Infertility

Is it ridiculous to go back to IUIs after 3 failed IVFs?

Hi ladies.

I'm just sitting here trying to figure out what we'll do if this third IVF is a BFN (negative this AM at 6dp5dt).  IUIs are covered by my insurance, but IVF is not.  So you can imagine what our debt looks like right now, after 3.  I was just thinking, my tubes are open and we don't have MFI.  Since I just had a lap in April, maybe it's worth a shot to do a couple of IUIs while we take a break from all the shots and payments. 

But, would it be a waste?  I can't decide what to steer towards next.  I'm just about at the end of my rope.

TIA for any advice.

dx'd with severe endo and poor egg quality 3 IUIs were all BFN IVF #1 = c/p IVF #2 = BFN IVF #3 = beautiful baby girl born 2/2011; 8/2011 Surprise BFP - natural m/c at 8w; TTC #2 2011-2012; 2 IUIs = BFN; IVF #1 = BFP 9dp5dt beta = 328; 11dp5dt = 650; 13dp5dt = 1114; 18dp5dt = 4747 BabyFetus Ticker

Re: Is it ridiculous to go back to IUIs after 3 failed IVFs?

  • I have thought of doing this as well and we even have MFI. I wouldn't think it could hurt. And if it's covered, you might as well. GL to you sweetie.
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • Loading the player...
  • I am still totally praying for a BFP for you this cycle.

    But if it's not, then I don't think it can hurt to try a few IUIs.

    Good luck hon :) 

    image
    Unexplained Infertility

    After two Clomid cycles, three injectable IUI cycles, two IVFs, two miscarriages, and one lap surgery, IVF #2 has brought us our little boy!

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker

    TTC #2
    After months of being postponed or cancelled, FET #1.3 (Natural FET) brought us twin girls!

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker


    Surprise! Baby #4 is due in March!
  • jani7jani7 member
    I don't think it's crazy at all!  Esp with your insurance coverage the way it is.  Good luck!
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • I'd defintiely try IUI.

    I think someone on SAIF (sorry- can't remember who) had a few failed IVF's followed by a last ditch IUI which led to the BFP. 

    Lilypie Fourth Birthday tickers Lilypie First Birthday tickers
  • I don't think it's crazy at all! I think it's a good way to go.
    I married my best friend 6/24/07. Started TTC. Ectopic pregnancy found at 6 wks 5 d.(methotrexate shot on 11/21/07). 1st IUI (natural/August '09) - bfn; 2nd IUI (w/ gonal-f) - bfn 3rd IUI (w/ gonal-f) - bfn 4th IUI - cancelled due to too many follicles Laparoscopy 1/10 - endo found 5th IUI (w/ follistism) - bfn 6th IUI (w/ follistism) - bfn Taking a break b/f starting ivf June - IVF - failed December - IFV#2 - failed Trying naturally again for now
  • I don't think it will hurt to try them.  You never know what could happen!
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • If it's covered by insurance, I don't think it is crazy at all!!! Crazier things have happened. GL!
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • I don't think it's a waste at all.  Even though I'm hoping you don't have to make this decision and have a BFP for this cycle, I think that going back to IUIs isn't a bad idea.  Your insurance will be covering it.  It may give you a chance to get out of some of the IVF debt and save for another IVF cycle down the road if you need/want it.  But, you would still be cycling with IUIs while doing all of that. 

    I was just talking to DH about this.  We got pg with both IUIs (but had early losses both times).  If this IVF doesn't work, we really want to sit down with the doctor and discuss IUI vs IVF in my case.

    GL with whatever you decide!

    *P/SAIFW* TTC since 1/08 Clomid, 2 IUIs, 4 IVFs, FET 7 losses Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  • It certainly wouldn't hurt and if it is covered why not!!! I am really hoping you don't have to do it though and this will be a BFP cycle!!!
    image
  • I would do it.  Though hopefully you won't have to ;-)
  • I would do it. Every little bit of help, helps. But I'm hoping you won't even have to consider that option. Fingers crossed for a BFP!
    +++
  • I think it's still really early to call it a BFN, and I'm stil hoping you get pregnant this cycle, but I went to IUI after doing two IVFs. So I don't think it's crazy at all.
    IVF #1 BFN... IVF #2 BFP! TWINS!
    Twins born too early at 23 weeks due to incompetent cervix
    FET #1, IUI #1, 2, 3, 4 - all BFN
    IVF #3 BFP!!! IT'S A BOY! Born July 16th, 2011
    FET #2 BFP! Due February 15, 2013
    Pregnancy Ticker
    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker


