I actually went out on a limb (a BIG limb for me!) and bought ugly Disney paper this year for the kids to enjoy. It won't be the beautiful presentation of gifts *I* love, but they are all excited about it. Even the big guys. I have NO idea how I am going to find ribbon to coordinate yet though.
I usually check Hobby Lobby and Old Navy has had some good paper in the past. Costco sometimes has very thick reversible paper in patterns I like too.
I usually get mine at either Sam's or Costco. I prefer theirs since it's usually the thicker kind and many times like pp mentioned it's reversible. I hate paper that tears too easily!
Ditto Costco. I got a two pack last year and it was actually good quality! I picked a blue and silver pattern that had snow flakes in the pattern on one side, but the other didn't, so I was able to use it to wrap gifts all year long. Very pretty!
I buy all my wrapping paper at Hobby Lobby. I love the quality of it, nice and thick to make pretty corners. Sams has all the extras, real ribbon, cute tags etc for cheap, but I spend a little extra on the paper.
Re: NBR: Where's all the pretty wrapping paper?
I usually check Hobby Lobby and Old Navy has had some good paper in the past. Costco sometimes has very thick reversible paper in patterns I like too.