Babies: 9 - 12 Months

First birthday drama - opinions

For the past few weeks I have been actively planning my daughters first birthday however was having difficulty nailing down the guest list.  With immediate family only our number was at 31. Our house could definitely not accommodate 31 people - so we were torn on what to do....not have a party at all? Cut out some of our family and risk them getting upset they werent included in her day?  Well at the same time I was planning my daughters bday party, my sister-in-law was planning my niece's 4th birthday party which is November 18 (my daughers is October 13).  This past tuesday my sister-in-law found a small room at a local hall that was extremely affordable and could accommodate up to 50 people - she booked it for November.  I joked with my mom and husband that if I booked that hall all my problems would be solved as we could have all our family plus a few of my daughters "friends" come.  My husband said it sounded good and encouraged me to go and have a look at it.  That same day I went to view the room - it was very plain but the perfect size and best of all - all the pre and post party cleaning was included!  I booked the room on the spot.  Well the next day I found out that my brother and and sister-in-law were disappointed with me that I did not ask for their permission to book that room since they had booked it first for my niece's party.  They said I was disrespectful and inconsiderate and that I "took the wind out of their sails".  Well I immediately cancelled the room and had to completely change plans 3 weeks before my daughters first birthday.  I then emailed my brother to let him know that I didnt intend to upset anyone and that there was "no hard feelings".  However they still continue to be upset with me as this whole thing has gotten out of hand.  Finally my question to you ladies - Should I have asked for their permission before booking the room?  Was I disrespectful?  It's driving me crazy and has caused a huge riff in my family.  Thanks and sorry for the long post!

Re: First birthday drama - opinions

  • They are being a bunch of babies.  It is a room, its not like you stold the theme and the day they wanted.

    My sisters and I have rented the same room for all of our wedding and baby showers, my DD's b-day and my neices b-day. No biggie.

    photo a42489fa-98a3-436b-b31b-266d7d204e5d_zpsde5f201a.jpg
    my read shelf:
    Molly's book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)Follow Me on Pinterest
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    Anniversary
  • Loading the player...
  • First, I totally understand your dilemma! We're in the same boat - a HUGE family, and a not so huge house... :) I haven't started planning anything yet, but I've started thinking about it. I'm not sure what I'm going to do yet. As for the double booking, I can kind of understand them being bummed. Basically, it's the same party that htey were planning - same people, same room. And yours would be first, even though they found the venue. I'm SURE it wasn't intentional, on your part, and as soon as you called it off, they shoudl have been FINE. I'm sure everything will be fine when everyone has a chance to cool off. Good luck - sometimes family politics suck.... ;)
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imagembgreenwalt:
    They are being a bunch of babies.nbsp; It is a room,nbsp;its not like you stold the theme and the day they wanted.
    My sisters and I have rented the same room for all of our wedding and baby showers, my DD's bday and my neices bday. No biggie.
    I agree. It's a room, and they are being stupid. If the room is still available I would snag it again.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagelittlebriderachel:
    First, I totally understand your dilemma! We're in the same boat - a HUGE family, and a not so huge house... :) I haven't started planning anything yet, but I've started thinking about it. I'm not sure what I'm going to do yet. As for the double booking, I can kind of understand them being bummed. Basically, it's the same party that htey were planning - same people, same room. And yours would be first, even though they found the venue. I'm SURE it wasn't intentional, on your part, and as soon as you called it off, they shoudl have been FINE. I'm sure everything will be fine when everyone has a chance to cool off. Good luck - sometimes family politics suck.... ;)

    Aside from the fact that they didn't double book since the parties are in separate months it's an empty room.  A blank canvas.  I find it a bit high-schoolish for someone to stamp their feet around crying about another relative using the same hall for their party.  It's not like they're both having it at Bounce-A-Rama, which would then be almost the exact same party (and still lame to be upset, IMO.)  It's a frickin' hall.  Each family can decorate it for their parties as different as they want it to be.  This is just as lame as those posts about someone's friend having the same wedding colors as theirs did.  They don't own the patent or license to have only their party there!

    OP, I don't think you should've cancelled your reservation.  You just basically rewarded their infantile behavior and gave them permission to control you.  Now you will NEVER be able to throw your child's party at any location that they've chosen because they saw it first, wah wah wah.

