Snaps for me (Fuzzibunz perfect size), Aplix for DH (Bumgenius 4.0)
This exactly, except we have other brands thrown in the mix as well. Mostly FB and BG though. I like blueberry with a bamboo insert quite a bit though, we have them in snaps and aplix.
I picked both because I like them for different reasons. I use Fuzzibunz and BumGenius 4.0 snaps during the day and BumGenius 3.0 aplix and Blueberry aplix at night. I find the aplix so much easier to use at night when I'm half asleep and it is still pretty dark in the room. Also, I've noticed that if I let someone else diaper her (like my DH or my mom) they are more comfortable with the aplix.
I've only been doing this for a couple of months, and I liked aplix at first, but I'm already starting to notice the aplix is not wearing so well. I've been very diligent about sticking the tabs down before I wash them, but they're still not holding up so well. Also, Caroline loves to pull them off. She has even figured out that she can undo the velcro through her pants!
So far I've only used Thirsties, but I just got a couple of Blueberries in the mail today. I use prefolds with them.
Re: Mama's Who Currently CD
I voted for snaps since they hold up better than aplix.
I've only been doing this for a couple of months, and I liked aplix at first, but I'm already starting to notice the aplix is not wearing so well. I've been very diligent about sticking the tabs down before I wash them, but they're still not holding up so well. Also, Caroline loves to pull them off. She has even figured out that she can undo the velcro through her pants!
So far I've only used Thirsties, but I just got a couple of Blueberries in the mail today. I use prefolds with them.