Blended Families

Would it be completely awful if....

SD did not come to my uncle's house this summer when we plan on going??? Background we have my SD EOW and 2 weeks on 2 weeks off in the summer. My DH and I were thinking about visiting my aunt and uncle who live in virginia, as i have not been able to see them in several year and we are saving up to take my SD and DD to disneyworld next year. I only am asking this bc we live in michigan and in order for our SD to come with us out of state we have to have permission from BM. BM in the past put up a fit when we tried to take her to ohio last summer for my family reunion. She flat out refused to let her come and said if we did take her she would call the police and claim that DH was kidnapping her. (I dont think it would of worked but didnt feel that SD needed to see or hear any of the drama.) BM does not like any family function that involves myself or my family, and will frequently make comments about my family in front of SD. So im asking would it be horrible if we did not take SD if we go visit my uncle??

Re: Would it be completely awful if....

  • So you'd rather just leave your SD at home on a family trip because you want to avoid the headache, stress and drama that BM will cause? How is this any different than needing her 'permission' to go to Disneyworld next year?

    I'm in MI as well, and I can tell you that parental kidnapping is only when the NCP is intentionally trying to withhold the child from the CP for a period of 24 hours or more. BM would be hard-pressed to prove this when you're going on a family vacation -- your DH isn't trying to 'steal' your SD.
    ETA: Is it in your CO that you need to have her permission to travel OOS?

    imageimageimage

    image

  • Loading the player...
  • firstly, is it in your CO that you need written permission when traveling OOS?

    if yes, then it might be trickier, but you could atleast approach BM and ask.  if she flips a nutty and doesn't let SD go, thats on her, not you guys

    if its NOT in the CO then make sure you have in writing which weeks you will be having SD for summer vacation (even though it alternates I would atleast send BM an E-mail just to "clarify" that the weeks of 123-456 you have SD for summer break.  that way if she DOES try to call the cops, you have the proof that it is your visitation time. 

    I can see where it seems easier to just do it during the time you don't have her, but I would ATLEAST try.  if BM doesn't allow it, you can explain THAT to SD.  

    would there be things for SD to do while on the trip? age appropriate places to visit and other cousins/ relatives to play with? 

                           
                         View Full Size Image  View Full Size Image
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I agree that you should at least try.  Plan your trip during the 2 weeks you have SD.  Maybe just inform BM of your plans after you have SD with you (I know this is sneaky, but sometimes you have to be).

    If it doesn't work out then BM has to tell SD why she couldn't go.

    Make your plans to visit your family and try to make it work. 

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker My birthson who came before I was ready. He doesn't call me mom but I love him just the same. ~7/10/99~
  • Put something in writing stating you are planning to take her out of the state from X-X period of time.  CC is to FOC and send it to the BM certified so she has to sign for it.  If she has a problem with it then teh responsibility falls onto her to file a motion to prevent it from happening.  It's especially easy if you are in Oakland, Livingston, or Macomb County.

    I think it would be lame not to include your step child in the vacation plans.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • If you're just trying to save yourself the hassle then yes that's awful. Of course you should in no way set yourself up to be arrested but you should do everything you can to make sure she gets to visit family. After all that is her family now too.
  • Our CO is in Michigan (where BM lives) and we dont have that clause in ours but by definition they have to go out of state to see DH so maybe thats the difference. If its in the CO, ask BM and if she says no then proceed anyways. If its NOT in the CO then plan the trip during your visitation.
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Michigan in the house!! Woot Woot! lol


    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • you can tell her you are going out of state without telling her why. she doesn't need to know why other then you are going for a visit.
  • It would be a mistake to not try and bring her. But this is not a situation entirely within your control, so if you try and fail, I don't think you should cancel your trip.

    my read shelf:
    Erin's book recommendations, liked quotes, book clubs, book trivia, book lists (read shelf)
  • I must be in the minority. I don't think it would be awful if you and DH went on this trip when SD is with her mom for her regularly scheduled time (not missing out on time with you guys at all). If you know you all are planning a family vacation to Disneyworld soon, there will be lots of family time in the future. You are setting time aside as a family, so one trip with just DH isn't going to break the family bond. 
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagemschocokitty:
    I must be in the minority. I don't think it would be awful if you and DH went on this trip when SD is with her mom for her regularly scheduled time (not missing out on time with you guys at all). If you know you all are planning a family vacation to Disneyworld soon, there will be lots of family time in the future. You are setting time aside as a family, so one trip with just DH isn't going to break the family bond. 

    I agree, though I think it also depends on how close your SD is with your side of the family.  Would she be upset if you went without her?

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • No she does not know this part of my family as we do not get to see them very much either. She would be upset if my parent and sister went on the trip with us as she is close with them but we they are not going. Our CO state that the other parent needs to ok an out of state travels, not sure why but w/e. Thanks ladies for all of the input!!!!
  • Unless it states in the custody arrangement that neither party may leave the state with the child without the expressed permission of the other parent, then it is fine for you and your husband to take her out of state for a trip during your visitation time. If it is joint custody that means that while your husband has visitation he gets to call the shots on what you guys do for entertainment, including vacations.

    If she tried to approach an attorney about this they would laugh in her face. I can't believe she would seriously begrudge her daughter the opportunity to travel with her father for a family vacation. She sounds ridiculous. 

    BabyFruit Ticker
  • imagesuze423:

    imagemschocokitty:
    I must be in the minority. I don't think it would be awful if you and DH went on this trip when SD is with her mom for her regularly scheduled time (not missing out on time with you guys at all). If you know you all are planning a family vacation to Disneyworld soon, there will be lots of family time in the future. You are setting time aside as a family, so one trip with just DH isn't going to break the family bond. 

    I agree, though I think it also depends on how close your SD is with your side of the family.  Would she be upset if you went without her?

    This.  If SD is close to the people you are visiting it is different but assuming that she barely knows them or does not know them at all she will likely be uncomfortable anyway, they are your family and that does not automatically make them her family.  Assuming BM needs to give permission for her to leave the state then I would skip it b/c it is not worth the hassle for something that does not actually affect her, if you were going to Disney without her and did not want to hassle to ask that would be a different story.  I actually would suggest not asking BM so that you only have one out of state request instead of fighting and having her say no to Disney.

    Jen - Mom to two December 12 babies Nathaniel 12/12/06 and Addison 12/12/08
  • imageLittlejen22:
    imagesuze423:

    imagemschocokitty:
    I must be in the minority. I don't think it would be awful if you and DH went on this trip when SD is with her mom for her regularly scheduled time (not missing out on time with you guys at all). If you know you all are planning a family vacation to Disneyworld soon, there will be lots of family time in the future. You are setting time aside as a family, so one trip with just DH isn't going to break the family bond. 

    I agree, though I think it also depends on how close your SD is with your side of the family.  Would she be upset if you went without her?

    This.  If SD is close to the people you are visiting it is different but assuming that she barely knows them or does not know them at all she will likely be uncomfortable anyway, they are your family and that does not automatically make them her family.  Assuming BM needs to give permission for her to leave the state then I would skip it b/c it is not worth the hassle for something that does not actually affect her, if you were going to Disney without her and did not want to hassle to ask that would be a different story.  I actually would suggest not asking BM so that you only have one out of state request instead of fighting and having her say no to Disney.

    I agree w/this.

    image

    image
    image

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"