1st Trimester

How to respond to "were you trying"?

How to you respond politely to this when you don't really want to share personal information? 

My issue is this:  We didn't try long, but yes, we were totally "trying" and I don't necessarily want to share this with everyone.  We have a sizeable amount of student loan debt and have struggled financially.  Comments have been made by some members of our in-laws family that we should wait until we had more financial stability, since is the way they did it.  I just don't want to deal with the judgment that comes with disclosing this was planned despite our less-than-ideal situation. 

Also, does anyone else just find it rude?  I'll admit, I'm always curious about this with my close friends/family but if they don't volunteer the information, I usually don't ask so directly.

Re: How to respond to "were you trying"?

  • It's rude. End of story!

    It's like when people ask "were the twins because of fertility drugs?!?!?!" (they were, BTW, but so was DD)

    It's because they are nosey and just have to get into your business.

    Just tell them "WOW! I had no idea you wanted to know about out sex life... if you want details... we should sit down and talk!" Stick out tongue

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Loading the player...
  • Well, if you ARE struggling financially, then it does beg the question of were you trying, and why. Certainly it is no one's business per se, but it is irresponsible to plan a baby if you are barely making it. If your family knows you are struggling financially, then you can't really blame them for being curious. This is one of my major pet peeved. Don't have a baby unless you can afford it.
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • Who cares about their judging, just tell them like it is.  Yes, we were trying and this is a very wanted baby.  Nobody in your family will care when they see that sweet little face.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • My mom asked this. I told her to mind her own business and that was the end of the discussion.
    imageimageimage
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    BabyFetus Ticker
    Breastfeeding and pregnant!
  • I had many people ask me this question (even though my husband and I both own our own home, have very good jobs, and ARE in a good place financially).  It is rude.  My friend gave me a good response after I was venting to her about how rude it was!  She said to make it into a joke and hopefully the other person will drop it.  Example:  

    Rude person:  "Was it planned?"

    You:  " No, as a matter of fact I'm still trying to figure out who the father is..." (dripping in sarcasm) 

      

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I think it's rude.  I understand their concern over whether you would be able to support the baby, but unless you are depending on them financially, frankly- it's none of their business.  And even in the case that they were helping you out financially, I think there is probably a nicer way of bringing up that discussion, one that sounds less like an accusation. 
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagetiffbomb:

    I had many people ask me this question (even though my husband and I both own our own home, have very good jobs, and ARE in a good place financially).  It is rude.  My friend gave me a good response after I was venting to her about how rude it was!  She said to make it into a joke and hopefully the other person will drop it.  Example:  

    Rude person:  "Was it planned?"

    You:  " No, as a matter of fact I'm still trying to figure out who the father is..." (dripping in sarcasm) 

      

    Yes  love this response!

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Well I have to agree with all the women's responses. It's really no one's business if you were trying or not & yes I think it's rude to just blatenly ask someone. Why the hell do they care if you were trying or not!?!?  When people ask this question I almost feel like they are asking how often are you guys having sex. It's a very personal question.

    We personally are in no financial situation to have a child. Between student loans & back taxes from being self employed, to sinking every last dime we've had in the last year into starting our own business we're frankly broke.  My answer to this question is simple...trying or not....we were open to the possibility. And who cares if you were trying....your friends and family should just be happy for you guys!!! 

    All the questions, money and situations aside...we have all been blessed with the gift of life. And the most important thing is how you are feeling, & making sure you and baby are getting the best care possible.

    I've said for the last couple of years, that we wanted to wait until we moved out of the city, we were more financially stable...blah blah blah. I sounded like a broken record. The truth of the matter....there is no perfect time, and you and your sweetie will make it work. Everything happens for a reason & everything always has a way of working out. Good luck, and enjoy every minute of this gift you have been given. 

  • Sorry to continue my long winded answer...If you couldn't tell from my response that question gets me somewhat irritated.

