is it because THEY feel uncomfortable or you do? i wish i could whip it out at family dinners but my brothers think its the grossest thing there is... just wait until they have babies too and i can nurse with their wives!
My brother thinks it's gross, too. While I try to be super modest about it, I don't leave the room all the time, more than anything to try and get my brother used to it. There were times when DS was a baby and there was a lot of family that we did leave the room... mainly because we both needed the break. Now that DS is older I don't hardly ever leave... but he also doesn't nurse as much!
I remember sitting down to nurse DD1 at DS's birthday party. DD was a few weeks old at the time. Everyone left the room except for my teenage brother and his girlfriend.
Over time, though, no one left any more, and in fact my dad got really mad at someone who said something about me NIP at the state fair. I was always discrete, though I did not use a blanket. I personally wasn't going to spend my time locked away from people. DD1 nursed literally around the clock.
I did not/will not nurse in front of any relatives, b/c it makes ME uncomfortable. Wasn't too concerned about them. I'm just very, very modest and not comfortable with anyone seeing more of me than is covered by clothing. I don't let anyone but DH and doctors see my stomach either. The only people I ever nursed in front of (without a cover) were DH and medical professionals. The handful of times I nursed in public it was with a cover but that didn't work well for us so I tended to nurse him in the car before going in somewhere, or in mother's rooms at stores (Nordstrom, BRU, etc.)
I don't think anyone thinks it's gross, but I am always torn about bfing in front of them because I STILL don't have the transition down. Once DS is latched on, you can't tell we're nursing -- even when he pulls off, I'm covered by his head -- but I someone can't manage to pull my boob out or put it away without exposing myself!!
I BF in front of most of my male relatives, but not in front of my nephew. He is 13 and has taken it upon himself to remove himself from the room when I am nursing. (He used to work really hard to get his brother and sister to leave the room, too.) I have assured him that he doesn't have to leave unless he wants to. He is just uncomfortable, so he tends to leave. I usually tell him when I am about to start nursing. After almost two years, sometimes he will come back in the room after DD is latched...usually because we are in the middle of a Skip-Bo game or something!
With #1 I didn't nurse in front of any male relatives. Now I don't care about my father (I don't have any brothers and no uncles who live close enough) although I still wouldn't feel comfortable at all nursing in front of FIL (although, actually, I did but I covered up). It was because of my comfort. I did ask my dad before I whipped it out last time he was up. He didn't care.
Warning
No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
I don't feel comfortable breastfeeding in front of my dad, FIL, or BILs, but it really isn't because they're male. Due to a lot of self-esteem crushing comments from my mom and a friend's mom (regarding breast size and body shape) growing up, I'm not very comfortable BFing in front of anyone but DH.
Married to my best friend 6/5/10
BFP #1 9/7/10, EDD 5/14/11, Violet born 5/27/11.
BFP #2 4/9/12, EDD 12/16/12, M/C Rory 4/24/12.
BFP #3 10/6/12, EDD 6/16/12., Matilda born 6/17/13.
I have no real issue NIP, or in front of my family... but I don't in front of (most of) DH's family. He made a really big deal about NIP before J was born, and I just feel like they would be uncomfortable, which makes me uncomfortable... vicious cycle.
I have BFed in front of his aunt and grandmother (who both BFed their babies) and if somebody walked in I wouldn't be upset.) FIL did come in (to our house) while I was pumping, and I tossed a blanket over... but I wasn't comfortable unhooking it all with him in the room... I think I was more awkward about it than he was...
(fortunately we live very far away, and they mostly come to see us on our turf)
My father, mother and sister are 100% cool with bf'ing and could care less. DH's family (FIL, MIL, BIL and SIL) are ill-informed, squeamish and awkward about it. I am modest as possible, but I don't feel comfortable squirreling myself away, and DH basically forbid it anyway. I don't relish in them being uncomfortable, but it's not going to harm them in any way and being a little more in-tune with the process might be a very good thing. I have gone into the bedroom to nurse in certain situations, but there is just something that feels wrong about that to me (not passing judgement on how others handle it, to each their own). I feel a little resentful afterward, even if it was my decision
Warning
No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
I BF in front of everyone, male or female. Granted, i am discreet about it, but I definitely exercise my right to NIP. If they feel uncomfortable, that's their problem. My baby has to eat. I never have my boob just hanging out or anything, but I am sure people know what I am doing.
Warning
No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
I'm uncomfortable with it. I'm all for public BFing, but I'm not the type of person to just whip it out whereever, whenever. If possible, I try to find a private area. To me, BFing is more of an intimate thing.
"My friends, love is better than anger. Hope is better than fear. Optimism is better than despair. So let us be loving, hopeful and optimistic. And we'll change the world." - Jack Layton
I'm uncomfortable with it. I'm all for public BFing, but I'm not the type of person to just whip it out whereever, whenever. If possible, I try to find a private area. To me, BFing is more of an intimate thing.
the phrases "whip it out" and "intimate thing" scream anti-public bf'ing to me.
My stepfather leaves the room. I haven't really asked him why but I think it freaks him out. I nursed in front of my grandfather today and J is in the habit of unlatching and playing and then coming back and so I was kind of hanging out. I felt bad but my Grandmother told me not to worry, that he watches National Geographic and knows what they are there for. That made me feel good. Otherwise, I nurse in front of anyone. I don't really care about their comfort, TBH. I'm showing less than a poster at Victoria's Secret in the mall. I actually looked at one of those ads the other day and was appalled at how much breast they expose. So, I don't really worry about it.
