I'd bet that E would easily transition to sleeping in her crib. It had been a handy storage and outgrown clothing sorting space, and I finally cleaned it out a few weeks ago with full intentions to have her start sleeping in it. However, she's still sleeping in the PnP in our room, and I still wake up once or twice a night to make sure she's breathing, even though it's never been an issue. Is it weird that I'm having a hard time moving her into her own room?
Re: What is wrong with me?
I'm going to make an AWESOME big brother.
You should do what works for you and your DH. There's no right or wrong.
I thought DD would have been in our room a lot longer than she was. Having a newborn and a new heightened sense of listening for every little noise left me being a horrible mess. DD would make noise all night (like a snort/snore) and I could never relax enough to sleep. We moved her to her own room and crib at a month. That was the best thing for me and her since now I could be awake and with the program.