    To solve our financial situation, we have sat down with a consultant that has reviewed all our finances and we have come up with a plan that we can stick to. It's really an eye opening experience to have someone point out small things in your check book that make a huge difference in savings. Like I said, there is always a way and after our consult we were both relieved and better prepared to embark on this journey. Our future suddenly felt so much more manageable!!

  • Depending on the person I would be honest, or ask, why are you so interested in our sex life? Interesting question, why do you want to know? Just smile and say we are very excited/happy. If you forgive me for not answering, I'll forgive you for asking. This question is rude IMO.
    BFP CP 1/12/11 DD born 10/16/11
  • imageLissa832:
    Well, if you ARE struggling financially, then it does beg the question of were you trying, and why. Certainly it is no one's business per se, but it is irresponsible to plan a baby if you are barely making it. If your family knows you are struggling financially, then you can't really blame them for being curious. This is one of my major pet peeved. Don't have a baby unless you can afford it.

    So because they owe student loans that means that they can't "afford" a baby?

    Who are you to judge anyone elses financial situation?

    On paper our budget wasn't exactly "perfect" but we have managed to afford $400 a month in prescription formula for our daughter, $50 a month in brand name medication along with diapers, toys and her extreme amount of medical bills without using any sort of help from the government although we certainly qualify.

    There is NEVER a "perfect" time to have a baby.. you can't plan for their expenses. I obviously intended to breastfeed and we weren't supposed to have to pay for formula! So please don't judge unless you yourself are living in the situation.

    As far as OP's question. Frankly, like PP said, it is NONE of their business. I would tell them to back off.. however I am very blunt =) A baby is a gift of life and finances always work themselves out. Just takes some savings and a good budget =)

    IAmPregnant Ticker

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imagesarie1621:

    imageLissa832:
    Well, if you ARE struggling financially, then it does beg the question of were you trying, and why. Certainly it is no one's business per se, but it is irresponsible to plan a baby if you are barely making it. If your family knows you are struggling financially, then you can't really blame them for being curious. This is one of my major pet peeved. Don't have a baby unless you can afford it.

    So because they owe student loans that means that they can't "afford" a baby?

    Who are you to judge anyone elses financial situation?

    On paper our budget wasn't exactly "perfect" but we have managed to afford $400 a month in prescription formula for our daughter, $50 a month in brand name medication along with diapers, toys and her extreme amount of medical bills without using any sort of help from the government although we certainly qualify.

    There is NEVER a "perfect" time to have a baby.. you can't plan for their expenses. I obviously intended to breastfeed and we weren't supposed to have to pay for formula! So please don't judge unless you yourself are living in the situation.

    As far as OP's question. Frankly, like PP said, it is NONE of their business. I would tell them to back off.. however I am very blunt =) A baby is a gift of life and finances always work themselves out. Just takes some savings and a good budget =)

    This!!
  • imagetiffbomb:

    I had many people ask me this question (even though my husband and I both own our own home, have very good jobs, and ARE in a good place financially).  It is rude.  My friend gave me a good response after I was venting to her about how rude it was!  She said to make it into a joke and hopefully the other person will drop it.  Example:  

    Rude person:  "Was it planned?"

    You:  " No, as a matter of fact I'm still trying to figure out who the father is..." (dripping in sarcasm) 

      

    This! 

    This reminds me of when DH told his best friend our news -- his first response, without missing a beat, was "So what are you going to do when you catch the guy?"

    "I know not all that may be coming, but be it what it will, I'll go to it laughing."



  • imagecatch2010:
    imagetiffbomb:

    I had many people ask me this question (even though my husband and I both own our own home, have very good jobs, and ARE in a good place financially).  It is rude.  My friend gave me a good response after I was venting to her about how rude it was!  She said to make it into a joke and hopefully the other person will drop it.  Example:  

    Rude person:  "Was it planned?"

