February 2012 Moms

Would this bother you or am I being sensitive? NBR

So, my younger sister (who is also my best friend) and my brother-in-law are spending quite a bit of time together. They really like each other and are starting to head in a romantic direction. At first, before it was a reality, I was fine with the idea. But, now the more I think about it, the more I am having trouble accepting it. I just picture the future if they were to get married and have kids. She and I would live parallel lives and could possibly be compared against each other FOREVER. And then if they don't work out, it could make things awkward.

Am I just worrying and obsessing over nothing?

Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml

Re: Would this bother you or am I being sensitive? NBR

  • I'm an only child, but I don't think it would bother me. I mean, maybe if I didn't like my sister, but I think it would be kind of fun to get to stay so close. Then again, I never had a sister, so I may be looking at this completely wrong.
  • Loading the player...
  • Actually, it could end up being a fun thing, I would think.  Then you'd get to hang out with your sister more and you already know him so it wouldn't be a worry of whether or not everyone would get along. 

    If she's happy, that should be what matters...

    BabyFruit Ticker
  • I guess I am more nervous because she is just getting out of a 2 year relationship (as in the last few weeks) that she was so in love with her bf and he ended things then wanted her back.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageJeter1028:

    Actually, it could end up being a fun thing, I would think.  Then you'd get to hang out with your sister more and you already know him so it wouldn't be a worry of whether or not everyone would get along. 

    If she's happy, that should be what matters...

    exactly this.  it wouldn't bother me at all.  

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • Living the parallel lives and being compared....you are sisters that is going to happen no matter what. I would only worry about the part about it not working out. BUT, what if it does? You really can't stand in the way of someone possibly finding their partner...especially your sister. Just my opinion.
    Hatching the Hawks
    Hatching the Hawks
    BabyFruit Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • You can't control who your sister dates, so what's the point in getting worked up over it? Your concern that "She and I would live parallel lives and could possibly be compared against each other FOREVER." seems like a bit much. Why would people compare you forever? How would your lives be parallel? If people are going to compare you, they'll do it regardless of who you each marry.

    Yes, as with any relationship, there's the possibility for awkwardness if they break up. But if it does work out, your sister would be at every family gathering with you. I think that would be awesome! I wish my sister could be around every time I had to deal with my mother-in-law.

    I assume that your sister is an adult, so allow her to make her own decisions. It has probably occurred to her that it could potentially be awkward if they dated and then broke up, and she has likely weighed that into her decisions. Be supportive of her no matter what she decides. At this point, the thing that's most likely to affect your relationship with her is how you respond to her dating your BIL.

     Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • So I guess I am just overreacting :) Wouldn't be the first time. They are both the babies of the family and pretty spoiled and I think I have always been a little jealous of that. She is the "golden child." But, they are both finishing degrees (him Bach and she Masters) and living at home so I guess I have time to adjust to the idea of them together. I need to grow out of my competitive nature.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I would personally be thrilled if one of my sisters was dating/or married one of my brother in laws. You already know you like your sister, no surprise there about getting a really nasty sister in law. :-)

    I am a wedding photographer, and one of my clients last year who I adored was marrying her sister's brother in law. The other sister (who was married first) refused to be in family pictures, refused to congratulate, and made it clear that she was there just for the free food. I'm sure that there were underlying issues from other times, but to everyone else it just looked petty and ridiculous. Your sister is one of the people who you love the most; loving someone means you are happy to see them happy; even if it means they marry your brother in law. Now if it were a TWIN brother I might be a little more freaked. LOL. :-)

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagesoveryexcited:

    I would personally be thrilled if one of my sisters was dating/or married one of my brother in laws. You already know you like your sister, no surprise there about getting a really nasty sister in law. :-)

    I am a wedding photographer, and one of my clients last year who I adored was marrying her sister's brother in law. The other sister (who was married first) refused to be in family pictures, refused to congratulate, and made it clear that she was there just for the free food. I'm sure that there were underlying issues from other times, but to everyone else it just looked petty and ridiculous. Your sister is one of the people who you love the most; loving someone means you are happy to see them happy; even if it means they marry your brother in law. Now if it were a TWIN brother I might be a little more freaked. LOL. :-)

     

    OH I WOULD NEVER behave like that. She said she would stop hanging out with him if I wanted her to and I would never want that. She has had her heart broken twice and if he really makes her happy than I am happy. I couldn't take that away from her and wouldn't want to. I joke with DH that they saw how compatible we are and how much fun our familes have together and thought... why go elsewhere?

     

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • OMG, sign me up! My younger sister is my best friend, and if I had a BIL that I could see her dating, I'd be pushing that as hard as I could. I think it would be so much fun. Your kids would be almost like siblings. I'm sure they'd all look a lot alike. And you'd get to spend a lot of time with your sister, too.  Ah, if only my BILs could get their sh*t together...
    Pass the sheet cake.

    BabyGaga
  • I understand your fears for the break up but if it worked out i think you're being a little sensitive. I don't think it would be parallel lives or anything. brothers are obviously different or you wouldn't have picked the one you did... don't worry about it until it's something to worry about.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"