We got most of the decor (photo banner, cupcake toppers, yard sign, favor tags) from an etsy seller - Mary had a Little Party. LOVED their stuff. There are pics on my FB of his party which include decorations. Otherwise I got plates/cups/napkins/etc. from Party City in colors coordinating with the decor. For favors we did sugar cookies shaped like "1" that matched the invite and decor, from another etsy seller (Sugar and Flour, I think).
I did "Nathaniel and Caroline's Sweet Shoppe" I got the idea from the tomkatstudio
She also has an etsy shop in which she customized everything and I printed it out and assembled! I just got cups, plates,and napkins from party city, and I did clear jars with different candy and for the favor they got to fill a clear bag with candy. I have pics in my blog
Re: Where did you order your LO's birthday supplies...
After 2 rounds of IVF & 2 rounds of FET, we were blessed with identical twin girls!
I did "Nathaniel and Caroline's Sweet Shoppe" I got the idea from the tomkatstudio
She also has an etsy shop in which she customized everything and I printed it out and assembled! I just got cups, plates,and napkins from party city, and I did clear jars with different candy and for the favor they got to fill a clear bag with candy. I have pics in my blog