    You:  " No, as a matter of fact I'm still trying to figure out who the father is..." (dripping in sarcasm) 

      

    This! 

    This reminds me of when DH told his best friend our news -- his first response, without missing a beat, was "So what are you going to do when you catch the guy?"

     LOL!  

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • We've told maybe 12-15 people so far and NOBODY has asked us this! I will be dumbfounded if someone does. Beyond rude.

    Lilypie Pregnancy tickers

    Lilypie Third Birthday tickers

  • imagesarie1621:

    imageLissa832:
    Well, if you ARE struggling financially, then it does beg the question of were you trying, and why. Certainly it is no one's business per se, but it is irresponsible to plan a baby if you are barely making it. If your family knows you are struggling financially, then you can't really blame them for being curious. This is one of my major pet peeved. Don't have a baby unless you can afford it.

    So because they owe student loans that means that they can't "afford" a baby?

    Who are you to judge anyone elses financial situation?

    On paper our budget wasn't exactly "perfect" but we have managed to afford $400 a month in prescription formula for our daughter, $50 a month in brand name medication along with diapers, toys and her extreme amount of medical bills without using any sort of help from the government although we certainly qualify.

    There is NEVER a "perfect" time to have a baby.. you can't plan for their expenses. I obviously intended to breastfeed and we weren't supposed to have to pay for formula! So please don't judge unless you yourself are living in the situation.

    As far as OP's question. Frankly, like PP said, it is NONE of their business. I would tell them to back off.. however I am very blunt =) A baby is a gift of life and finances always work themselves out. Just takes some savings and a good budget =)

    Love all of your hilarious and awesome responses.  I'm glad to know I'm not only one standing there speechless when I was asked!  

    I get why it's smart to plan ahead and be as financially stable as possible beforehand...but, I also think it's about your priorities and choices.  We aren't on welfare and have some significant savings and good jobs.  I have fairly decent income (and huge loans) because I had to pay for all of college entirely by myself and went all the way through to grad school.  We've waited two years for this reason alone and finally felt like we really wanted this and were committed to making it work no matter work.  My in-laws, by contrast, live in million-dollar homes and have executive-level, white-collar jobs; they pay thousands of dollars for their daughter's preschool and buy her the  very best of everything (organic food, state-of-the-art stroller system, designer clothes, etc.)  Our situation will be different, but we will love our baby and be great parents regardless.  We've already waited years and are happily married and in our late-twenties.  I believe our baby is an amazing gift from God and that we can make it work no matter what.   We live in a small rental house, aren't going to be taking a lavish babymoon or buying designer maternity clothes, but I'm already happier than I've ever been in my entire life.  (I've already bought a like-new Bumbo chair and rocking chair on craigslist for under $25!  I'm going to be a thrifty, smart mama.)  

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

  • imagesarie1621:

    imageLissa832:
    Well, if you ARE struggling financially, then it does beg the question of were you trying, and why. Certainly it is no one's business per se, but it is irresponsible to plan a baby if you are barely making it. If your family knows you are struggling financially, then you can't really blame them for being curious. This is one of my major pet peeved. Don't have a baby unless you can afford it.

    So because they owe student loans that means that they can't "afford" a baby?

    Who are you to judge anyone elses financial situation?

    On paper our budget wasn't exactly "perfect" but we have managed to afford $400 a month in prescription formula for our daughter, $50 a month in brand name medication along with diapers, toys and her extreme amount of medical bills without using any sort of help from the government although we certainly qualify.

    There is NEVER a "perfect" time to have a baby.. you can't plan for their expenses. I obviously intended to breastfeed and we weren't supposed to have to pay for formula! So please don't judge unless you yourself are living in the situation.

    As far as OP's question. Frankly, like PP said, it is NONE of their business. I would tell them to back off.. however I am very blunt =) A baby is a gift of life and finances always work themselves out. Just takes some savings and a good budget =)



    She said they have a ton of student loans AND are struggling financially.

