moby wrap or sling???

aps003 · July 2010

I cant decide anyone have any opinions on this??? I love how easy the sling looks to get on, but I love how snuggly the moby wrap keeps baby to you but it looks hard to put on! anyone have expierance or researched it better than me I would love to know what you ended up with!!!tia

FishNchips1 · July 2010

Not that I have personally used it yet..but I hear the moby wrap is awesome!

JamieFL · July 2010

I have a Moby and a Bjorn when I had DS. I used the Moby twice because it was so flippin' hot in Florida at the end of August. I know people suggest tying it on and leaving it on, especially if you're driving somewhere, and then putting the baby in at your destination. This was impossible since it was ridiculously warm and confining for me.

Also, I am a little inept and it wasn't the easiest thing to tie and get the right amount of room for the baby. I always seemed to make it too tight or too loose.

The Bjorn I used from about 4 months on with him. Since that time, I now know how bad it can be for the baby's hips and being suspended that way. I've bought an Ergo for this baby, so we'll see.

Be careful with the sling because my understanding is that you need a correct fit (after delivery, basically) to determine the size for the baby. If it's too loose, the baby could be in danger of falling. I'd ask over on the AP (attachment parenting) board for ideas, too.

sabinameister · July 2010

I bought the Moby and it is way more versatile than a sling. I talked to a mom of 6 who has both and she raves about the Moby and how her babies just loved it. She barely used her slip b/c it wasn't as tight and just not versatile.

stephanieroyer · July 2010

i bought a moby because i had heard such great things about them. i personally havent used it yet. i used a snugli for DS and we both hated it so i knew i needed to upgrade. from what i hear the moby looks hard to use but you catch on easy..im hoping this is true, im excited to use it.

Allie30 · July 2010

There are lots of Moby-like things that aren't as hot. Check out the attachment parenting board and becoming mama's website -- you can get wraps that are woven, etc.

aps003 · July 2010

thanks I am ordering the moby for sure!

haleybeth81 · July 2010

I have both and used both at different stages. Moby would be better for the newborn stage and small infant, but I love the sling for when DD was bigger and a toddler. Also it is much easier to throw a sling on although once they're bigger I wouldn't recommend it for long trips (it starts to hurt your back)

eta I use a ring sling because it's much easier to adjust.

Dobie_Mama · July 2010

My vote is for a woven wrap. It's snuggly, like a Moby, but you can use it longer because it's more supportive for heavier babies/toddlers.

Waiting4myJulyBaby · July 2010

Hi, lurking from 0-3 but wanted to share my opinion. I love the moby- it does keep LO very snug but it is very hot in this weather and kind of complicated to put on- that being said once it's on you can take the baby in and out (for diaper changes, feeding etc) without having to take it off. With my 3 week old I highly recommend a mei tai style carrier, mine is Kozy brand and it's super comfortable, easy to use and my LO loves it (he was 7 lbs when I started using it). Another benefit to this style carrier is that you can BF discreetly while wearing it- you may be able to with the Moby too, I'm not sure. Hope this helps!

heatouel85 · July 2010

i loved the moby with DD, and i plan to use it with DS also, just haven't had a need for it yet. you can totally BF discretely with one once you get the hang of it, and after tying it a couple of times it gets very easy, promise!

KathyStraw · July 2010

I bought the moby wrap and you can use it as a sling as well, there are many different position you can use the moby wrap for. I haven't tried it yet because my 20 month old wants nothing to do with it.

erinjcianciolo · July 2010

i have both a Moby and Maya Ring Sling. i really like them both, but for different stages. I used the Maya Sling when DD was really small, but read FAR too many reports of infants suffocating in the cradle position because of the way their necks were laying, so i switched to the Moby wrap until she was old enough to sit upright on her own. I loved how snuggly and close it kept DD. Once you get the hang of putting it on, it's a piece of cake! Also, you can make your own Moby for a lot cheaper than you can buy one and it's SUPER easy!

i still use the Maya Sling almost every day and DD is 13 months old, she loves riding on my hip while we are out and about and it doesn't crush my big belly.

i did however just buy a Lillebaby Everywhere Carrier as it will do all 5 carrying positions in one carrier - we'll see how it goes when DS gets here in September!

BearsMrs · July 2010

I consider the moby wrap a must have. My DS#1 stayed in the moby wrap all the time until he was about 8 months old. Slings are easier to use, but I think they put too much strain on one shoulder & the baby will outgrow it sooner. If you have to choose between one or the other I'd definitely go with the moby.

mrs.g_6708 · July 2010

There are a ton of how to put the moby wrap on tutorials on youtube. It seems difficult at first, but these women do it with such ease and take the time to explain every step.

adnesekfi1 · July 2010

have heard amazing things about the mob, so that is what i am going with! My friend (and parent of 4) uses it all the time (her baby is now 3 months) and she loves it! not only that every time i see her wearing it her baby looks happy and content (can i buy that too???) lol

deltadawn79 · July 2010

If you are tall I would recommend the moby or any other wrap that you tie. I am 5'10" and my husband is 6"2" and we found the slings to be too small and uncomfortable to work for us.

Also the moby fabric is a bit stretchy so you may need to re-try if you wear for a long time.

Want a personalized experience?

moby wrap or sling???

Re: moby wrap or sling???

Choose Another Board

Search Boards