So how does anyone get their LOs to stay in time out? DS1 was good at staying in his chair at first, but once he stopped being scared of it (its a child's sized rocking chair that was mine when I was little) he's always getting down and just running up to me and laughing. I've told him no and put him back in the chair but he just slides right out again. It's really getting frustrating! We started putting him in his crib if he climbs out of the chair, but I don't know if that is even telling him anything... plus its a PITA to carry a flailing child up the stairs. What do you ladies do? Any advice is appreciated.
Re: Time outs
The one time I've done it, I put him in his high chair, because that was the one place I could think of to strap him in. I've heard of people that say they sit LO on the couch, and that would last about a milisecond in our house. I'll be interested to see what other people do.
I put him in the crib or pack and play.
I tend to agree with this. We try to either ignore/redirect, or use natural consequences, i.e. if you throw your toy at me, you lose it for a while.
I agree. We say "no" and redirect. If he tosses something on the floor, it is taken away for a while
Our TO spot is just a spot on the floor in front of the living room closet door. I kind of do the Super Nanny thing and just put them back in place without saying anything.
Alex doesn't really get TO yet but Will does and he actually caught on pretty quickly to the idea that if he gets up, TO will just last longer, so he stays put. He tends to misbehave when he gets overly hyper and spirals out of control (and starts hitting, or throwing something hard at one of us, etc.), so TO works really well with him; it kind of interrupts the spiral and helps him calm down and listen.
Yeah, we do a lot of natural consequences as well. That works well for some things. TO helps when what's needed is to calm down. I do think it really depends on the kid though, especially at this age; with two the same age, we find they respond so differently to the same things.