    And trust me, you can certainly plan for them.  I would never have had a baby in my twenties because I wasn't as financially secure.  I waited till we could easily afford it (and having me SAH) while not ruining our quality of life.  No one would ever ask us if ours was planned, because we don't make our finances anyone elses' business.

    To the OP - why is everyone aware of your financial situation to the point where they are concerned for your child?
    imageimage
    Lilypie First Birthday tickers
    Lilypie Maternity tickers
  • imageSarahcakes29:
    imagesarie1621:

    imageLissa832:
    Well, if you ARE struggling financially, then it does beg the question of were you trying, and why. Certainly it is no one's business per se, but it is irresponsible to plan a baby if you are barely making it. If your family knows you are struggling financially, then you can't really blame them for being curious. This is one of my major pet peeved. Don't have a baby unless you can afford it.

    So because they owe student loans that means that they can't "afford" a baby?

    Who are you to judge anyone elses financial situation?

    On paper our budget wasn't exactly "perfect" but we have managed to afford $400 a month in prescription formula for our daughter, $50 a month in brand name medication along with diapers, toys and her extreme amount of medical bills without using any sort of help from the government although we certainly qualify.

    There is NEVER a "perfect" time to have a baby.. you can't plan for their expenses. I obviously intended to breastfeed and we weren't supposed to have to pay for formula! So please don't judge unless you yourself are living in the situation.

    As far as OP's question. Frankly, like PP said, it is NONE of their business. I would tell them to back off.. however I am very blunt =) A baby is a gift of life and finances always work themselves out. Just takes some savings and a good budget =)

    Love all of your hilarious and awesome responses.  I'm glad to know I'm not only one standing there speechless when I was asked!  

    I get why it's smart to plan ahead and be as financially stable as possible beforehand...but, I also think it's about your priorities and choices.  We aren't on welfare and have some significant savings and good jobs.  I have fairly decent income (and huge loans) because I had to pay for all of college entirely by myself and went all the way through to grad school.  We've waited two years for this reason alone and finally felt like we really wanted this and were committed to making it work no matter work.  My in-laws, by contrast, live in million-dollar homes and have executive-level, white-collar jobs; they pay thousands of dollars for their daughter's preschool and buy her the  very best of everything (organic food, state-of-the-art stroller system, designer clothes, etc.)  Our situation will be different, but we will love our baby and be great parents regardless.  We've already waited years and are happily married and in our late-twenties.  I believe our baby is an amazing gift from God and that we can make it work no matter what.   We live in a small rental house, aren't going to be taking a lavish babymoon or buying designer maternity clothes, but I'm already happier than I've ever been in my entire life.  (I've already bought a like-new Bumbo chair and rocking chair on craigslist for under $25!  I'm going to be a thrifty, smart mama.)  

     

     

     

     

     

     

     

    Maybe your first post was misleading, it sounds like you and YH have it together. Good luck to you!

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imageJamieS2006:
    imagesarie1621:

    imageLissa832:
    Well, if you ARE struggling financially, then it does beg the question of were you trying, and why. Certainly it is no one's business per se, but it is irresponsible to plan a baby if you are barely making it. If your family knows you are struggling financially, then you can't really blame them for being curious. This is one of my major pet peeved. Don't have a baby unless you can afford it.

    So because they owe student loans that means that they can't "afford" a baby?

    Who are you to judge anyone elses financial situation?

    On paper our budget wasn't exactly "perfect" but we have managed to afford $400 a month in prescription formula for our daughter, $50 a month in brand name medication along with diapers, toys and her extreme amount of medical bills without using any sort of help from the government although we certainly qualify.

    There is NEVER a "perfect" time to have a baby.. you can't plan for their expenses. I obviously intended to breastfeed and we weren't supposed to have to pay for formula! So please don't judge unless you yourself are living in the situation.

