What do you think?

Re: What do you think?

• Ella85 member

  January 2011

  I guess when I see Harper I think girl, but that might be because I have friends with daughters named Harper.

   

  Married 8-02-08

  After 3 years TTC with PCOS and two losses Olivia Nikelle was born 4-08-13

  TTC #2 Since August 2014
  

  

  Report0 Reply
• Loading the player...
• BFab11 member

  January 2011

  I thought Harper was a girl's name...

  Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml

  Report0 Reply
• Rachel&Jake member

  January 2011

  I love Harper foe a girl but not a fan of Piper.
  

  Report0 Reply
• Ceridwen21 member

  January 2011

  Am I crazy, or did you post this the other day?

  I like your girl choice but Harper is NMS.

  Oscar born October 2011

  Miscarriage at 8 weeks (August 2013)

  DD due September 1, 2014

  

   

  Report0 Reply
• magsugar13 member

  January 2011

  Harper is a girls name, not one i am fond of, but it is a girls name. Love Robert

  Not a fan of piper, but like Amaya

  Report0 Reply
• melody921 member

  January 2011

  BFab11:

  I thought Harper was a girl's name...

  this
  

  
  

  

  
  

  
  

  Report0 Reply
• C12H22O11 member

  January 2011

  Harper = girl.  I love Piper though.

  Ethan Michael - 12/21/09
  Norah Jewel - 2/26/14

  Report0 Reply
• EastCoastBride member

  January 2011

  Yeah, another vote for Harper = girl.

  "Beer is living proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."
  ~Benjamin Franklin

  
  DS dx with celiac disease 5/28/10

  Report0 Reply
• loveyoubean

  January 2011

  Like the girl name, your son is going to be battling his name forever.  While Harper may have started out a boys' name, like Avery, it now screams girl.  I would keep looking for the boy name.

  Report0 Reply
• onislandtime member

  January 2011

  Harper is totally a girl's name IMO. Robert is fine.

  I love Piper, but not a fan of Amaya. I really don't think Piper and Amaya flow well together.

  Report0 Reply
• starsjaime member

  January 2011

  Not a fan of Harper (girl or boy) or Piper.  But one thing i must agree one, is that Harper is a girls name.  It's one of those names that started out for a boy but now the girls have taken it over.  once the girls take it over (like completely over like they have), it's then not good to name a boy that.  

   But go with what you love! 

  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  
  

  Report0 Reply
• Melrose10 member

  January 2011

  C12H22O11:

  Harper = girl.  I love Piper though.

   

  this exactly
  

  

  Report0 Reply
• rsquaredr member

  January 2011

  Ugh. Harper is a girl's name. I mentioned this before but when I met someone who had two kids named Harper and Lily I asked how old her girls were. She said, "well my daughter Lily is 5 (or 6, don't remember) and my son Harper is 2." Awkward. Please don't use Harper for your son. Robert is good and I like Piper.

  Report0 Reply
• CocoBrynne

  January 2011

  cute, but I would be hesitant to name a boy Harper now bc it is getting to be a really popular girls name

  Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml

  Report0 Reply
• ames71 member

  January 2011

  Please don't name a boy Harper. I realize that it's a surname, but it's one that is much more often used for girls. The name was ranked #176 for girls by the SSA vs. #734 for boys. As an alternate, what about Holden? It has a literary connection like Harper, has the same number of syllables, and begins with an H, but is commonly associated with boys. Just a suggestion.

  I don't care for Amaya, but it's okay. I love Piper. 

  
  

  ---

  
  

  Report0 Reply
• Hope&Faith&Love

  January 2011

  I have to agree that Harper is a girl's name. I do love Piper though!

  Mommy to our sweet girls: Avery Terese 4/11/08 Lucy Elizabeth 9/10/09

  Report0 Reply
• mlf625

  January 2011

  Ditto the others.  Harper is a girl name, and Harper Robert doesn't sound that great with the double letter r running together.

  the bug & bee blog
  (read it. you know you want to.)
  anderson . september 2008
  vivian . february 2010
  mabel . august 2012
  

  Report0 Reply
• PhilsWife07 member

  January 2011

  Harper = girl.

  Piper is NMS.

  Love Robert. 

  P - 9/2008

  A - 8/2010

  L - 1/2013

  S - 3/2015

  Report0 Reply
• JaysonandKristin member

  January 2011

  Ceridwen21:

  Am I crazy, or did you post this the other day?

  I like your girl choice but Harper is NMS.

  Pretty sure she posted this on 1st tri for comments.

  OP, I am going to restate my original opinion in short.

  Robert is really the only name that I like from your combinations, and Harper is a girl's name. 

  Prudence

  
  

  Otis

   

  Hank 

   

  

  Report0 Reply
• [lu?ia]

  January 2011

  Harper Robert is okay. I definitely prefer Harper on a boy, but it's not a name I really care for myself. Robert is not one I'm a fan of, but it's a perfectly legit, well-spelled, masculine, strong name.
  I dislike Piper but Amaya is pretty. 

  Report0 Reply
• EHBean

  January 2011

  Please do not name your boy Harper. That's a girl's name!! Poor kid will be tortured. I have a guy friend named Carey and he hates it. People always think he's a girl. So embarassing.

  Report0 Reply
• EHBean

  January 2011

  Great suggestion on Holden!

  Report0 Reply
• LoveToTeach25

  January 2011

  I agree that Harper is becoming too popular as a girl's name to use it for a boy now.

  What about Hudson? It's more masculine (while still used for both boys & girls)

  I think Hudson Robert sounds nice.  

  Report0 Reply
• dufortc

  January 2011

  in this day and age names don't stick to gender! don't listen to them! i'm using Harper for a girl, but I think Harper is a beautiful name either way! I kinda thought Harper was a boy's name in the first place. Your girl's pick is a great choice too. Piper is always adorable! and I would've taken amaya but my cousin already named his daughter that. It's a great name! We think the same

  Report0 Reply
• RobinSparkles214 member

  January 2011

  Harper makes me think girl. I like it a lot though, only for a girl.

  Piper is cute, but doesn't flow well with Amaya IMO.

  Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml

  Report0 Reply