play some sports over the summer for elite athletes so that did not allow him to work as much as he could have otherwise.  There are rules to his vehicle and he helps transport his sibling a lot and keeps his grades up.  That is why he asked his dad for help he was short some of the money.

    First let me start by saying that it's fantastic that your son was afforded the opportunity to play with an elite program over the summer.  I know those programs are done based on tryouts and kids have to qualify and be invited to participate.

    However, this is a great learning experience for your son.  As adults, sometimes we aren't able to do everything we want to do because there are other things that need to be done.  When I was in High School I played volleyball.  I was invited to play for a travel team that was always heavily recruited by colleges.  It was the perfect opportunity to get some exposure and possibly a scholarship.  But I had to pay for my car insurance and gas.  I was an AP student, editor of the Yearbook and played volleyball, and my parents made me pay my own car insurance.  I knew that having practices 4 days a week and traveling every weekend would leave me zero time to work, so I declined the invite.  It sucked, but I knew that without car insurance I didn't have a car.  Did it suck?  Yup.  But that's life.

    As for what BD buys, you're right it's none of your business.  I completely understand your frustration.  My children's father owes me more than 20k in CS and yet he always manages to have a new car, new cellphone, new quads, etc.  He works for cash so the State can't garnish anything.  And yet somehow, he spins it so I'm the bad guy.  Because really, how dare I expect him to provide for his children when I'm remarried, own a business with my husband, and work.  It's a crap situation, yes.  But your BD is paying his CS.  And your son is a Senior in High School and is capable of working and paying for his own insurance.  We all wish that our BMs/BDs would do more for our kids, but we can't make them do more than what the CO specifies.

    image

    Created by MyFitnessPal - Free Weight Loss Tools



  • image&babymakes5:
    imagedocco11:

    On the flip side from the SM point of view...I make a good living and it infurates me that I have to justify what I spend my money on.  If I choose to buy my husband a new Harley, take vacations, buy a new car/house, it's really no one's business as long as CS is paid and needs are being met. 


     



    I agree but to tell your child that you cannot afford to help with something and then turn around and buy something expensive is to me a lie, had he said something like it was your responsibility and now you have to figure out how to handle it would have been different. The child support is generally a month or two behind also, which considering how some people never see a dime I am thankful.


    I get why you are annoyed. But this insurance agreement was between you and DS and he did not make his part of the bargain and that was a choice. Either you decide he did enough and pay the rest or you decide to stick to the agreement and he does not get to drive. If I were you and my SD is turning 23 and live with us in middle and high school I would not allow money from BD to pay for DS' responsibility because it tells him that he can ask others to pay his way when he does not work hard enough. If you choose to pay it then it would be with the understanding that the extra sports helped him earn it from you. Oh, and driving your other kids around does not make BD responsible, it might have made him less inclined.
    Jen - Mom to two December 12 babies Nathaniel 12/12/06 and Addison 12/12/08
  • image&babymakes5:

    My son would never say this to his father.  Second his dad expects him to drive himself and his sister over to his house for visits, don't you think if he wants him to drive 100 miles round trip he should maybe contribute something to the vehicle?

    Honestly?  No.  Your son is a Senior in High School, has access to a vehicle and is capable of working to pay his own insurance and gas.  My parents made me pay my own car insurance and gas when I was in High School, and I come from an intact family.  My parents could have easily afforded to pay all my expenses but they thought it was more important to teach me to do it myself.  Granted, if I needed new tires or some major repairs to the car then my parents would cover it, but I was expected to pay it back in full. 

    And if your son isn't going to drive himself for the visits, what is the other option?  Either you will have to drive the kids or BD will have to come get them.  I'm counting down the years until K can drive and transport herself to and from houses so that we can limit our interaction with BM.  I cannot wait for the day we no longer have to plan everything around pick-up and drop-off times. 

    image

    Created by MyFitnessPal - Free Weight Loss Tools



  • I'm with OP. If her son is potentially a talented athlete with a college future, BD should man up and help his son out. Both me and my cousin got a full ride athletic scholarships because of our hard work and talent and all the opportunities we took to be even better athletes. I absolutely think that in those situations, kids should be able to take a full advantage of their athletic opportunities and parents on both sides should pay for transportation expenses. Not helping him with car expenses is sh*tty, IMO. I look at it this way, when you are talented and colleges are looking at you, your parents need to look at it as your "job" already, not some petty after school job that could kill the bigger opportunity. I was able to save my parents' tens of thousands for college thanks to my athletic abilities. I'm glad my parents weren't petty or selfish and saw the bigger picture....what's best for their kid.
  • imagejobalchak:
    image&babymakes5:

    My son would never say this to his father.  Second his dad expects him to drive himself and his sister over to his house for visits, don't you think if he wants him to drive 100 miles round trip he should maybe contribute something to the vehicle?