    As far as OP's question. Frankly, like PP said, it is NONE of their business. I would tell them to back off.. however I am very blunt =) A baby is a gift of life and finances always work themselves out. Just takes some savings and a good budget =)



    She said they have a ton of student loans AND are struggling financially.

    And trust me, you can certainly plan for them.  I would never have had a baby in my twenties because I wasn't as financially secure.  I waited till we could easily afford it (and having me SAH) while not ruining our quality of life.  No one would ever ask us if ours was planned, because we don't make our finances anyone elses' business.

    To the OP - why is everyone aware of your financial situation to the point where they are concerned for your child?

     

    This is also my question......Hmm


    "You and me together can do anything, baby!!" DMB
    Married October 16th, 2010
    TTC #1 since October 2010
    1st BFP 1-12-11
    MC'd 1-22-11
    2nd BFP 2-15-11
    Our Wee One....**KENNEDY JO** born 10/3/11@ 36weeks via Csection
    My BFP Chart
    Image and video hosting by TinyPic
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    Labor Buddy to **MRS.ATCH** Welcome Quinn 11-5-11**
  • it is incredibly rude, but i get it all the time too.  especially since we are not married and i'm still in school part-time.  i tell them the truth, even though it's frankly none of their business: we weren't actively trying but we weren't doing anything to prevent it.
    BabyFruit Ticker BabyFetus Ticker
  • I hate that question. It's very rude.
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie First Birthday tickers
    Married since 06/19/2004|Anna born 11/19/2006|Charles born 11/1/11
    Double undergrad graduation May 2011| Me: Psychology, DH: Communication| A long journey!
    <a href="http://s21.photobucket.com/albums/b268/gussiebutt/?action=view
  • DH and I have had a similar problem.  We weren't really trying... We decided to get off the pill and stop not trying for a few months.  I got pregnant the first month I was off the pill.  I know several people who have been trying for months, even years to have a child but haven't gotten pregnant yet.  Since we've told that we are pregnant, I feel awkward around those people because when they asked if we were trying, I said, "Not really." I understand that their feelings are probaby hurt, but I almost feel like I can't talk about the pregnancy in front of them... What should I do!?!!

    BabyFruit Ticker
  • I mean to the point of the other people who have been trying... Not tracking your cycle or taking fertility treaments and things like that. 

    BabyFruit Ticker
  • "yes".

     

    End of story.

    Rylee - 3.28.08
    Malakai - 8.3.09
    Ezra - 12.1.11 ASD
  • imageLissa832:
    Well, if you ARE struggling financially, then it does beg the question of were you trying, and why. Certainly it is no one's business per se, but it is irresponsible to plan a baby if you are barely making it. If your family knows you are struggling financially, then you can't really blame them for being curious. This is one of my major pet peeved. Don't have a baby unless you can afford it.

    Whoa.  I don't like you.

     

     

    OP - everything will work out in the end. 

    Rylee - 3.28.08
    Malakai - 8.3.09
    Ezra - 12.1.11 ASD
  • I would respond with, "Why do you want to know?"

    And if they mention anything about your finances, I'd say, "I'm not asking you to pay for my child, so why does it matter to you?" Hopefully they would stop after that.

  • imageJamieS2006:
    imagesarie1621:

    imageLissa832:
    Well, if you ARE struggling financially, then it does beg the question of were you trying, and why. Certainly it is no one's business per se, but it is irresponsible to plan a baby if you are barely making it. If your family knows you are struggling financially, then you can't really blame them for being curious. This is one of my major pet peeved. Don't have a baby unless you can afford it.

    So because they owe student loans that means that they can't "afford" a baby?

    Who are you to judge anyone elses financial situation?

    On paper our budget wasn't exactly "perfect" but we have managed to afford $400 a month in prescription formula for our daughter, $50 a month in brand name medication along with diapers, toys and her extreme amount of medical bills without using any sort of help from the government although we certainly qualify.

