I decided to keep it. The more I thought of it, like you all pointed out, it was such a great thoughtful gift and it just reminds me of such sweet effort that I can't give it back. I know that he wouldn't be hurt by my returning it, just disappointed his gift "failed" so we'll just avoid that altogether. Thanks for the advice!

DD -- 5YO
DS -- 3YO
Re: I DD'ed MD gift post -- thanks!
Me too. Sounds like you're happy with the resolution and that's a good thing.
Big - 1 year old
Bigger - 6 years old
Biggest - 13 years old
I think you made the right call