Francesca Pearl is here! Josephine Hope is almost 3!
Well I don't really fit into this category...When Isaac was a new squish he had a tongue tie that no one picked up on until I had massive cracking and mastitis. The cracks were so bad that it hurt like crazy to put on a bra/shirt/anything that would touch me. My in-laws of course wanted to come over and see their grandson....
So they saw him, and me in all my topless glory. I would have cared more if it hadn't hurt so d@mn much but after that I kind of got over the nursing in front of FIL stuff. I'll nurse in front of my sister's husband but not really in front of DH's BIL. Just my preference- don't know him that well and I usually need a break from everyone at that point anyway- I've actually only seen him once since Isaac was born anyway.
I have been leaving when males are around because DS wants to toss off the cover, he gets fussy eating away from home. Around the girls I don't even bother with a cover, they've seen a pair before even though I try to be discreet. As I hopefully get more practiced with the cover I will try to stay with the group depending on the company. My dad, brother, friend's husband (who has a nursing wife) and maybe uncles I don't think would care. I do have a few friends though that ask that I not and will leave the room if I have to feed him. I have nursed in the sling in front of FIL but I don't think he knew what was going on because I latched in another room and then rejoined the group, if he knew he'd probably be embarrassed though.
I will nurse in front of FIL and BIL but I'll use a cover. I have large breasts and it can be tough to wrestle them out of my bra and shirt discreetly so I tend to nurse from the top.
Warning
No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
I don't care who sees me BF dd. BUT, I leave the room in front of most of my family because it makes THEM uncomfortable. FIL supports the BFing and thinks it's great, he just gets a little freaked out about it.
It's because they get this very pathetic look of panic on their faces. I can just hear their internal dialogue: "OMG. Boob. I can't look. I'm a perv if I look. I'm a perv for thinking I'm a perv. She's feeding her baby. She'll think I'm a perv if I don't look. If I look her DH will kill me! OMG OMG OMG" ::head explodes::
I always nursed in front of everyone. I am very discreet though. I've heard from my friends, if your boobs are bigger, they are harder to hide while nursing. I guess if that were my problem (if you want to call it that! haha). I would use a cover, but still do it. Feeding my baby would out way me or others feeling uncomfortable. That is what breasts are for!
Re: if you dont BF in front of male relatives...
My brother thinks it's gross, too. While I try to be super modest about it, I don't leave the room all the time, more than anything to try and get my brother used to it. There were times when DS was a baby and there was a lot of family that we did leave the room... mainly because we both needed the break. Now that DS is older I don't hardly ever leave... but he also doesn't nurse as much!
I remember sitting down to nurse DD1 at DS's birthday party. DD was a few weeks old at the time. Everyone left the room except for my teenage brother and his girlfriend.
Over time, though, no one left any more, and in fact my dad got really mad at someone who said something about me NIP at the state fair. I was always discrete, though I did not use a blanket. I personally wasn't going to spend my time locked away from people. DD1 nursed literally around the clock.
BFP #1 9/7/10, EDD 5/14/11, Violet born 5/27/11.
BFP #2 4/9/12, EDD 12/16/12, M/C Rory 4/24/12.
BFP #3 10/6/12, EDD 6/16/12., Matilda born 6/17/13.
I have no real issue NIP, or in front of my family... but I don't in front of (most of) DH's family. He made a really big deal about NIP before J was born, and I just feel like they would be uncomfortable, which makes me uncomfortable... vicious cycle.
I have BFed in front of his aunt and grandmother (who both BFed their babies) and if somebody walked in I wouldn't be upset.) FIL did come in (to our house) while I was pumping, and I tossed a blanket over... but I wasn't comfortable unhooking it all with him in the room... I think I was more awkward about it than he was...
My house = Bf'ing wherever and whenever
Their house = being a little more discrete
(fortunately we live very far away, and they mostly come to see us on our turf)
My father, mother and sister are 100% cool with bf'ing and could care less. DH's family (FIL, MIL, BIL and SIL) are ill-informed, squeamish and awkward about it. I am modest as possible, but I don't feel comfortable squirreling myself away, and DH basically forbid it anyway. I don't relish in them being uncomfortable, but it's not going to harm them in any way and being a little more in-tune with the process might be a very good thing. I have gone into the bedroom to nurse in certain situations, but there is just something that feels wrong about that to me (not passing judgement on how others handle it, to each their own). I feel a little resentful afterward, even if it was my decision
BFP #2 12/26/11 ~ EDD 9/6/12 ~ MMC discovered on 1/27/12 @ 8w1d (measured 6w2d)
BFP #3 8/10/12 ~ EDD 4/23/13 ~ MMC discovered on 9/13/12 @ 8w2d (measured 6w6d)
the phrases "whip it out" and "intimate thing" scream anti-public bf'ing to me.
Francesca Pearl is here! Josephine Hope is almost 3!
Well I don't really fit into this category...When Isaac was a new squish he had a tongue tie that no one picked up on until I had massive cracking and mastitis. The cracks were so bad that it hurt like crazy to put on a bra/shirt/anything that would touch me. My in-laws of course wanted to come over and see their grandson....
So they saw him, and me in all my topless glory. I would have cared more if it hadn't hurt so d@mn much but after that I kind of got over the nursing in front of FIL stuff. I'll nurse in front of my sister's husband but not really in front of DH's BIL. Just my preference- don't know him that well and I usually need a break from everyone at that point anyway- I've actually only seen him once since Isaac was born anyway.