Toddlers: 12 - 24 Months

Gender Bias Question..

So my son is a year he LOVES only Dora (Not Diego, I tried); I bought him a Dora book and a Dora beach towel and he loves those two things so much. I wanted to buy him a Dora doll but everyone I talk to thinks its the worst idea in the world if he were to carry his doll out in public. My mother in particular is against it because he likes to brush his hair or put my headbands on his head and say "Pretty".. she thinks I'm trying to make him into a  "girl"

I'm kind of torn on what to do.

I was just wondering what everyones views are on it & if you have let your sons play with dolls or do other things that are considered "girly".

Re: Gender Bias Question..

  • I don't have a son, but I would let him play with it and carry it around outside if he wanted to.  I wouldn't keep anything from DD just cuz it was "boyish."
    imageimageimage
  • Loading the player...
  • Buy it for him.  Tell your mother to deal.  DS loves Dora. I never understand these questions.  I buy toys my son likes.  I have no concerns about making him "girly".  He'll be who he will be and toy selection for a toddler will not change that.
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Third Birthday tickers Lilypie Pregnancy tickers
  • I'd totally buy it for him. It won't hurt anything, and it doesn't make your DS "girly." To him, it's just another fun toy.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I would buy him the doll.  Tell your mother it's an "action figure". 
    Formerly known as ms.mittens Jude 12/31/2008 Ezra 2/10/2011 Nora 7/23/2013 Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • I really hate these questions.  Buy your son a Dora doll.  Or a play kitchen.  Or whatever toy makes him happy.  Your mom wouldn't say anything if you bought your daughter a ball or a truck, so it shouldn't matter the other way around.  My 3 year old girl just had a Thomas the Train birthday party.  It was awesome.
  • My DS loves to feed the baby dolls at daycare.  I got him a boy baby doll so he can have a baby to play with that my husband would approve of (well, or at least he can put up with it).  I love that DS gives kisses constantly, hugs and kisses all his stuffed animals, and is gentle with babies. 

    If he likes Dora, get him Dora.  Other than your family's annoying comments, the only other thing that may get old is people maybe assuming he is a girl?  For whatever reason, people are idiots and still thing DS is a girl when he is wearing something with trucks on it. 

  • I'd be fine with letting my DS's do that.
    fraternal twin boys born january 2009
  • You post makes me LOL. I think it's very cute that he's so into Dora. It's totally normal. Little boys don't understand that they aren't "supposed" to like dolls or Dora or whatever. Let him have his fun.

    Finn has gone through phases where he was obsessed with (in no particular order) my makeup, baby dolls, the color pink, having his cousin's barrettes in his hair and (my personal favorite) a pink hand-me-down Care Bear that had to go everywhere with us and said things like "A CARE-IFFIC DAY IS HEADED YOUR WAY!!!" very loudly when squeezed. I can't count the number of side-eyes that thing got us. All of it passed, and right now he's obsessed with dump trucks, bulldozers and dinosaurs. Tomorrow it might be Cinderella. Who knows? Who cares?

  • I bought my DD matchbox cars for christmas and she loves them.  As long as they are happy who cares. Kids don't know the difference unless you make a big deal out of it.  Let kids be kids.
  • My daughter cares nothing for baby dolls but loves all cars and trucks. Of course I let her have them- who cares if some people think only "boys" should play with cars? Stupid, stupid generalities. 
  • My baby brother used to paint his toenails with my mom and sisters (blue, because that's for BOYS, lol.) He was also in figure skating until he got big enough for hockey. He played with Barbies and dolls and wore my sisters' dress up clothes. So far, it doesn't appear like it's damaged him for life. In fact, now he is a stereotypical boy. On the other hand, my parents tried to push the girly girl thing on me. I wanted to play hockey, they said "no that's for boys." Made me wear dresses every day until 3rd grade. Curled and braided my hair. etc. etc. and I turned out to be a tomboy for most of my childhood and didn't get "girly" again until I was 17. 

    Letting your child explore their interests or refusing to because of gender roles is not going to determine your child's sexuality or personality. So why not let them have fun with the things they like? It's really, really not going to hurt him.

  • Honestly, I don't see the big deal with it. I think people that have issue with these type of things are.... odd. While I was a nanny, one of the little boys (he only had an older sister) wanted to dress up like Cinderella, and the dad totally freaked out. He immediately bought him a bunch of trucks and "boyish" videos. No joke.

    I bought DD an Iron Man t-shirt. She loves it. She also has a little t-shirt with a vintage Ford Mustang on it. It is definitely a boys shirt, but I don't care, she totally loves it.

    My brothers both had Cabbage Patch dolls when they were little. I promise they don't paint their nails or wear pink now. Wink

    AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers AlternaTickers - Cool, free Web tickers
  • I would let him.  My some is a little over a year and dh thinks I'm trying to make my son just like me because he wants to wear my sun glasses and tries to put on my make up when its sitting out but he's just doing it because he watches me everyday.  I'm not worried at all.
  • imagems.mittens:
    I would buy him the doll.  Tell your mother it's an "action figure". 
    (snickering...action figure!) Good one!
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Agreed with hewinked. I think the double standard is ridiculous. I dont keep DD from playing with cars or buzz lightyear b/c it will make her boyish! Dumb. I have a quite a few friends who buy their boys dolls, its not a big deal.

     

    ETA: I dont mean to sound like I'm calling you dumb BTW, just the double standard thing!

    My 2 girls, both born on a Friday the 13th, are exactly 2 years, 2 months, 2 hours and 2 minutes apart! And Baby Boy joined us October 11, 2013! image
    Lilypie Kids Birthday tickers Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • I think people are pretty stupid when they worry about these kind of things (no offense to your mom).  I'd have no problem with Adam carrying around a girl doll.

    I'd ask them what exactly they're worried about.  It's not like you can really make him into a girl.  He's a toddler.  He doesn't know boy vs girl yet.

  • My son has a doll. The reason he was nice to it and helps him be gentile with little ones. Also I was told boys who play with dolls of any kind make better dads. My sons doll is a teaching doll like zippers and buttons I think it is good for him. 
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • DS has a little baby doll that we got him for "practice" on being gentle with little brother. I have no problem with him wanting to play with girly toys. We bought him a play kitchen for Christmas. We're thinking of getting him an outdoor playhouse for his birthday in September. I wouldn't let other peoples complexes about gender roles impact my son's playtime.
    P - 9/2008
    A - 8/2010
    L - 1/2013
    S - 3/2015
  • Get him the doll, he will love it and that is what matters! I get my daughter trains and little toy cars. I think it's good that they are exposed to both.
  • let the kid play with his doll.  I totally would.  He'll be a daddy one day, probably.
  • Do it! And I'll finally cave and buy DS a baby doll stroller. :)

    I've been struggling over it. He loves pushing the pinkest girliest stollers (ever notice they are all pink?) when we're at Pottery Barn Kids and I know he would love it but am hesitant to do it. DH and I agreed we'll buy him one if it's not pink and then he can put his trucks and robots in it.

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"