Long Island Babies

Mother's Day Decison ... need to decide fast!

We are first time parents and my husband wanted to take me and our five month old son out for a Mother's Day brunch at either the Garden City Hotel for $69.00 pp or The Carltun in Eisenhower Park for $49.00 pp. Bother menus seem the same except that the Carltun breaks it down more specifically. I know this is a nice decision to have to make but which would you go with? I have been to GC many years ago in the Polo Room for dinner and used to go to there night club when I was single but I have never been The Carltun at all. Anyone hear things lately about these places? Which would you go with? I need to decide soon

Re: Mother's Day Decison ... need to decide fast!

  • We went to a wedding at The Carltun and it was very nice and I remember the food was good. Enjoy!
  • Loading the player...
  • My DH and I just had brunch at the Garden City Hotel a few weeks ago. It was ok. I was glad we weren't footing the bill because I would not have spent that much money! I think it is overpriced for what you get and the service/atmosphere is average. Sorry I dont have anything to add on the Carltun but good luck in your search!
This discussion has been closed.
Choose Another Board
Search Boards
"
"