We got a children's bible for each girl on their baptism days. My MIL also got each girl an engraved silver comb and brush set. Those were our FAVORITE gifts. I prefer keepsake stuff. We also got a few religious children's books, one of those Willow Tree statues (of a little girl with a heart I think), picture frames.....I think that's all.
I tend to go the less traditional route and buy things the kid likes. We recieved a few children's Bible story books that DS loves. I also like to give a noah's ark theme gift with a book and animal toys for the kid to play with.
Re: Baptism gift ideas
Shmoo is growing up!