    There is NEVER a "perfect" time to have a baby.. you can't plan for their expenses. I obviously intended to breastfeed and we weren't supposed to have to pay for formula! So please don't judge unless you yourself are living in the situation.

    As far as OP's question. Frankly, like PP said, it is NONE of their business. I would tell them to back off.. however I am very blunt =) A baby is a gift of life and finances always work themselves out. Just takes some savings and a good budget =)



    She said they have a ton of student loans AND are struggling financially.

    And trust me, you can certainly plan for them.  I would never have had a baby in my twenties because I wasn't as financially secure.  I waited till we could easily afford it (and having me SAH) while not ruining our quality of life.  No one would ever ask us if ours was planned, because we don't make our finances anyone elses' business.

    To the OP - why is everyone aware of your financial situation to the point where they are concerned for your child?

    FYI - People do not only ask the question if their concerned about your finances. Everyone knows that we live WAY below our means - small house, no new cars, grow our own food etc. and they still ask that rude and stupid question.  

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • My hormones must be going full blast today because when I read your post, my initial reaction was that you should have told them "Yes, my husband and I were purposefully having unprotected sex.  Are you also interested in the positions we used? I'd be happy to share..."
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagesarie1621:

    imageLissa832:
    Well, if you ARE struggling financially, then it does beg the question of were you trying, and why. Certainly it is no one's business per se, but it is irresponsible to plan a baby if you are barely making it. If your family knows you are struggling financially, then you can't really blame them for being curious. This is one of my major pet peeved. Don't have a baby unless you can afford it.

    So because they owe student loans that means that they can't "afford" a baby?

    Who are you to judge anyone elses financial situation?

    On paper our budget wasn't exactly "perfect" but we have managed to afford $400 a month in prescription formula for our daughter, $50 a month in brand name medication along with diapers, toys and her extreme amount of medical bills without using any sort of help from the government although we certainly qualify.

    There is NEVER a "perfect" time to have a baby.. you can't plan for their expenses. I obviously intended to breastfeed and we weren't supposed to have to pay for formula! So please don't judge unless you yourself are living in the situation.

    As far as OP's question. Frankly, like PP said, it is NONE of their business. I would tell them to back off.. however I am very blunt =) A baby is a gift of life and finances always work themselves out. Just takes some savings and a good budget =)

    You took the words right out of my mouth.

    When I was pregnant with DD, we were making good money and I still worried about finances.  I left my job to be a SAHM, DD was born, and two months later DH got laid off.  He didn't find another job for 18 months. Sure didn't see that one coming, but we managed to make it work. Where there's a will, there's a way.

    And to the OP, I would simply tell people "We were just having lots of unprotected sex".

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic

    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
    Lilypie Pregnancy tickers

    image

    Trust in the LORD with all your heart, and lean not on your own understanding.
    In all your ways acknowledge Him,and He shall direct your paths.
    Proverbs 3:5-6

  • imagelanoue25:

    imageJamieS2006:
    imagesarie1621:

    imageLissa832:
    Well, if you ARE struggling financially, then it does beg the question of were you trying, and why. Certainly it is no one's business per se, but it is irresponsible to plan a baby if you are barely making it. If your family knows you are struggling financially, then you can't really blame them for being curious. This is one of my major pet peeved. Don't have a baby unless you can afford it.

    So because they owe student loans that means that they can't "afford" a baby?

    Who are you to judge anyone elses financial situation?

    On paper our budget wasn't exactly "perfect" but we have managed to afford $400 a month in prescription formula for our daughter, $50 a month in brand name medication along with diapers, toys and her extreme amount of medical bills without using any sort of help from the government although we certainly qualify.

    There is NEVER a "perfect" time to have a baby.. you can't plan for their expenses. I obviously intended to breastfeed and we weren't supposed to have to pay for formula! So please don't judge unless you yourself are living in the situation.

