My older son's birthday is 12/27, a Tuesday this year. In the past we've had his birthday party the first or second weekend in January, but I'm thinking maybe we'll do it on his actual birthday this year.
Pros to doing it on his birthday: just one celebration (past years we've done small family birthday party on his actual bday, then bigger friends party later), location cheaper on a weekday, most family and close friends are local and do not travel over the holidays, a lot of people have time off between Christmas and New Years
Cons: 2 days after Christmas, people more likely be traveling or have other commitments, some people may have to work
[Poll]
Re: Birthday Party Date Poll
I'm not going to vote because I have no idea, but I'm posting to offer sympathy. As a 12/27er myself, I can tell you I've done all of the above and also chosen "none." When I was M's age, my parents celebrated my birthday before Xmas with my older brother (12/20), on a weekend of their chosing. Later, we had group parties for all three of us (bro #2 is 12/22) on a weekend before Xmas vacation. I had my 7th and 13th birthday parties on my actual birthday but they were a bit sparsely attended. The only people who agree to celebrate on the actual day are my husband and parents and only then if someone isn't sick (which is less likely than you'd hope).
As an adult, I sometimes fold it into a NY day open house which works well.
Good luck deciding!