Ours has completely careened out of control.
Reading mrs.george's post below, I do chalk a lot of this up to DS's age but my lord I do not know how to regain control. Now that he is mostly potty-trained, his last stunt of every night is telling us "pee is coming, I need to go potty." The first couple of times we believed him, and at least once he did go.
But now, he wants a million books, a million songs, a million drinks of water, and has to go potty.
Seriously. How do you get two kids in bed before 10 PM? I'm ready to hang myself.


Re: Please share your bedtime routine - esp. if you have two kids.
Married to my BFF on 8.13.05 (after dating 5 years)!
DS born 2.14.08. DD born 9.30.09.
Finding a routine and sticking to it is the only thing that has worked for us. I had to have them in bed by 8:00 when I was in school so we've stuck with that routine.
At 7 we do bath (every other night), books, homework, etc. At 7:30 each kid gets to watch their nightly show. For DS it's Diego and DD it's iCarly.They always eat their daily apple (they love apples and it somehow became part of the routine) during this time too.
They're pretty much trained to know that once their show is over they brush their teeth, give everyone hugs and kisses and hit the bed.They share a room and usually spend about 10-15 minutes talking or snuggling before they fall asleep.
I've been through all the stall tactics with both of mine and the only thing that has worked is removing their nightlight or music from the room until they stay in bed quietly for 5 minutes. Then the light comes back on.
Our routine is about 7:30-8ish I take Sawyer upstairs, PJ's, teeth, nurse bed. so easy.
8:00-8:30 DH takes Jack upstairs- PJ's, teeth, pee, drink, one book, 2 songs, prayers, (I usually go in and sing)
Sometiems he gets up for something silly, like a long lost animal he never plays with, or because he "forgot " something, but we are pretty strict about the routine and he doesn't, surprisingly, stray too much from it. It usually takes about 20 minutes. (also remember he doesn't nap anymore, so he is probably pretty tired)
This sounds silly, but what about making a bedtime chart? Make a list of what has to happen in he exact order and if he does it he gets a prize? (which may be just a smiley face on the chart) or a sticker, or positive feedback or whatever.
Then just talk it up through the day, explaining that this is the new plan?
Jackson is really into Calendars, grocery lists, dys f the week, stuff like that right now so I think it would work well for him.
good luck.