    As far as OP's question. Frankly, like PP said, it is NONE of their business. I would tell them to back off.. however I am very blunt =) A baby is a gift of life and finances always work themselves out. Just takes some savings and a good budget =)



    She said they have a ton of student loans AND are struggling financially.

    And trust me, you can certainly plan for them.  I would never have had a baby in my twenties because I wasn't as financially secure.  I waited till we could easily afford it (and having me SAH) while not ruining our quality of life.  No one would ever ask us if ours was planned, because we don't make our finances anyone elses' business.

    To the OP - why is everyone aware of your financial situation to the point where they are concerned for your child?

     

    This is also my question......Hmm


    Lanoue -   I'm going to on this board for awhile so I want to clarify:  I'm not being irresponsible.  We have struggled paying off my loans (as anyone in my position would) but we have two years' of savings, stable jobs, and we do make ends meet.  It has been hard saving up for two years and sacrificing so we could do this.  However, my in-laws have a very different lifestyle (they have a multi-million dollar home, CEO jobs, and at one point insinuated that we should be homeowners before having kids.   Our in-laws (it's actually only my brother-in-law and his wife) are the ONLY people out of a huge network of family and friends in our lives that haven't been as supportive and expressed suprise.  They aren't aware of my financial situation except they know we drive older cars, turn down their family trips to Europe and don't have live a in huge house in an expensive neighborhood.  I did not make our financial affairs anyone else's business.  We aren't perfect but we HAVE planned and are doing the best we can.  And we're going to be fine.

     

     

     

     

     

  • imagelanoue25:

    imageJamieS2006:
    imagesarie1621:

    imageLissa832:
    Well, if you ARE struggling financially, then it does beg the question of were you trying, and why. Certainly it is no one's business per se, but it is irresponsible to plan a baby if you are barely making it. If your family knows you are struggling financially, then you can't really blame them for being curious. This is one of my major pet peeved. Don't have a baby unless you can afford it.

    So because they owe student loans that means that they can't "afford" a baby?

    Who are you to judge anyone elses financial situation?

    On paper our budget wasn't exactly "perfect" but we have managed to afford $400 a month in prescription formula for our daughter, $50 a month in brand name medication along with diapers, toys and her extreme amount of medical bills without using any sort of help from the government although we certainly qualify.

    There is NEVER a "perfect" time to have a baby.. you can't plan for their expenses. I obviously intended to breastfeed and we weren't supposed to have to pay for formula! So please don't judge unless you yourself are living in the situation.

    As far as OP's question. Frankly, like PP said, it is NONE of their business. I would tell them to back off.. however I am very blunt =) A baby is a gift of life and finances always work themselves out. Just takes some savings and a good budget =)



    She said they have a ton of student loans AND are struggling financially.

    And trust me, you can certainly plan for them.  I would never have had a baby in my twenties because I wasn't as financially secure.  I waited till we could easily afford it (and having me SAH) while not ruining our quality of life.  No one would ever ask us if ours was planned, because we don't make our finances anyone elses' business.

    To the OP - why is everyone aware of your financial situation to the point where they are concerned for your child?

     

    This is also my question......Hmm


    Lanoue -   I'm going to on this board for awhile so I want to clarify:  I'm not being irresponsible.  We have struggled paying off my loans (as anyone in my position would) but we have two years' of savings, stable jobs with great benefits, and we do make ends meet.  It has been hard saving up for two years and sacrificing so we could do this.  However, my in-laws have a very different lifestyle (they have a multi-million dollar home, CEO jobs, and at one point insinuated that we should be homeowners before having kids.   Our in-laws (it's actually only my brother-in-law and his wife) are the ONLY people out of a huge network of family and friends in our lives that haven't been as supportive and expressed suprise.  They aren't aware of my financial situation except they know we drive older cars, turn down their family trips to Europe and don't have live a in huge house in an expensive neighborhood.  I did not make our financial affairs anyone else's business.  We aren't perfect but we HAVE planned and are doing the best we can.  And we're going to be fine.