    image
  • I don't think it would hurt to try again - you never know. Especially since it's covered by insurance. Let us know what you decide!
    Warning No formatter is installed for the format bbhtml
  • How was your quality at ET? I got pregnant a  few times from IUI's but they didnt end well. My RE wanted me to do IVF to see the quality. Well I just did my 2nd transfer and honestly my quality was great for my age. I am in debt from this and will have to go back to IUI's if this one dosent work out. Because My quality was good we are thinking my clotting disorders and lining issues are to blame. So, my RE pretty much had me do IVF as a diagnostic. How did your embies look at transfer?
    1-20-09 BFP third month of Follistim IUI 02-19-09 MC 06-24-09 MC July IUI Follistim Ganirelix Ovidrel Crinone=BFN Aug. IUI Follistim Ganirelix ovidrel Crinone=BFP= scared sh**less 10-12-09 MC = 1 ectopic 1 perfect Dec. IUI Gonal-F Ganirelix Ovidrel Crinone Lovenox 01-02-10 BFP=scared sh**less again 01-06-10 CP SAIF ALWAYS WELCOME : ) March 2010 - IVF in progress converted to IUI 03-30-10 BFN April 2010 - IVF - BFFN June 2010 - IVF - BFFN July IUI BFP! March 26 2011 Gracie is here! imageImage and video hosting by TinyPic imageImage and video hosting by TinyPic
  • imageginger67:
    How was your quality at ET? I got pregnant a  few times from IUI's but they didnt end well. My RE wanted me to do IVF to see the quality. Well I just did my 2nd transfer and honestly my quality was great for my age. I am in debt from this and will have to go back to IUI's if this one dosent work out. Because My quality was good we are thinking my clotting disorders and lining issues are to blame. So, my RE pretty much had me do IVF as a diagnostic. How did your embies look at transfer?

    I don't have very good quality embies.  For all 3 IVFs, there have been a total of 18 embryos (I think) and I've never made an "A"  or "AA".  The best we've had was BB with some fragmentation :/

    dx'd with severe endo and poor egg quality 3 IUIs were all BFN IVF #1 = c/p IVF #2 = BFN IVF #3 = beautiful baby girl born 2/2011; 8/2011 Surprise BFP - natural m/c at 8w; TTC #2 2011-2012; 2 IUIs = BFN; IVF #1 = BFP 9dp5dt beta = 328; 11dp5dt = 650; 13dp5dt = 1114; 18dp5dt = 4747 BabyFetus Ticker
  • Thats a good number of embies. Maybe your RE could be more aggressive with your IUI meds? If I have do do IUI's again ( I pray I dont) Im going to ask my RE if I can do the same meds I do for IVF, adding menopur, patches. GL!
    1-20-09 BFP third month of Follistim IUI 02-19-09 MC 06-24-09 MC July IUI Follistim Ganirelix Ovidrel Crinone=BFN Aug. IUI Follistim Ganirelix ovidrel Crinone=BFP= scared sh**less 10-12-09 MC = 1 ectopic 1 perfect Dec. IUI Gonal-F Ganirelix Ovidrel Crinone Lovenox 01-02-10 BFP=scared sh**less again 01-06-10 CP SAIF ALWAYS WELCOME : ) March 2010 - IVF in progress converted to IUI 03-30-10 BFN April 2010 - IVF - BFFN June 2010 - IVF - BFFN July IUI BFP! March 26 2011 Gracie is here! imageImage and video hosting by TinyPic imageImage and video hosting by TinyPic
  • JM1977JM1977 member

    I'm sorry for what you're going through!  I don't know if I could go back to IUIs at this point.  I think it would feel too much like going backwards.  I definitely don't think there would be anything wrong with it, though!

    Has your dr. recommended any further testing?  It seems like you've had a reasonable number of embryos - do they think it could be an implantation issue or primarily egg/embryo quality?

    I wish you the best!

    TTC with DOR, low morphology, fertilization issues
    IVF#1 Oct 2009 (CCRM) - BFN
    IVF#2 March 2010 - Poor response/cancelled
    DE IVF#1 Aug 2010 - BFN
    DE IVF#2 Dec 2010 - Transferred 1, 2 frozen - BFP!
    TTC#2 FET Jan 2013 - Transferred 1 - BFP!

    Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker Baby Birthday Ticker Ticker
  •  I did an IUI after a failed IVF and 2 failed FETs. I figured we didn't have much to lose since it is much easier on the body then going through another IVF. 

    Hopefully this cycle will still be a success for you. But if it's not, and you are planning to take a break from another IVF cycle, I say go for the IUI's especially if your insurance pays for it. It is so much easier on your body and your wallet. Good luck to you on whichever path you choose!

This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"