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • wow you should be upset with them for being so upset about something so silly.
    Started TTC - 01/2009 1st BFP - 09/04/09,1st u/s - 10/06/09- no heartbeat seen, D&E - 10/13/09 BFP #2 - 2/12/10, m/c 2/17/10 BFP #3 - 01/03/11 m/c 01/10/11 BFP #4 - 02/21/11 DS born 10/13/2011 Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • If it was me and they were still upset about it I would reschedule it for the same place.  Especially since they are still upset over it.  How childish of them.

    Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers
  • imageKaeldrasmommy:
    imagembgreenwalt:
    They are being a bunch of babies.nbsp; It is a room,nbsp;its not like you stold the theme and the day they wanted.
    My sisters and I have rented the same room for all of our wedding and baby showers, my DD's bday and my neices bday. No biggie.
    I agree. It's a room, and they are being stupid. If the room is still available I would snag it again.

    All of this, I would have kept the reservation, its just a room. I can see being upset if you stole their theme but what's the big deal, its just a room!!
    BFP #1 August 2007, Lost Nov 2007, no heartbeat found at anatomy ultrasound at 19 wks
    BFP #2 March 2011, Baby Girl born November 2011!!!
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I'm agreeing with others, seems childish of them to act the way they are. It would be different if there wasn't almost a whole month between your LO's birthday and your niece's. Plus I think they should be able to support you guys in making it through the first year, after all they've had FOUR birthdays with their daughter. I'd be pissed with them for making a big deal about something so petty, I wouldn't let it control me though. Good luck, do what you feel is best for you and your family. Also, I'd tell them if they are going to be sour pusses, they aren't welcome to come to the party!
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I feel like we have the same family members!Smile  Some of mine are crazy weird uptight about dumb stuff like what you are describing.  I don't know why people spend their lives being so miserable and making issues where there are none. 

    I'm sorry that you are dealing with that, and I think they sound ridiculous to be upset over something like that.  I am glad, however, that other people have crazy family members and I'm not the only one.  I say that with a lot of humor.

  • I can see where they could be upset about not being consulted as they were the ones who told you about it in the first place. That being said if they are STILL whinnying about it after you canceled than they are just being big babies and need to get over it. You meant no harm, apologized, and canceled your plans so they should be satisfied. I would apologize again and ask what more they want from you? As for your house being to small, we have a 3 bedroom ranch with a 2/3 finished basement, that's about 1000sq ft and we've managed a party of 45 people in the middle of winter, three times and will again this Dec for DD2s 1st birthday (both my girls are Dec babies, and their baptisms were in Feb.), so you may be able to manage a larger party than you think, plus not everyone you invite will show up. At the parties we had 45ppl we invited over 60.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • First off their reaction is ridiculous, rude and entitled! I would have told them to shove it as it isn't there property, and they have no say in where you have your daughter's party!

    I think you should go back and see if the place is still available and they'll get over it. 

    I'm having a very similar problem, I really want to have DD's party at our home. We have a really nice apartment and it's roomy... just not roomy enough for 36 people... and that's just family that I want there... not including the 10-12 more who will be pissed if they aren't invited. So I'm sending invites out to only the most important family members and friends and an informal word-of-mouth invite too the others and we're still having it at our home. What I'm going to do is have an open 4 hours and people can come and go as they please, arrive whenever, leave whenever. I'm hoping that will alleviate the packed house problem a bit.

    Proud babywearing, breastfeeding, vaccinating SAHM of 2U2!
    imageLilypie - (qCSN)Lilypie - (5rzN)imageDaisypath Anniversary tickers




  • I had to book a room too. Can you find another one? Maybe it would have been nice to get the info on the room from them, and say you think it would be a good idea to get their reaction...but not necessary. It's a public place to rent.
    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers Anniversary
  • F U C K them!  I wouldn't have canceled the room, they can suck it.
  • Agree with brighteyes2123.  I would go ahead and rebook if you still can.
  • They probably wanted kudos for finding this place first.  I would make sure to thank and congratulate them at the party for such a great find.  'You just couldn't help but copy their great idea!"
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"