     

     

     

     

     

  • imagermj80:

    imageLissa832:
    Well, if you ARE struggling financially, then it does beg the question of were you trying, and why. Certainly it is no one's business per se, but it is irresponsible to plan a baby if you are barely making it. If your family knows you are struggling financially, then you can't really blame them for being curious. This is one of my major pet peeved. Don't have a baby unless you can afford it.

    and when exactly is the proper threshold at which you can AFFORD a baby???

    wow, just wow.

    OP: the smartarse in me would say something like "Every day!! And it was FUN!"

    but if you want your response to such a stupid question to be polite, then just change the subject or say something like "I guess."

    Best response ever!  Plus it's totally true.  Stick out tongue

  • I would say, "Can you believe we weren't even having sex??!!!"
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Daisypath Anniversary tickers daisypath PitaPata Dog tickers PitaPata Dog tickers Unexplained infertility HSG-clear, DH SA-Great 3 cycles Clomid TI with OB/GYN Switched to RE Jan2011 Feb2011 100mg Clomid + trigger + #1 IUI=BFN Mar. 12,2011 100mg Clomid + Estradiol + #2 IUI BFP 3/20/11, Beta #1 12dpiui 174, Beta #2 17dpiui 1660, Beta #3 21dpiui 6687 image
  • imagesomebodysmama21:

    I am pretty sarcastic so I would answer with something like "you mean were me and my husband having sex without using contraceptives, thats what you want to know, so you tell me about your sex life first then I will tell you."

    The reality is maybe you werent financially ready and maybe you were (you never are no matter how much you think you are) but its your choice and you arent asking them to support the baby so why should they care? Best wishes!

    This! Its no ones business! My DH has a student loan and we live off one income as I stay at home with my sons right now. We are trying for our third and final child. I know there will be people who feel the need to comment about whether or not we should have another, etc..but in reality its no ones business but yours!! My DH and I have never asked anyone for money, babysitting, etc...we do it on our own. My kids have a nice house to live in, clothes on their backs and food on their plates. They may not have everything in the world, but hey its good for them to learn they  need to earn things. Dont worry about what anyone in your family or on these boards has to say. Its your life and kids dont need a ton of "material" things to be happy, healthy and loved!

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • imagePecanSam:
    I would say, "Can you believe we weren't even having sex??!!!"

    Yes

    My family still doesnt know but they are REALLY snarky/bitter/rude and DD will be turning one in May and they told us when we had her not to have them close..But its none of their business.. 

    Our financial situation isnt "perfect" but its better than a lot of others.. I dont work more than 3 days DH works 40 hours and we can still save monthly on top of DD diapers/food/toys etc.. 

    As a PP said, you arent asking THEM to care for your child so say yes.

  • imagePecanSam:
    I would say, "Can you believe we weren't even having sex??!!!"

    Yes

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagetiffbomb:

    I had many people ask me this question (even though my husband and I both own our own home, have very good jobs, and ARE in a good place financially).  It is rude.  My friend gave me a good response after I was venting to her about how rude it was!  She said to make it into a joke and hopefully the other person will drop it.  Example:  

    Rude person:  "Was it planned?"

    You:  " No, as a matter of fact I'm still trying to figure out who the father is..." (dripping in sarcasm) 

      

    Thisss!!!!Yes That's great :)

    BabyName Ticker Lilypie Maternity tickers
  • If they make you feel awkward then respond with something that will do the same to them. My personal favorite is "heck yes, we tried 3 times a night" or something to that effect.
    someecards.com - I support Newt Gingrich's idea of colonizing the moon if it'll help me get away from Newt Gingrich.

    My baby is two!!! Baby girl 9/17/09

    My other baby is still a baby! Baby Boy 11-30-11

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"