So af oficially came overnight.  Called re today and they want me to start same dose of femara not change anything.  No trigger, no progesterone.  I love my re but I think he is being way too conservative here. He only wants to give me femara 3 times.  Why waste another cycle on low p and short lp. Is a 10 day lp not way to short.  Isnt it bad that af came 5 days early?  My gyn is a good friend of mine and have me some progeaterone samples when I told her about lp. What do you think? Should i take it even though re doesn't think I need it. I'm leaning towards heck ya                
                             
        
Re: WWYD?
I agree. I wouldn't waste time taking Femara alone.
Me: 36 DH: 33 DD:2
PCOS diagnosis February, 2011
Clomid - 50 mg + Met June & July 2011 - BFN
Clomid - 100 mg + Met September 2011 - BFN
Clomid - 150 mg + Met Oct & Nov 2011 - +OPK - BFN
HSG - clear S/A - normal
IUI #1 - Clomid 150 mg/Ovidrel/Met - February, 2012 - BFN
IUI #2 - Clomid 150 mg/Ovidrel/Met - March, 2012 - BFP!!! EDD 11/29/12
Daughter born on 11/6/12
TTC #2 since 5/14
9/14 - D&C / Hysteroscopy
11/14 - Met / Clomid 100 mg - BFN
12/14 - Met / Clomid 100 mg / Ovidrel / Acupuncture - BFN
1/15 - Met / Clomid 100 mg / Ovidrel - IUI #1 - ???
IVF #1 with ICSI - ER 1/20 (16R, 12M, 10F), ET 1/23 (1-10 cell and 1-8cell transferred), BFP on 1/31 Beta #1 on 2/3 = 68, Beta #2 on 2/6 = 261 EDD 10/12/12
Hmmm, this is kind of an interesting situation. I would definitely be leaning towards the progesterone, escpecially after such a short LP this time around.
Do you think if you called your RE and explained that you think he needs to be more aggressive (or at least put you on progesterone for a short LP) he would be likely to agree?
I would say, if he is not willing to listen to your concerns and see that your LP is too short, then maybe start shopping around for a new RE.
This, it doesn't sound like you trust your RE fully and that is making you question his treatment plan. That doesn't bode well for future cycles. I would maybe seek out a 2nd opinion or a WTF appointment with your current RE.
TTC #1 since 2009 with unexplained infertility
IUI#1-4 Jan.-Apr. 2011 = BFNs
IVF#1 Aug. 2011 = c/p, FET #1 Nov. 2011 = c/p, FET #2 April 2012 = BFP!
Beta #1 = 153, Beta #2 = 269, Beta #3 = 675
1st U/S = TWINS!! EDD 12/29/12
my blog: Journey to Somewhere
~~PAIFW/SAIFW~~
April IVF Spring Chicks
Thats just it...Idk what the dr would say but the RE had no idea about a short lp b/c the nurse called me and never said hold on let me ask or anything like that. The nurse told me my LP was fine...I disagree. Its really the nurse I'm not agreeing with here and she didn't validate my concerns. I guess you wouldn't start progesterone or anything till after O so I could talk to dr at my monitoring appointment and see what he says. Finding another RE isn't really an option. I already drive over 2 hours to see him b/c the only 3 in my area are incompetent. He is the best dr around.... I did respond to the femara- my p4 was much better than last cycle and I had 2 nice follies. So I don't necessarily think we have a bad plan, I just don't feel like my P4 issue is being addressed.