Colgate Classica I vs. III? Can't decide...

sescms2004 · June 2010

So, the Colgate Classica I gets rave reviews as the best mattress out there for the price ($150). The Classica III has the firm side for infants plus a softer side for toddlers. TreasureRooms.com has them both for the same price (the III is usually more$). Which would you get?

shellyxo · June 2010

I got the III. I like it but I haven't used it yet.

erin033 · June 2010

I got the III but haven't used it yet. I was originally going to get the I but diapers.com price matched treasure rooms for the III and I used a 10 percent off code. So it ended up being cheaper.

amiserip · June 2010

I got the I b/c I liked that it was firmer.

redtulip · June 2010

Classica III. We have it for our current DS and bought another one for baby #2.

bethanylang · June 2010

We got the III

MrsH2you · June 2010

I called the mfg and found out that the III firm side is the II and not the I. The I is the only mattress recommended for over 12 years by consumer reports as well as Baby Bargains. As a result I went with the I.

Want a personalized experience?

Colgate Classica I vs. III? Can't decide...

Re: Colgate Classica I vs. III? Can't decide...

Choose Another Board

Search Boards