Get them on Amazon so you can try a few sizes. I got a half-size bigger than DS1's current size, and they stretched out so much he doesn't want to wear them (he has shoe issues, though). I got DS2 his true size, and they seem like they should be ok even if they stretch out.
TOMS don't actually run small IME. They're a little tighter when you put them on and then they conform to your feet. I can't wait to get DD a pair...if she doesn't get them for her birthday I'll get them for a Christmas gift.
I can't wait to get T some pink glittery ones. She was in between sizes last time I tried them on her, so we decided to wait till the Fall to get some since they are a bit pricey. They only have whole sizes, not half.
Re: Tiny Toms?
DS2 - Oct 2010 (my VBAC baby!)
TTC #1 since 8/09, Dx MFI 4/10
IUI #1: 6/10 = Cancelled, IUI #2: 7/10 = Cancelled, IVF #1: 9/10 = BFP
Baby girl arrived - 6/14/11
TTC #2
IVF #2 - Oct/Nov 2012: 11/5 - eSET - 7 Frosties - BFP
Baby girl arrived - 7/17/13
TTC #3
FET #1 6/21/18
Layne-May 6, 2013
Callie-February 14, 2011