    Honestly?  No.  Your son is a Senior in High School, has access to a vehicle and is capable of working to pay his own insurance and gas.  My parents made me pay my own car insurance and gas when I was in High School, and I come from an intact family.  My parents could have easily afforded to pay all my expenses but they thought it was more important to teach me to do it myself.  Granted, if I needed new tires or some major repairs to the car then my parents would cover it, but I was expected to pay it back in full. 

    And if your son isn't going to drive himself for the visits, what is the other option?  Either you will have to drive the kids or BD will have to come get them.  I'm counting down the years until K can drive and transport herself to and from houses so that we can limit our interaction with BM.  I cannot wait for the day we no longer have to plan everything around pick-up and drop-off times. 

    According to our CO BD would have to pick up and drop off the kids for visitation.  I am sorry I think if he is not going to do that then he needs to give his son some gas money or help with the insurance when he is driving the vehicle to his dads house it would be different if we lived close but 100 miles round trip is something else.

  • image&babymakes5:

    can tell you that if my SD or BM came to us, asked MH for car insurance, he says "no, I can't afford it"  (which would be a true statement) but then they throw out "how come you can afford XYZ" I would be hella mad. I shouldn't have to justify that we spend my income on and our priorities as long as SK'd needs (not wants) are being met.

     

     

    My son would never say this to his father.  Second his dad expects him to drive himself and his sister over to his house for visits, don't you think if he wants him to drive 100 miles round trip he should maybe contribute something to the vehicle?

     

    I think this complicates matters. I would think that your ex would be responsible for some of the costs to see his kids if they are CO'd visits, if he isn't the one doing the traveling. But gas money would probably be the way to handle that as you have a previous arrangement with your DS regarding the insurance. But on the other hand your DS will need to learn to prioritize. Are his sports more important to him than time with his father?
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagehopanka:
    I'm with OP. If her son is potentially a talented athlete with a college future, BD should man up and help his son out. Both me and my cousin got a full ride athletic scholarships because of our hard work and talent and all the opportunities we took to be even better athletes. I absolutely think that in those situations, kids should be able to take a full advantage of their athletic opportunities and parents on both sides should pay for transportation expenses. Not helping him with car expenses is sh*tty, IMO. I look at it this way, when you are talented and colleges are looking at you, your parents need to look at it as your "job" already, not some petty after school job that could kill the bigger opportunity. I was able to save my parents' tens of thousands for college thanks to my athletic abilities. I'm glad my parents weren't petty or selfish and saw the bigger picture....what's best for their kid.

    I was able to earn a volleyball scholarship and work part-time to pay for my car insurance and gas in High School.  I don't see anything wrong with telling kids they need to take responsibility for the extras they want.  If I didn't work to pay for my car expenses, then my parents would have had to drive me around everywhere.  They would have gladly done that, but I wanted the freedom of being able to drive myself. 

    As PP said, the agreement regarding the insurance and gas was made between OP and DS, not BD.  He had no say in the matter, and to expect him to be bound by that agreement is wrong.

    image

    Created by MyFitnessPal - Free Weight Loss Tools



  • Ok OP, you stared on this whole rant about how BD won't pay the insurance and how you are bitter because he can buy things for himself but not pay for things your son should be responsible for. Piece by piece you add things to try and justify it. 

    Why wasn't dad included in the deal in the first place?  If your son is driving himself and sis 100 miles round trip then there should have been some sort of agreement before this even took place or Dad could have kept on picking them up the way CO states.  I really do feel like you brought this upon yourself as well, especially since we really don't know the whole story. 

    You decided to make a deal just including you and your son- Dad wasn't part of the deal.  Now if son can't drive because of no insurance or can't afford the gas then it is time for dad to start to do pick ups and drop offs again.  That simple.

  • Your right there are 12 years of history behind this whole story and I am not getting in to all that as the past is the past.  I know I made the deal.  I know my son asked for a little help, not all the money.  He was not asking to get out of work.  I am tired of seeing my kids lied to and that what this was a lie.  You are right I can't make the man contribute and I will continue to pay for the gas that my son uses to go to his dads  becasue if I don't he will never see him.  I refuse to ever let it be said that I am the reason my kids don't see BD.  With that being said it can still annoy the H*&L out of me, which is what it does.
  • imagepiffle42:
    imageDaringMiss:

    imageKaeldrasmommy:
    Maybe I'm the only one, but its my personal opinion that a teenager can drive when they work to pay for their own insurance and gas.

    I am with you there.

    I agree that kids should at least contribute.  My parents paid to insure the car, but I paid for the insurance that actually covered me.  Being on their plan gave me a discount I wouldn't have been able to get on my own.  But it's all about teaching responsibility!

    That was the arrangement for the most part when I lived with my mother and when I lived with my aunt as a teenager. It benefited all of us, because they were required to cover me as a minor driver under their insurance whether I drove their vehicles or not.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Why would you think he is obligated to pay for insurance?
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"