Cincinnati Babies

POLL: FF for a week, or rent a carseat

We are going to Hilton Head for Thanksgiving this year, and my parents called the other day to tell us they bought a Graco Nautilus for Sawyer.

The problem is, the Nautilus doesn't RF.

So, we are debating what to do. I think I would like to rent a convertible carseat for the week, which will cost about $60.00.

DH says he will be fine for a week FF in a 5 pt harness.

He is about 25 lbs.

What would you do?

 

[Poll]

Re: POLL: FF for a week, or rent a carseat

  • Why can't you bring your carseat?

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Loading the player...
  • well, we are flying.

    I guess we could bring it, but we already have so much stuff with the luggage, the double stroller, carryon's, diaper bag....

    that may be an option though...

     

  • Gotcha!
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Can you explain this to your parents and have them exchange it for a Sencera or something that RFs?
    image Ready to rumble.
  • I could, but really, in the long run, he will need the Nautilus anyways. (unls the ones you mentioned RF and FF, I am not sure )

    We will probably switch him around 18- 24 months, and since we only visit them 2x a year, it would only apply to this visit.

     

  • I think your peace of mind will be worth the $60.

    When we went to Hawaii when Rylee was 13 months old we special ordered cab to take up to and from the airport. It showed up with a FF facing carseat. I cried the whole way to the hotel.

  • Amanda, you are so sweet. I couldn't help but chuckle reading that!
  • imageMelissaMc22:

    I could, but really, in the long run, he will need the Nautilus anyways. (unls the ones you mentioned RF and FF, I am not sure )

    We will probably switch him around 18- 24 months, and since we only visit them 2x a year, it would only apply to this visit.

     

     

    If exchanging is an option what about the Graco My Ride 65

    https://www.amazon.com/Graco-My-Ride-Car-Seat/dp/B003JSX68I

    It rear faces to 40 pounds and harnesses to 65 pounds and is the same or cheaper than the graco

     

  • hmmmm.... I will definitely ask. Thanks!
  • I'd be afraid of how he'd react to going back to RF when you get home.
    image Ready to rumble.
  • imageKristenBtobe:
    I'd be afraid of how he'd react to going back to RF when you get home.

     

    Ditto this!  I was thinking the same thing.  I would see if they could exchange it.

    image
    Jennie Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • We had to do something similar to DD when she was around 12-13 mos old. She went back to rear facing just fine (although back then extended rear facing wasn't as popular).

    Besides, don't statistics show that the majority of car accidents happen within a 2 mile radius of the home or something like that?  Stick out tongue

  • When we flew to Florida we bought this https://www.toysrus.com/product/index.jsp?productId=2910024 

    and just brought our carseat along with us. The bag was easy to use and really helped keep the carseat from getting dirty, torn, etc.

    It fit our Britax Marathon perfectly and was super easy. They consider it a "specialty" item so it didn't count as luggage.

    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • imagewarrior*mom:

    We had to do something similar to DD when she was around 12-13 mos old. She went back to rear facing just fine (although back then extended rear facing wasn't as popular).

    We were in the same predicament when DD was 15 months. She FF'ed for a week and had no trouble going back to RF'ing when we got home.  

    Lilypie Fifth Birthday tickers Lilypie Third Birthday tickers
  • On an unrelated note, I'm sending you a PM.
    imageimage
    Matilda 6/19/09
    Graham 10/25/13
  • I am doing research on FFing vs RFing for a speech I am giving.  Now that I know the statistics:

    A child RFing is 75% less likely to die or be seriously injured in a crash

    During a crash in forward facing seats the neck is subjected to a force of 300kg vs 50kg in the rear facing seat. 

    I know I personally couldn't handle him being FFing for even a week.   

    Image and video hosting by TinyPic Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Pregnancy Ticker
  • This would be my fear as well.

    ETA:  Ack, the quote didn't work.  I'd be afraid he'd resist going back to RF.

  • imageTraycee1242:

    When we flew to Florida we bought this https://www.toysrus.com/product/index.jsp?productId=2910024 

    and just brought our carseat along with us. The bag was easy to use and really helped keep the carseat from getting dirty, torn, etc.

    It fit our Britax Marathon perfectly and was super easy. They consider it a "specialty" item so it didn't count as luggage.

    We took our carseat with us when we flew to Myrtle Beach, too.  We had a bag to put it in and gate checked it (along with our stroller) and it was no big deal at all.

    image
    Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers
  • I would either bring your seat, have them exchange the seat for something that RF and FF, or have them or you buy a Cosco Scenera which would be cheaper than renting a seat, and then you could sell it on craigslist or something if you wish.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I personally would just use the one your mom has FFing for that week or take yours.  I would not rent one.  I don't think he would have an issue switching.  Kids are more flexible then we give them credit for :-)  The Graco Nautilus is a very comfy and safely designed seat and even has side impact.  Kileigh is not in it yet since she is not 20lbs but she LOVES sitting in her brothers extra one (haven't put it in Jeremys car yet, LOL!).  Good luck in your decision!
    Our kids are 19mths apart and we LOVE it!!

    Married to my BFF on 8.13.05 (after dating 5 years)!

    DS born 2.14.08. DD born 9.30.09.

  • I picked Shiver me timbers.  Cause it was fun.  :)

    I would see if your parents could exchange it or I would bring mine on the plane.  Or do they have any other friends who are also grandparents who they could borrow a RF seat from?

    I was just way to nervous to switch that close to a year.  GL!

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"