Baby Showers
Options

Am I rude or is my MIL?!

Warning: MIL VENT Tongue Tied

I'm dealing with the consequences of refusing (politely!) a second shower. My mom and SIL (hubby's sister) offered to co-host a shower at a central location for both sides of the family (DH and I live out of state and are driving 9 hours for the shower) I am excited and honored that they are wanting to host a shower for me.

Well, DH got off the phone with MIL. She felt like she wasn't included in the shower and wanted to know why she just now heard about it. (It had been planned THAT day, e-vites hadn't gone out) She proceeded to insist that she throw us another shower the next day (we are only there for that weekend.) I do NOT want to have two showers in the same weekend. (Is that snotty?!) I told her I would love to have a get-together or luncheon the next day but I really was not up for another full-blown shower when we only have two days there.

I wasn't going to ask MIL to plan a shower... my mom and SIL offered one first and they would be more than happy for MIL's input/participation. Sheesh.

Long story short... MIL is complaining that the shower my mom and SIL are planning isn't a good time for her and is basically annoying me to tears because she was "left out."  Phewww... that's better.

Daisypath Anniversary tickers image image Lilypie First Birthday tickers imageimage

Re: Am I rude or is my MIL?!

  • Options
    She didn't offer.  Not your problem.  =)
     Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
    <a href="http://www.thebump.com/?utm_source=ticker&utm_medium=HTML&utm_campaign=tickers" title="Pregnancy"><img src="http://global.thebump.com/tickers/tt1d55f2" alt=" Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker" border="0"  /></a>


  • Options

    The shower is a time for you -- it's about you. It sounds to me like your MIL is trying to make it all about her (I have that same problem, too). I think you handled it well: suggesting a light lunch the day after. Don't worry about her being left out - she will get over it. So long as she was included (invited), I don't see what the problem is.

     Carry on, girlfriend. :)

  • Loading the player...
  • Options
    You could always ask your mom and SIL if MIL could be included in the planning (if you think that would satisfy her).  Odd that your SIL wouldn't have thought her own mother might like to be involved.  Hmmmm.  I think your idea of the luncheon the next day is a good one.  If she doesn't want to go with that (or help your Mom and SIL) then she'll just have to be left out.  Personally, I don't think grandmothers-to-be should be hosts anyway.  JMO
  • Options

    I find it pretty telling SIL didn't even think/want to include her mom...based on MIL's reaction, as well, I'm guessing she might be a pain to work with.

    I'm firmly in the camp that a shower is mostly up to the hosts, but one thing the honoree has the right to do is politely refuse.  There are times when I do think it is nice to 'let' someone throw you a shower (for example, if your mom was throwing one just for your family, I'd think it was rude to refuse one from MIL for her family), but since SIL is involved and it already includes the IL side of the family I'd just let her complaints roll off your back and change the subject whenever it comes up.


    image
  • Options
    imagekdodge423:
    imagesarahmrue:

     (It had been planned THAT day, e-vites hadn't gone out)

    Your MIL is rude, but this is tacky.

     

     

    I left the invite thing up to the hosts. I wasn't going to demand paper invitations and that they pay for postage. I agree that a traditional invitation is more personal (and I will be mailing out hand-written thank-yous!) But it wasn't my call... They did make some really cute e-vites at punchbowl.com. Plus you don't have to worry about losing the info on a piece of paper if it's always in your email.   

     Thanks everyone for hearing out my vent-session! Hopefully down-playing the situation will ease the drama. Smile

    Daisypath Anniversary tickers image image Lilypie First Birthday tickers imageimage
  • Options

    I think for her to take it personally is pretty inconsiderate.  She could very well call the other hosts and maybe help them plan the one being held or contribute in some way if she can't make it. If not, she should just let it be. It's hard enough dealing with so many hormones and emotions, but to add her 'tude to the mix is totally unnecessary.

    Take a deep breath...

    IAmPregnant Ticker BabyFruit Ticker
  • Options
    On top of the already-posted observations on your MIL being totally unreasonable, if your SIL is already involved in the first shower, who in the world does your MIL expect to show up the very next day?
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Options
    I agree that your MIL is trying to make the shower experience about her rather than you guys and the bundle of joy you are supposed to be celebrating.  If she really wanted to do something FOR you and baby she could offer to help somehow with the originally planned shower.  I completely understand your frustration. 
    TTC in May 2009.
    M/C July 2009.
    BFP #2 6/1/11(1st cycle on Clomid)
    Norah Lynn was born on 2/3/2012
    TTC again January 2014



    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker


    Trying to Conceive Ticker
  • Options

    I guess its hard for me to feel bad for people that complain about MIL's that just want to be involved.

    I would give anything to have my MIL here to meet this baby in April. My daughter will never know her grandma. Being mad about showers just seems silly to me.

    Hopefully you realize what matters and what does not.

    Photobucket Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • Options
    I think it's great that so many of your relatives are wanting to give you a shower. When I asked my mom/sisters about hosting a shower in my hometown, they told me it was tacky for family to host a shower--I told them that was "old" rules, nowadays it is much more acceptable. You are fortunate to have family that is so thoughtful, even if you do have what sounds to be a high-maintenance MIL.
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"