I vote the seahorse. My DS has a couple of those snuggle buddy blankets and he just doesn't seem very interested in them. He has a stuffed turtle more like the seahorse and likes it much more.
I would say the seahorse since I think it is so cute but I think DS would vote for the blanket. I honestly thought they were kinda silly so I returned all of them I recieved except the one from my SIL (I know I am terrible) and yet I noticed a few weeks ago DS loved grabbing and cuddling the burp cloth and so I started giving him the doggy blanket and what do you know he loves to cuddle the thing and make out with it. I only give it to him at naptime when I am watching him though. I tried to give him the seahorse to soothe to sleep but it seemed to keep him up watching it more than put him to sleep so I haven't used it much yet.
Re: Gift help
The bumpie formerly known as First Time in MI