Being July birthdays this will definitely be a topic of discussion for when to start school, like kindergarten. This has been a huge topic for my family. My nephew is a July 28 birthday and my sister basically sent him to kindergarten the day after her turned 5 to avoid paying for childcare (in the south school starts in early August and it is very typical for people to hold their kids with late birthday, and a late birthday could be as "early" as May!!) So my nephew goes to school with kids that are almost a whole year older then him.
Personally I think it depends on the kid, my nephew would have benefited from another year of preschool to develop more socially. I know a lot of families that try to "bred" a fall baby so they can start late and have an upper hand in sports.
Being that DD's birthday is the 20th I think we will wait to start her, since we will probably live in the south and school starts so early here.
What will or did you do?
Re: When will you send your LO to school?
This. We have friends who had a baby a week after us and they had made the decision to "red shirt" before he was even born since he has a July birthday. I think its ridiculous to even consider making a decision until you are closer to the time to register for kindergarten. DD could have started kindergarten this year based on academic and social milestones (at age 3.5) but obviously we will wait until she is 5. If DS follows her he would be bored out of his mind staying in preschool any longer than absolutely necessary. However, as a PP pointed out boys do tend to lag a lot of times so its completely possible we will wait. I will make the decision over the winter before he turns 5 using the guidance of our pediatrician, my parental instincts, and his preschool teachers.
I agree completely; I just believe it's too early to tell.
She will have just turned 5 when we send her. Isn't that the normal age for a kindergartener?
If she needs to be held back, so be it but I'm going to at least give her the chance.
I plan to send DS to kindergarten when he turns 5, and plan to do 1/2 days in preschool at 4 too.
My bday is the 22nd of July, and I was 17 when I graduated so I was among the youngest in my class. It didn't impact me socially or academically other than being sad I had to wait to drive lol.
Not too long ago I read something about the drawbacks to redshirting, especially for sports advantage. That it actually isn't the great advantage for sports or academically, especially as the kids get older. Basically it's a bad idea because kids need to be challenged both in physical and mental tasks to excel. Obviously if the child is struggling that's a different scenario.
We are going to start pre-school at age 4 and see how she is adjusting in pre-school. If the pre-school instructor and us feel that she is ready to enter kindergarten then we'll enroll her when she is 5. If we don't think she is ready we'll do another year of pre-school and then start kindergarten.
My birthday is in September, right after Labor day, and I started before I was 5 and then had to do kindergarten twice, because I was not developmentally ready. All through elementary and middle school I hated birthday time because I was always older and, being a kid, I felt I had to tell people I was held back in kindergarten. It was a little emotionally scaring for me. I would rather DD do pre-school twice and be a ready and adjusted for kindergarten then to do what I did. Lots of kids do pre-school for multiple years before starting kindergarten.
In our district, you have to be 5 by Oct 1 to enter kdg, unless you pay for testing to test in earlier. When i was little, we started school at 4, and we've always been the youngest in our class (sorry to say "we," I'm a twin). :-) They used to be more flexible with ages for kdg entry when I was little, but they've tightened up their policies considerably over the last 25 years.
BFP: 7/5/10 EDD: 3/13/11 Miscarriage 8/1/10 at 8 weeks
BFP: 10/30/10 EDD: 7/7/11 Born 7/11//11 7lb12oz, 20 in.
BFP: 7/30/13 EDD: 4/9/14 Born right on time on his due date! 8lb10oz, 21.5 in.
Awesome prophetic fortune cookie: Love is a present that can be given every single day you live