My dd just turned 4. I am concerned about her ability or lack thereof to express her sad feelings... if something makes her feel sad she doesn't want to talk about it,For example, the other day we were watching a TV show and something on it made her sad, I could tell she was sad and tried to comfort her and reassure her and she kept insisting she was fine and then burst into tears but kept saying she was fine... After some time I finally got her to tell me she was sad because she didn't like the idea on the show (it was the fresh beat band graduation episode and they were talking about graduating and not being a band anymore...) I felt so badly that she couldn't/wouldn't let herself feel sad about it and know it was okayto feel sad... I'm concerned I am doing something that is making her feel this way... can't think of what, I always try to acknowledge her good and bad feelings and am at a loss... she also has difficulty with any kind of conflict on TV (like she gets upset at Chuggington because they typically learn from their mistakes and she gets very upset before they make their mistake and doesn't want to watch it... her brother enjoys the show which is the only reason it is on and i try to get her to do something else with me while he watches... ) anyway I am wondering if it is the age and/or maybe we should cut out tv we prob watch about 1 to 2 hours a day tops... but then I don't want to excessively shield her from the idea of conflict like on Chuggington... I don't know guess I am just wondering if anyone else has experience with this and what their thoughts are... TIA
Re: Helping Preschooler express sad feelings
If these incidences tend to be TV related then yes, I'd turn it off. There's a difference in "shielding" her from real life emotions and experiences vs. shielding her from a 30 minute episode that doesn't always accurately depict the natural time line progression of conflict, emotion and resolution. If she can't handle it well at this age then turn it off and try exposing her to it again down the road once she's a bit more mature. Focus more on dealing with expressing emotions in a real life context first.
The next time she's sad about something that's happening to HER encourage her to talk about it. She may be able to communicate better about being sad about something in real life that's happening to her vs. sad about something happening to a character on a show.
Beyond that the only suggestion I have is to take time to talk about your own feelings. The next time something happens that makes YOU sad tell her what you're feeling. We're dealing with this a lot right now with my Dad going thru cancer. I get sad. I cry. I can't always hide it from them even though I try not to expose them to too much of it. I try to explain it to the boys. One of them seems fine with it while the other gets really upset and tells me he's sad that I'm sad. It's life and it's what's happening to our family. I use it as a chance to explain to them that I am sad and that's OK. I tell them what I'm feeling and why and then explain to them all the positive things we have going in our lives and how that makes me feel happy and in the end I have WAY more happy in my life than sad but it's OK to express both.
Modeling labeling, expressing and dealing with emotions is the number one way they learn about them.
At 4 it's hard to find the words to express emotions sometimes.
Another thought is to hit the library for books specifically talking about identifying emotions. You can search in advance of your trip or talk to a librarian once you're there. I've found our librarians can put their hands on a half dozen books about almost any topic if I'll just ask for their help. We've used them for everything from potty training to first dentist trips to naming and expressing emotions.
Total score: 6 pregnancies, 5 losses, 2 amazing blessings that I'm thankful for every single day.