Cincinnati Babies

Has anyone purchased a used car recently?

DH and I are in the market for a new car, but not necessarily a brand spanking new one (because of cost). We just need to replace our secondary car that mainly gets me to work and back as it's almost 13 years old. We'd like something smaller, like maybe a Honda Civic or a Ford Focus. We've never purchased a used car, before, though. We can't decide if we're better off going through a dealer or someone selling in the paper or on Craigslist or whatever. We feel like the markup might be higher at a dealer, but then the car has at least been checked by a mechanic, so it's kind of a trade-off. Also, at a dealer we could probably trade my other car in, right? Has anyone purchased a used car recently? Any advice?
Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml

Re: Has anyone purchased a used car recently?

  • We bought my car used in 2007 and we ended up finding it listed on craisglist.  Overall I was really happy with our experience, except we had to pick it up in Dayton and we are in Cincy.  I know we got a way better deal avoiding a dealership, but we didn't have a car to trade in at the time since we only had one car at the time, so that wasn't a problem for us.  Good luck!
    Kristen & Mike 7/2005
    Griffin 10/2007
    image
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker BabyFruit Ticker
  • Loading the player...
  • Do you have a mechanic that you use and are comfortable with? How handy is your DH with cars/how much does he know about cars? My DH knows enough that if we drove it he would be able to tell if anything was off about it and we have a mechanic that we use for everything so a few times when we've bought used (we've never bought new and only bought from a dealer once) we ask the current owner if they mind if we take the car to our mechanic for a quick once over most havent had a problem as long as we leave something with them for collateral like our drivers license. The mechanic we use basically does a trip-check and is able to tell if there is going to be anything that needs done plus we do quite a bit of research on the make & model so we know what kind of problems to expect/look out for.

    Actually the one car that we bought used that we have had problems w/ we bought from a dealer. I dont think the dealer was dishonest or anything I think we just happened to get a lemon of a car that consistently has little things wrong with it (of course this all adds up). Buying used is definitely the way to go IMO, cars lose value as soon as they are driven off the lot and we dont like having car loans so we pay cash for our vehicles which means anything over $15k is out of our price range. If you are wanting to do a dealer my BIL is a sales manager at a toyota dealer here in Nky (they do new and used sales). I could have him keep an eye out for you and I can vouch that he isnt a skeezy salesman haha ;-)

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Lilypie Third Birthday tickers Lilypie Second Birthday tickers Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • Dealerships have more markup- but most sell their cars as-is unless you buy a warranty, it is just like buying from a private seller.  You can get a car fax report on any car I'd I would highly suggest that. 

    Dealerships will take your trade in but don't expect a good amount on it. Don't bother with the blue book value, either... They typically look at recent auctions of cars with your make/model/year/mileage and take the mid to low numbers on those because unless your car looks excellent in person that is where it is headed for, so they want to know what they will get out of it.

    Any car you care to buy I suggest making an appointment with a trusted mechanic to look over.  Let them know you are interested in buying a car and ask if they can look it over for you.  They are usually happy to.  You would think dealerships ensure that everything is great, but I know a two friends that bought crap from dealerships and the dealers told them sorry, you bought as is.  I bought a used car years ago and took it by a mechanic with no problems. 

    I sold insurance to car dealerships and became familiar with how they worked to some degree.  We bought a used Volvo XC90.   I won't buy new because I hate the immediate loss of money you have on them!  Negotiate the price of the car seperate from financing/down payment/trade in amounts.  Settle on the price first, otherwise many will try and do a pencil trick where they keep adding/subtracting amounts in various ways to confuse you.  It really ticks me off and I walk out on them.  Also, make sure to get ANY warranty in writing signed off on by either the sales manager or the finance manager.  Magically sometimes the sales guy that you used doesn't remember or they claim he no longer works there and they never okayed it.  (Yes, seems obvious but again, one of my friend's is an idiot and thought "surely he will admit he promised us 90 days!").

    Good luck and happy hunting! Also, we have a Corolla my DH uses for back and forth to work.  Gets about 35mpg and works just fine even if it is a 98 with 140k miles!

    image Momma to Ms. C age 16 months and Mr. C age 3 months!
  • My car is used, but from a dealer.  We didn't trade in on it, but next time I will probably be trading in my car or selling it ourselves and then using that money toward the downpayment, whichever I think we can get more money out of since my car will be close to 12 yrs old at least.  Mine is certified used so it comes with a warranty, and you can buy an extended warranty, which I liked, and was all cleaned up inside.  I also liked that it had been gone over by their mechanic, and with the warranty if something came up after I got it it would be fixed.  We managed to talk them down on price as well.  Overall it was a great experience.
  • Buying used and buying from a private seller will definately be the cheapest route to go. Like PP said, you can always take it to your mechanic for a complete check before you purchase it. If they don't want you to do that, then I would be a little worried!

    Just because you buy used from a dealership doesn't mean it will be any better than buying from a private seller. Most dealership mechanics are instructed to do the bare minimum to get the car in sellable shape (my BFF's husband is a master mechanic at Volvo and this is coming from his mouth) and most of the time, unless you buy one, used cars do not come with any type of warranty.

    I bought my first car used from a small dealership and I had so many problems with that car! Good thing my dad can fix anything or I would have been a broke 16 year old paying for a mechanic!

    Good luck! Car buying is always stressful to me.

    6/28/10: Lost our sweet baby Addyston at 18wk 1day to pPROM 7/24/11: Michael William born at 24wk 2d due to IC after an emergent cerclage at 18wks, 4wk home BR and 2 weeks hospital BR. Grow strong our little Miracle! 9/17/11: Michael joined his sister in heaven after 8 amazing weeks with us on earth. He fought a very hard fight but NEC was too much for him in the end. Lilypie Angel and Memorial tickers Lilypie Angel and Memorial tickers Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • We bought our 2007 odyssey used from a dealership, and we have no complaints as far as the buying process, but we did have some issues with the dealership.  We have also sold 2 cars on craigs list and that was a fairly easy process.  I would not suggest trading your car in because you will get next to nothing on it especially since it is 13 years old, you are better off trying to sell it yourself.  DH's 2004 honda civic that was in fantastic shape....the dealership wanted to give us like $2k for it which was a total rip off....we sold it $6K on CL.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Thanks, ladies. I don't have a mechanic we regularly use because we've been very fortunate in that we've had almost no car issues outside of routine maintenance like oil changes. I think we'll look around and see what we see....we sold DH's last car on Craigslist and had a good experience, so I think I'll start there and compare with dealerships at the same time. I appreciate the advice!
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"